3 ms·
You keep saying that prison deters public order offences. It clearly doesn't. I'm curious why you think it does?
by DanBC 11y ago
You keep saying that prison deters public order offences. It clearly doesn't. I'm curious why you think it does?
- DougN7 11y agoHow can you say it clearly doesn't? Sure it doesn't deter ALL but none?
- DanBC 11y agoHave you ever chosen not to do something because you want to avoid prison? Or is there other stuff that's stopping you from breaking laws?
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoIt only takes one, for public order to dissolve.
- aninhumer 11y agoOf course, most people are socialised not to even consider breaking most laws, but that only happens because they live in a lawful society. When you see people around you breaking the rules, you feel much less obliged to keep them.
- DanBC 11y agoBut I'm not calling for a lawless society. You can have rule of law with minimal prison use. I'm not sure why people are thinking that I'm calling for an end to law.
- DougN7 11y agoI have chosen not to speed on a road that I know is heavily patrolled because I don't want the speeding ticket.
- whitegrape 11y agoI have. Of course I have my own personal code, as most every man does, but that does not always align with the law, and so where they conflict, rational calculations are made. I like to think that my code is good enough that in a society of just Mes we could get on well enough in anarchy, but there will never be a society of just Mes, there are lots of differing codes out there and the law helps ease tensions between them, plus my code certainly has flaws even if I can't change or see them yet.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoIn places where there is no civil authority, they have what resembles post-apocalyptic landscapes. We've not descended into that. So yes, enforcing public order has an effect. (And what about prison? Where did that come from?_
- eanzenberg 11y agoWhere is your evidence that prison doesn't deter petty crimes, burglary, rape, etc.?
- DanBC 11y agoYou make a good point, but I rather think the burden of evidence that prison is a deterrent rests on the people who recommend it, seeing as prison is a pretty significant interference with someone's human rights. I should say that I have no problem of prison for repeat violent criminals. Some people say that prison stops those people committing crime while they're in prison, but it doesn't even do that. Look at the rates of violent crime happening in US prisons (which I accept are unusual) to see evidence of that. There's not much evidence that a stay in prison stops a person from re-offending; it seems that there's a bunch of "psycho-social" stuff (housing, debt management, employment, education, drug and alcohol treatment) that would be more effective at stopping re-offending. (Or preventing crime). And do we really want to deprive someone of their liberty in prison for "petty crime"? I'm not sure what you mean about petty crime.