3 ms·
Sure, the primary burden of proof is on those proposing a change. However, any time you stand up and make an argument, the burden is on you to make sure it actu
by andrewflnr 11y ago
Sure, the primary burden of proof is on those proposing a change. However, any time you stand up and make an argument, the burden is on you to make sure it actually makes sense, and that goes for both sides.
- pg_is_a_butt 11y agouh, both sides did make sense... they're also both irrelevant. you want to remake all stop lights to never turn green unless a sensor says no cars are approaching the intersection over 5 mph? ok, so you spend a trillion dollars and update every single stoplight everywhere... then the sensors start failing, things are worse, and more people die. what we have now works... the last thing we need is more rust in the infrastructure.
- viraptor 11y agoThis is getting a bit meta, but I disagree. It would be trivial to abuse in discussions. A: Bash would be way better for SQLite, really! B: But Bash is a terrible choice because X, Y, Z, ... A: If you make those arguments, you have to prove them.
- lotyrin 11y ago"Bash would be terrible because using it would cause a fire" Yes, arguments have a burden to make sense, and provide evidence...
- pg_is_a_butt 11y agook, so if you think it won't cause a fire, then do it in your own garage. when your garage catches on fire, let me know... i rebuild garages.
- andrewflnr 11y agoI'm not sure I take your point. If X, Y, and Z are cogent enough to be worth a rational response, B has done their job under my principle above. A is precisely the one I would want to yell at for using specious arguments.
- coliveira 11y agoAnything that is stated without proof can be refuted without proof. Why you think your opinion should be regarded at a higher standard than anybody else's?
- andrewflnr 11y ago...I don't. That's sort of my point. Both sides of a debate have the same responsibility to be reasonable, whatever that level of responsibility may be, whether it's a formal debate or just tossing ideas around.