3 ms·
I've used this in teaching a class before as an example of a computer vision API...it's important to understand what it does not do...it doesn't have a huge voc
by danso 11y ago
I've used this in teaching a class before as an example of a computer vision API...it's important to understand what it does not do...it doesn't have a huge vocabulary of trained words...and just a couple of months ago, what it was trained on was...not very optimal for showing off the product.
For example, this image of President Obama on the phone at his desk:
https://farm2.staticflickr.com/1445/24129414022_f89da8ea52_b_d.jpg https://farm2.staticflickr.com/1445/24129414022_f89da8ea52_b...
--- currently is interpreted by Watson's API as "90% person"...a month ago, when I was demoing the product, it also returned "person"...but a whole variety of other things too...most notably, "Flag Burning"...it's only when you dive into the API and request a list of default classifiers did you see that the API contained a lot of specific terms, but was by no means comprehensive...so "Flag Burning" had been trained, but not just "Flag". It seems they've cut down the vocabulary at this point, which is good, because it shouldn't be judged against APIs that purport to do face/celebrity recognition and have been trained for that.
I think the key advantage of this API is that it's the only one that I had seen that allowed you to build your own classifier. Here's an example I found in the wild, of someone building a classifier to differentiate between M1A1 Abrams tanks and...non-Abrams tanks (you upload a set of positive and negative images to the API):
http://cmadison.me/2015/12/03/classifying-tanks-with-the-ibm-visual-recognition-service/ http://cmadison.me/2015/12/03/classifying-tanks-with-the-ibm...
Here are some quick notes I wrote for my class...I have no idea if they apply exactly today:
https://github.com/compciv/watson-preview https://github.com/compciv/watson-preview
And here's a example of the Watson classifiers performing on sample White House images:
http://stash.compciv.org/samples/watson-preview/printout.html http://stash.compciv.org/samples/watson-preview/printout.htm...
My favorite is the pic of Obama and the Pope, of which the top classifier is "Coffee_Maker -- 0.681709"
http://stash.compciv.org/samples/watson-preview/pics/popehouse.jpg http://stash.compciv.org/samples/watson-preview/pics/popehou...
Now...the image is classified as: 99% Person, and 80% wedding...which, actually, isn't the worst guess :)
- salyssasimpson 11y agoAccuracy with visual recognition is in the eye of the beholder. If you're looking for something specific in a photo, best to train your own classifier. For example - picture of a dog could be correctly tagged in several ways "dog" "puppy" "my dog spot" "color: brown" all can be accurate descriptions of the photo - but it comes back to how do you want to take action with the information.