5 ms·
I think investing in explosives detection is a better approach. It is an irony that there were explosions at the airport while they are screening you completely
by wslh 11y ago
I think investing in explosives detection is a better approach. It is an irony that there were explosions at the airport while they are screening you completely before boarding a flight.
- BFatts 11y agoThey don't scan for explosives until you're going through security. If they had the security checkpoint at the entrance to the airport: a) People would bitch more because it would take forever to get into an airport. And, b) It isn't practical. What's next, stopping you at your car or bus before you park? People demand security but don't want inconvenience. And if security fails, they point and say "it's ineffective." Even if it stops 80% of attacks, unless it's 100% people will bitch. AND if there aren't any attacks, can they really claim that they stopped one unless they publicly acknowledge every attempted attack?
- adrianratnapala 11y agoIt gets worse, since in this case it's not even a trade-off between convenience and security. In Sri Lanka they had (and perhaps still have) security scanning at the entrance to the terminal. As a result people have to bunch up outside the terminal, making them even more vulnerable than they otherwise would be. Any true improvements would have to come from streamlined pre-screening, e.g. chemical detectors (or dogs?) in the concourse sniffing things out without making people stop or bunch up. Hard to do.
- jonatanheyman 11y agoAccording to BBC the explosion are believed to have been in the checkin area, i.e. outside of the security screening.
- ekianjo 11y agoThis is a clear weakness of airports: where people regroup even before reaching the terminal, with no surveillance or security checks whatsoever. And that's not just in Brussels.
- Thriptic 11y agoYeah I don't think this is easily mitigated short of increasing throughput through check in / security so that you never have large groups of people standing around.
- ptaipale 11y agoAnd of course not just in airports. Train stations, buses, markets, theatres, concerts (Balaclan), anything you have in city life where people gather together. Metros and mass transit are generally the most lucrative target, as we see here, and as we saw in London 10 years ago.
- cm2187 11y agoBut why should checkin areas be more protected than any bakery, bus stop or supermarket, any place where people gather. One can't (and shouldn't) put policemen at every corner of every street.
- eonwe 11y agoOnly place I've seen some security checks was at Ben Gurion airport in Tel Aviv, where there was a mild security check when entering the airport. This consisted of a small interview on what I've been doing in Israel, where I am going to, with whom and who packed my stuff. This all was before even entering the actual terminal building.
- compactmani 11y agoI see Europe in the future adopting many of the (some call paranoid) security measure of Israel. For example security checks before entering all malls.
- mrblueblue 11y agoIn Paris, there are security checks at entrances to malls and big stores now.
- dchesterton 11y ago
- balabaster 11y agoGet dogs trained to detect explosives patrolling all areas of the airport and I'm not sure what they're called, but they have these sniffer devices at the CN tower where they basically make you walk through a large hairdryer and it sniffs the residue blown off you for chemical signatures. It's not perfect, but a combination of those two things any place where you have large volumes of people congregating would surely yield an above average result. The dogs alone I would wager would be an efficient response - they're portable, don't take up much room and can clamber over all kinds of obstacles.
- mistermann 11y agoPerhaps, but then bombs could just be detonated in open public squares, playgrounds, etc - it's actually surprising they're not.
- danieldk 11y agoIndeed, you cannot protect any place when more than a few people gather. You have to stop the issues at their source: why did people who were born and raised in Europe radicalize in just one or two years? And why did the community they lived in not see or report that this was happening?
- cavilatrest 11y agoWhile I agree, I think we can admit that doing so will take some time. Would it not be appropriate to have compensating controls in the meantime?
- oneeyedpigeon 11y agoThe trouble is, temporary compensating controls have a history of becoming permanent once in place, so you need to be absolutely sure you want those controls forever.
- cavilatrest 11y ago
- dinosaurs 11y agoIndeed, the explosions were in the checkin area. I was there last week and there's a couple of armed soldiers in the area, but you can walk right in without any security screening.
- crispyambulance 11y agoExplosives detection is a perfectly worthy thing to do. Unfortunately, by the time there's a bomb at the airport, it is too late unless "James Bond" is on the scene. The core issues here need to be addressed.
- SonicSoul 11y agowhy is it too late? it can still save many lives even if there is a 5 min notice
- crispyambulance 11y agoIt is "too late" if you want to actually solve the problem of terrorist organizations blowing up people at airports. Yes, we should have security and even bomb detection tech in select public places... but that's secondary to what needs to be done to fix this mess.
- Zigurd 11y agoMany commonplace chemicals, such as hand sanitizer, confound the explosives detectors used at airports. Dogs can only work a very limited time before their sense of smell gets fatigued. Moreover, the bomb was set off outside the secure area. It is VERY likely that existing security measures got more people killed because there are dense crowds waiting to clear security. This exact type of attack, outside the secure area, was predicted long ago. And there you have it.
- twoodfin 11y agoWithout better information on the whereabouts of the explosion, it's hard to draw any conclusions. But from the photos I've seen, any crowds targeted by the bomber(s) would not have been due to security lines, but rather the densely packed lines at the various airline checkin desks. Unlike most American airports, where broad desks face the outer wall, at Zaventem they're arranged in facing rows like booths at a convention. Any security lines are actually past passport control, and I've never seen them particularly packed.
- Zigurd 11y agoSo perhaps the security lines need to be outside the check-in area? See what I did there?
- nikcub 11y agoI just happen to have a conversation with Matt Ocko, a venture capitalist, about this on Twitter tonight: https://twitter.com/mattocko/status/712227775805988864 https://twitter.com/mattocko/status/712227775805988864 TATP (acetone peroxide), the type of improvised explosive favored by terrorists because of the easy access to ingredients, is uniquely difficult to detect but there have been some recent advances in this area [0] Most of these attackers use vests that carry 2-10kg of TATP, or backpacks with 10+ kilograms. They are required to load these devices up and travel to their designated target, the hope is that with explosive detection you could pick these guys up or minimize casualties in the same way you could identify a gunman on CCTV. It wouldn't be a panacea - but it could form part of a broader set of new tech to assist with these cases [0] http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0925400511010161 http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0925400511...