4 ms·
The speculation that, on Sunday night, some security researcher was able to convince the FBI they had a good shot at cracking the phone defies belief. A simple
by Zigurd 11y ago
The speculation that, on Sunday night, some security researcher was able to convince the FBI they had a good shot at cracking the phone defies belief.
A simpler and more likely explanation is that the FBIs lawyers, having overreached, have gone back on an earlier lie and concocted a new lie: Oh yeah, we need just a couple weeks to try this out. (And for the furore to die down.)
Don't let these little John Yoos off the hook. They are over-aggressive, unethical, and unprofessional.
- hockeybias 11y ago'overly aggressive'.
- mikeash 11y agoI think it's more likely to be a mix. The FBI knew for a while, if not from the beginning, that getting into the phone without Apple's help was feasible. The NAND mirroring technique described here has been floating around for a while. But the FBI didn't want to, either because they have ulterior motives in forcing Apple's cooperation or because they just didn't want to take the risk of breaking anything. Now that they're having so much trouble securing Apple's cooperation, they either think the alternative is worth trying, or at least find it to be a good excuse for stopping.
- jessaustin 11y agoWhat you say is plausible. Can it be shown by outside parties what FBI knew and when? If so, it seems a fair bet that several agents and lawyers perjured themselves/suborned perjury in their zeal to "win" at all costs.
- mikeash 11y agoWe know they were aware of the attack no later than three weeks ago, when Congressman Issa brought it up during the FBI's congressional hearing on the matter. Of course, that doesn't mean they took it seriously, but I'd say they should have, given that Issa described it in great detail. In fact the FBI director said they'd check into it. Of course, that could just be meaningless pleasantries meant to placate someone in power. The timing certainly is suggestive, though.