5 ms·
There's a very interesting thought experiment devised by the human rights lawyer Clive Stafford Smitg and outlined at the end of the excellent book "So You've B
by onion2k 11y ago
There's a very interesting thought experiment devised by the human rights lawyer Clive Stafford Smitg and outlined at the end of the excellent book "So You've Been Publicly Shamed" by Jon Ronson.
Quoting from the book;
“Let me ask you three questions,” he said. “And then you’ll see it my way. Question One: What’s the worst thing that you have ever done to someone? It’s okay. You don’t have to confess it out loud. Question Two: What’s the worst criminal act that has ever been committed against you? Question Three: Which of the two was the most damaging for the victim?”
The worst criminal act that has ever been committed against me was burglary. How damaging was it? Hardly damaging at all. I felt theoretically violated at the idea of a stranger wandering through my house. But I got the insurance money. I was mugged one time. I was eighteen. The man who mugged me was an alcoholic. He saw me coming out of a supermarket. “Give me your alcohol,” he yelled. He punched me in the face, grabbed my groceries, and ran away. There wasn’t any alcohol in my bag. I was upset for a few weeks, but it passed.
And what was the worst thing I had ever done to someone? It was a terrible thing. It was devastating for them. It wasn’t against the law.
Clive’s point was that the criminal justice system is supposed to repair harm, but most prisoners — young, black — have been incarcerated for acts far less emotionally damaging than the injuries we noncriminals perpetrate upon one another all the time — bad husbands, bad wives, ruthless bosses, bullies, bankers."
The point of it is that we punitively punish people for many crimes while doing things far worse at the same time. Should we really be putting someone in prison for burglary when there are people who rip millions of people off with legal price gouging or break up a family by cheating?
We should think and question the legal system, and what effect it has on people unfortunate enough to become embroiled in it. If the legal system is there to punish behaviour that isn't in the interest of society or to protect communities from those who'd harm them, are we actually punishing the right people?
It's a very deep question. Not something that HN will answer in a thread. I think it's worthwhile spending some time on though.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoCan't ignore in all that, the issue of public order. Going soft on bullies (which is what many smash-and-grab criminals may be) means it grows without limit. So establishing public order is not an optional thing.
- DanBC 11y agoYou keep saying that prison deters public order offences. It clearly doesn't. I'm curious why you think it does?
- DougN7 11y agoHow can you say it clearly doesn't? Sure it doesn't deter ALL but none?
- DanBC 11y agoHave you ever chosen not to do something because you want to avoid prison? Or is there other stuff that's stopping you from breaking laws?
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoIt only takes one, for public order to dissolve.
- aninhumer 11y agoOf course, most people are socialised not to even consider breaking most laws, but that only happens because they live in a lawful society. When you see people around you breaking the rules, you feel much less obliged to keep them.
- DanBC 11y agoBut I'm not calling for a lawless society. You can have rule of law with minimal prison use. I'm not sure why people are thinking that I'm calling for an end to law.
- DougN7 11y agoI have chosen not to speed on a road that I know is heavily patrolled because I don't want the speeding ticket.
- 11y ago
- nickff 11y agoYou should at least be comparing expected outcomes (if not worst possible outcomes) rather than actual outcomes. Especially because your thought experiment is subject to extreme (literal) survivorship bias; no murder victim will answer your hypothetical. Other crimes such as carjacking, which has a 50% death rate for the victim, should be punished very severely even if the victim survived. In addition, in cases where people do things like cheating, they could blame the 'victim' for actually filing for divorce, and not being more forgiving. The divorce filing could be seen as much more damaging to children than the actual cheating, unless you try to instate some sort of negligence standard for 'immoral' activities. Another interesting case might be a child 'coming out' as homosexual when their parents are very religious and consider homosexuality a sin; is the child not inflicting harm here? Is honesty (or lack thereof) more troubling to you than threatening a fellow human being with disability or death?
- bambax 11y agoI think the point of the parent is not that we should punish more, it's that we should punish less: since we don't punish grave misbehaviors that have dire consequences but are technically not illegal, why punish shoplifting?
- nickff 11y agoI do not address the question of what (absolute level of) punishment (if any) would be appropriate for any level of harm; I am offering a set of criticisms of the standard (, how harm could be measured and compared).
- DougN7 11y agoBut not punishing shoplifting is a non-starter. So if inflicting emotional pain is worse than mere property loss, and we want to keep things equal/relative, that means we start punishing for inflicting emotional pain. This whole line of reasoning leads to either anarchy or more punishment for arguably moral issues.
- ap22213 11y agoWhere'd you pull the 50% statistic? In the U.S. it seems it's more like fewer than 14 people die for every 38,000 carjackings.
- cousin_it 11y ago> Should we really be putting someone in prison for burglary when there are people who rip millions of people off with legal price gouging or break up a family by cheating? I agree that cheating usually hurts more than burglary. However, it's not just a question of how harmful it is, but also how many people feel the urge to do it. We can mostly deal with burglary by criminalizing it, but criminalizing cheating would be a disaster akin to the war on drugs.
- aninhumer 11y agoDepending on what exactly criminalisation means, I wonder if it wouldn't lead to far more openness about polyamory.
- sametmax 11y agoAnd again cheating is much greyer area than killing. The marriage, the wedding, being faithful are very artificial social constructs. I for once, would never, ever want somebody to be punished because she cheated on me. I may not like it, but I don't think the state has anything to do with it.
- ChoGGi 11y agoI was going to say that it is criminalised in South Korean, but I see they struck down that law last year. http://www.latimes.com/world/asia/la-fg-south-korea-adultery-legal-court-20150226-story.html http://www.latimes.com/world/asia/la-fg-south-korea-adultery... "The law called for sentences of up to two years in prison. Adultery cases were only heard when a spouse filed a complaint, and could be withdrawn at any time by that spouse."
- mc32 11y agoI don't think this kind of reductive thinking, if taken into more political and behavioral extreme areas works. Lets try this mental exercise, what is the physical damage to me if I get raped? In extreme cases one could get infected with a potentially deadly STD, or if a woman, onr may become pregnant, but in many cases at the physical level, it's not all that different from regular sex between people. The main difference is granting permission to sex, or not granting permission to sex. That makes all the difference, or most. So, you see, it's easy to break things down into oblivion, the thing is, this is what, in part, makes is human, why we don't follow the same kind of courtship other animals accept as part of nature. Or why otherwise rationalized behavior is not normally accepted. Restorative justice won't cut it here. I of course understand my example is extreme, but I simply want to point out that there is a point where these ideas break down as a solution to unjust sentencing.
- aninhumer 11y ago>what is the physical damage to you if you get raped? I don't think the parent was suggesting only physical damage be considered. They discussed several examples of emotional damage. EDIT: And I'm not really sure why you're calling their post reductive either, it seemed fairly nuanced, and ended with "It's a very deep question. Not something that HN will answer in a thread."
- eanzenberg 11y agoThe OP kind of was when they brushed away the burglary they experienced as, not much monetary loss and the lost feeling of security was back went away after a few weeks. To feel secure in one's home is f*&(ing important. I'm not equating it to rape, but it's that intangible feeling of lost of trust you cannot quickly brush away.
- whitegrape 11y agoEmotional damage is interesting. In many senses it's entirely one's own fault, if one feels emotionally damaged / offended / distraught. But it's an uncommon mental discipline to get yourself to feel differently. That intangible feeling of lost trust can be quickly brushed away, the OP is an example of that since they did it in weeks, similarly rape actually doesn't end up being a huge deal for some victims. But it's pretty weird to start drafting up policies (like "let's punish less 'cause come on, he just threatened you with a knife and took your wallet, he didn't actually hurt you and your material losses were only the cost to get a new wallet and the small time it took to cancel any credit cards") that would only work on a small portion of the population with a certain level of mental discipline. The fact that some have it to various degrees and some don't is enough to make any suggestion requiring it to be pointless unless that suggestion includes "and kill / severely culturally shame anyone who does not have the discipline".
- OJFord 11y agoIt's a bit interesting, but I don't think it's actually relevant to the OP. Reason #1: The vast majority of people haven't been victim to something that's put someone in prison anyway. Reason #2: At most, it would seem the 'solution' to the thought experiment is changes to legislation; not "scrap it all!"
- ChemicalWarfare 11y agoNot sure I follow. Are you saying robbers, rapists, carjackers, thieves, murderers, drunk drivers causing vehicular manslaughter etc etc should NOT be punished because some other "bad" behavior is not punishable by law in today's society?
- IsaacL 11y agoOne of the most damaging things Clive Stafford Smith has done is to give public support for Moazzem Begg, who was almost certainly a high-ranking member of al Qaeda (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moazzam_Begg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moazzam_Begg). (Sure, Begg should have gotten a fair trial -- he would have gone to court had the charges not been dropped, probably because the intelligence services didn't want to reveal all the intel they had gathered on him and his associates). In every human society in history, there have been people who choose to rob, rape and kill. There's no pleasant way to deal with such people, but it is the role of the state to deal with them, or you have anarchy. It isn't the role of the state to prevent "emotional damage", "bad wives" or "bankers". Stafford Smith's position seems to be a twisted version of Christian morality where all problems are caused by meanness. Since the justice system is an institutionalised form of meanness, it must be wicked -- indeed, it's probably responsible for crime and terrorism. This is a really evil worldview.
- onion2k 11y agoIn every human society in history, there have been people who choose to rob, rape and kill. There's no pleasant way to deal with such people, but it is the role of the state to deal with them, or you have anarchy. It isn't the role of the state to prevent "emotional damage", "bad wives" or "bankers". The point of the question (which is an interesting question regardless of who asked it) is that we should challenge what the role of the state is. We definitely shouldn't blindly or unquestioningly accept that the state is there to do one thing or the other, to deal with robbers and not bankers, because "that's the way it's always been" or something. That is how states attain power over citizens and we end up with things like the scandalous overreaching surveillance revealed by Snowden et al.
- IsaacL 11y agoWho said that we should? States have justified their actions by many different codes of ethics. I know my answer to the legitimate role of the state: to protect individual rights.
- albinofrenchy 11y ago
- Grishnakh 11y agoThis is a good question, but the direction he's going with it seems like it might be advocating throwing the baby out with the bathwater. It's true, we're not punishing the right people, and the people we punish are frequently being punished too much for comparatively minor crimes. The solution isn't to eliminate punishment, it's to fix the system so that the bigger criminals don't get away with their crimes because of their wealth and political connections. And for things that aren't against the law but are devastating, maybe we need to look at changing the law. However, even here, civil suits usually serve to deter such behavior: many things aren't technically "illegal", but they are actionable "torts", which you can sue people for. The McDonald's coffee case is a good example here, and shows why civil suits, though frequently derided, actually serve as a check on really bad behavior that doesn't have specific laws passed against it yet: McD's kept their coffee heated to dangerously-high temperatures, despite other people being injured by it in drive-thrus, and when it happened to this woman, she sued (wanting them to pay her medical bills, as she sustained serious burns) and won a very large punitive judgment as the jury felt that McD's was negligent. There's no law saying how hot coffee should be served (and that's likely to be micromanaging and not a good way to run society), but it is entirely possible to be sued for "negligence" when you do something that gets someone hurt, so there is a big incentive to not do that, and to make sure you don't seriously injure someone through your carelessness.
- krick 11y agoIt's only deep if you want it to be deep. In my opinion, it's as "deep" as any other meaningless question. As one in the title, by the way. Because the very assumption that legal system exists to help some commoner — you — seems absurd to me. It's not you who puts people in jail. It's not you who has the guns and manpower to maintain the existing regime and rules. It's not even you, who "feeds" those who have guns and manpower — regardless of what you think, you don't really chose to pay taxes, you just have to, because if you don't, then you are the "criminal" who must be punished. These questions seem deep (which actually translates to "without an obvious answer") only if you assume that you are choosing who should be punished, what is a crime and what is a punishment. Then, unsurprisingly, it is quite hard to explain rationally the current state of things — so that "your" choices would seem "right" enough. Because that's just not the case. But if you try to answer the question about "what is right" from the "Golem's" point of view — the legal system, the government, the "social norm" — it actually is pretty clear and simple. "Right" is what keeps it stable. Punishing somebody, who makes somebody else miserable doesn't really help it — it's ok for people to be miserable, it's not ok for them to turn on the Golem. It doesn't have to be rational or efficient, it doesn't have to help anybody or protect anybody. The moment it becomes something more than a mere human — and it long time is — it doesn't care for human needs or worries. Feeding murderers on behalf of other people, while keeping them in a closed institution doesn't really help anybody or is rational, it isn't about justice or whatever — it just works, it just keeps the system stable. On the other hand, people using psychedelic drugs and living in hippie communes doesn't hurt people, but hurts the system. That's why things are what they are.
- icebraining 11y ago- Government isn't about morality. - Really? What is it about? - Stability! Keeping things going. Preventing anarchy. Stopping society from falling to bits. Still being here tomorrow. - What for? - I beg your pardon? - What is the ultimate purpose of government, if it isn't for doing good? - Minister, government isn't about good and evil it's only about order, or chaos. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A-pj3mBscgo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A-pj3mBscgo
- smsm42 11y agoI think it's not about what is the worst, but about what is necessary. Ultimately, the idea is that there are some basic rules without which the society can not perform. The exact rules vary by culture, but in a Western culture they usually include murdering people, violating property rights, causing substantial bodily and emotional harm, defrauding or defaming someone, etc. Now, one has to admit our current legal system has gone way beyond that and subverted criminal justice system from "absolute necessities" to "things I love to force other people to do because I think they should be doing those things and too stupid to realize it" - and so we now prosecute people for setting wrong kind of plant on fire and inhaling the smoke, or for cutting other person's hair without consent of government employee, or for listening to a musical tune without paying to some corporation that is considering "owning" it, or for using the idea because somebody else thought about similar idea before and asked government employee to give them "ownership" of it. And so on. This all looks like abuse, but there's still the original idea behind it - the idea that there are some necessities underlying working society, and these necessities must be enforced. Not because each violation causes grave harm - but because multiple violations would snowball into set of consequences that would make our society very hard to live in. So if we go to the mugging example, let's assume we say "mugging is no problem, the police should not care about it, there's no harm done, especially compared to what Wall Street bankers are doing". Let's ignore even the facts that people are grievously hurt or murdered in muggings. But even beyond that - what happens if we declare free mugging season? First of all, more muggings - especially from people that are physically strong, imposing and have no moral problems with it. Then, people that are not so strong would try to defend themselves - e.g. by arming themselves. Then, muggers would arm themselves too, because they found the source of cheap income and are not going to give it up. Then you have two outcomes possible - either the non-muggers succeed, individually or collectively, in raising the potential price per mugging to level so high it's not worth it (i.e. if you are going to end up dead in 1/3 of mugging attempts, your mugging career is not going to be long) or you have situation where you're living in a warzone. Which some people learned to survive in, but would you want to get into such situation? In either case situation did not exactly improve - in the first case, you just create the police by other name, and probably more harsh to muggers than any current one (vigilantes have little use for Miranda rights and competitive trials) , in the second you get dramatic reduction in quality of life.
- Spooky23 11y agoThese examples (mugging, burglary) are serious crimes that have a lasting impact on most people. In addition, a place where mugging and burglary is happening without consequence has a really negative effect on the people there. Ask a black mother whose kids live in fear whether that guy who is mugging, robbing and breaking and entering belongs in jail. The punitive nature of arrest and jail makes the cost/benefit less attractive of capture looks like a high risk. (Example: NYC) We don't jail cheating spouses because society learned that moral turpitude as a crime creates other problems that society is struggling to move past. We don't effectively police many categories of white collar crime because the risk of capture is infinitesimal.
- force_reboot 11y agoOur legal system doesn't push "harm" per se, but rather harm caused unjustly[1]. E.g. it harms me a company raises the price of a product that happens to be in demand ("price gouging") but that company has every right to do so as it owns the product. One way we can reconcile the utilitarian notion of harm, with the property rights/natural rights approach is through economic theory. The so called "welfare theorems" of economics state that when every person maximizes their own utility (under the assumptions of a perfect market), then the result is pareto optimal. From this it follows that in a society with redistribution of wealth, no person has a right to complain that another person has "harmed" them by way how they behaved in the free market. Outside of the economic realm, the argument for natural rights is even stronger. How can you compare cheating, which is a consensual act, with robbery? At most cheating could be considered a violation of a contract, e.g. a prenuptial agreement. By completely ignoring the role of natural rights and property rights in the law and in moral reasoning, you are engaging in sophistry. [1] e.g. "[with developments such as the Model Penal Code] crime increasingly became conceptualized as the wrongful imposition of risk" (my emphasis) in "Making the Best of Felony Murder" http://www.bu.edu/law/journals-archive/bulr/documents/binder.pdf http://www.bu.edu/law/journals-archive/bulr/documents/binder...
- icebraining 11y agoE.g. it harms me a company raises the price of a product that happens to be in demand ("price gouging") but that company has every right to do so as it owns the product. Actually, 30+ US states have laws making "price gouging" illegal, though the definition isn't just that the product is in demand, but that there is also a state of emergency fueling that demand.
- superuser2 11y ago>I got the insurance money. >I was mugged one time Have you considered that muggings are rare and underwriting property insurance is rational because theft/burglary carries the risk of jail time?
- epx 11y agoMachiavelli said, the man forgets the loss of a father sooner than the loss of property. Imagine you worked 5 years to buy something and it is robbed. Isn't it emotional damage? Human rights people tend to separate rights in boxes, while in fact most rights are indeed human rights.
- epx 11y agoMachiavelli said, the man forgets the loss of a father sooner than the loss of property. Imagine you worked 5 years to buy something and it is robbed. Isn't it emotional damage? Human rights people tend to separate rights in boxes, while in fact most rights are indeed human rights.
- bmm6o 11y agoIt's very considerate of the burglar to only choose victims who have insurance! I'm sure the insurance company was happy to pay out. I hope you can still afford it when premiums go up with the increased crime rate that follows unpunished crimes.