5 ms·
This is very very weak grounds for any sort of lawsuit. But if having glanced at GPL source code prevents implementing similar functionalities in an entirely d
by epistasis 11y ago
This is very very weak grounds for any sort of lawsuit.
But if having glanced at GPL source code prevents implementing similar functionalities in an entirely different language, that's a pretty darn strong argument for me to never look at GPL code again.
- ktRolster 11y agoIf you're not trying to copy someone else's product, then you're probably ok
- dublinben 11y ago>that's a pretty darn strong argument for me to never look at GPL code again This is only an issue if your derivative work is under a different license.
- TheCoelacanth 11y agoCan you guarantee that you will never write a piece of software under a non-GPL license for the rest of your life? I certainly can't and I suspect that few programmers other than RMS can.
- jordigh 11y ago> This is very very weak grounds for any sort of lawsuit. Not according to the lawyers who have advised us GNU Octave developers to never read Matlab source code.
- jahewson 11y agoYour lawyers are peddling FUD because they make money that way. "Hey, it looks like you need another legal agreement, can't be too safe!" The reality is that an "unintentional copying" claim against source code makes for a very weak lawsuit and it's close to unimaginable that such a case would even make it into a court room. You're free to read whatever you like. Don't let anybody tell you otherwise.
- jordigh 11y ago> Your lawyers are peddling FUD because they make money that way. No, the SFLC works pro-bono. > You're free to read whatever you like. I wish that were true, but many current laws say otherwise. You do not sound like you are aware of those laws, so I take it you're not a lawyer. You're just hoping the world is as free as you say it is. I wish it were too, but we have to be pragmatic and work in the world we have while we strive for the world we want.
- jahewson 11y agoSigh... I feel like I'm not getting through to you here. Yes your layer works pro-bono but the rest of the time he works for money, and his entire conception of legal advice revolves around that. What's good for the goose is good for the gander: Your lawyer isn't paid to understand the law. He's paid to protect you from other lawyers. And other lawyers peddle FUD, so your lawyer has to protect you against FUD. Of course he's going to advise you to protect yourself! And if you've got an aggressive adversary, then you probably should. But you don't need to protect yourself. You're legally allowed to read stuff and write something similar. Just don't copy it. > I wish that were true, but many current laws say otherwise I'm going to disregard this statement (and it's conspicuous lack of citations) because you're not a lawyer :) > You're just hoping the world is as free as you say it is. No, I'm just reading Wikipedia: Clean room design is usually employed as best practice, but not strictly required by law. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clean_room_design#Examples https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clean_room_design#Examples
- npizzolato 11y agoYou're giving a lot of strongly-worded advice/opinions on legal issues in this thread. Are you a lawyer? Can you point to any case-law to back up what you're saying? I'm not a lawyer, and I don't really know who's right in this thread, but I'd find any citations you have really interesting to read.
- jahewson 11y agoHere's an crazy thought: when lawyers are in court, one of them is always wrong. Imagine that. A lawyer being wrong. Mind blown. Is your lawyer a software engineer? If not, he doesn't know anything! He has literally no idea. He can't even comprehend software. It would melt his brain. So you ask, how can I the holder of meagre so-called "Computer Science PhD", comprehend the the holy (and unspeakable) knowledge of those who have spent an unimaginable three years studying law? Who am I to question our very gods? Well, sir, I give you "The Wikipedia": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clean_room_design#Examples https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clean_room_design#Examples Perhaps we should have it destroyed for spreading the "unspeakable" knowledge, rightfully known only by our lawyer-priests and spoken amongst them in their own tongue.