6 ms·
How Do You Say “Life” in Physics?
- javajosh 11y agoAll persistent dynamic structures are fundamentally circular motion. And there has to be an energy gradient to drive the motion against the resistence that is required to reproduce. So, imagine a torus in a bath of molecules such that the torus rotates in proportion to the flux of light through it's hole. The torus rotates not like a steering wheel, but around itself (called poloidal rotation), such that the inside squeezes together and the outside expands. This might catch molecules from the surrounding bath, expanding the torus, changing it's shape. It would also tend to change it's relationship to incident light. At some point, the torus could "shed" a second torus, roughly equal to it's original, smaller shape, which would participate with the environment in the same way, aggregating energy and matter to reproduce itself, until either all light is consumed, all free matter is consumed, or both. Anyway, I'm not sure if this is all that realistic - but I think it captures the important quality of "life" when it comes to physics, mainly that life is circular motion that has the general character of memory and reproduction.
- alanwatts 11y ago>life is circular motion that has the general character of memory and reproduction. This is totally random but that bit reminded me of a quote from Black Elk Speaks: >Everything the Power of the World does is done in a circle. The sky is round, and I have heard that the earth is round like a ball, and so are all the stars. The wind, in its greatest power whirls. Birds make their nest in circles, for theirs is the same religion as ours. The sun comes forth and goes down again in a circle. The moon does the same and both are round. Even the seasons form a great circle in their changing, and always come back again to where they were. The life of a man is a circle from childhood to childhood, and so it is in everything where power moves. Our tepees were round like the nests of birds, and these were always set in a circle, the nation's hoop.
- javajosh 11y agoThat's lovely, but my meaning is a little more specific and technical, and comes from the singular observation that Life cannot be constructed from unbounded linear motion. The sun shines on the planet, making things move, but gravity pulls it all down again. It's only "circular" in the same sense that a human can be approximated by a sphere of water. P.S. Would really like to know why the downvote.
- trhway 11y agonon-live systems follow the entropy maximization gradient, ie. they maximize entropy only locally. Live systems increase entropy beyond that is possible by only following the gradient, ie. live systems maximize the total entropy integrated over whole space-time path of the given system.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mathgenius 11y agoThe Nature article is here: http://www.englandlab.com/uploads/7/8/0/3/7803054/nnano.2015.250__1_.pdf http://www.englandlab.com/uploads/7/8/0/3/7803054/nnano.2015...
- rumcajz 11y agoCan somebody explain what does Wittgenstein have to do with the whole thing?
- danharaj 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Language-game_(philosophy) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Language-game_(philosophy) Contrast with his ideas in the Tractatus Logico-philosophicus, his first great work, where he boldly (arrogantly?) claimed that all philosophical problems are pseudo-problems caused by misuse of language.
- jveld 11y agoIt seemed to me like the author of the article was playing a bit loose with Wittgenstein's ideas. Isn't the idea that gravity is merely a "translation" of the curvature of spacetime an example of precisely the kind of Tractatus-speak that the language game idea was meant to demolish? Or am I missing something.
- danharaj 11y agoThe idea the author seems to try to hint at is what i would call a Functor if we were talking about Categories: - Language games have structure - Structures can be compared by correspondences/functions - A particular concept in one language game therefore could be transported along such a correspondence into another language game. - We don't have a good correspondence between the language games of biology and physics that allows us to transport "life" from biology to physics. - Or do we!??? P.S. It occurs to me that my analogy with categories and functors is itself a transport between the language game of category theory and the language game of language games.
- jveld 11y ago> It occurs to me that my analogy with categories and functors is itself a transport between the language game of category theory and the language game of language games. Bahahahahaha! Brilliant. If I remember my category theory correctly, wouldn't this mean that you've discovered a Monad between the language game of category theory and the language game of language games? If so, we could create the most incomprehensible monad tutorial yet written! Now there's a real achievement.
- jveld 11y ago> For instance, there is no English translation for the Japanese wabi-sabi—the idea of finding beauty in imperfection—or for the German waldeinsamkeit, the feeling of being alone in the woods. Writers who proclaim that English has no translation for word x from language y, only to provide a matter-of-fact translation in the very next clause/sentence always make me chuckle. Or they provoke pedantic ire. Depends on how much sleep I've had. :p
- jmcmichael 11y agoword != phrase
- jon_richards 11y agoThere aren't translations for a lot of German words then...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- chatmasta 11y agoThere is no such thing as "word" and "phrase" distinction across languages. There are only ideas. In written Mandarin, for example, there are only pictographic characters. Each single character translates to an English word or phrase, but which it translates to is completely arbitrary. It is extremely anglocentric to say "English doesn't have a word" for a given Chinese character, if in fact English has a phrase for it. The Chinese language has no obligation to translate each character succinctly into a single English word. In fact, one of the greatest strengths of pictographic languages is the high degree of information density per character. More often than not, a pictograph will translate to an English phrase, not an English word. For native Chinese readers, inference comes naturally, as each character is built out of a set of "radicals," each representing a narrowly defined idea, that act as the primitive building blocks to convey a complex combination of their ideas within one "character." It's the ideas that matter.
- jhedwards 11y ago
- noobie 11y agoAh, Nautilus at it again. One of my favorite magazines! Any other proud subscribers out thete?
- tbabb 11y agoI am often disappointed with Nautilus. I find it tends to tout lofty or revolutionary ideas, and frosts them with intellectual prose, but underneath the article is surprisingly vague, content-free, and/or unscientific.
- grayje 11y agoAddy Pross wrote a similar paper in 2011, but the neologism then was "dynamic kinetic stability" https://aeon.co/essays/paradoxes-of-stability-how-life-began-and-why-it-can-t-rest https://aeon.co/essays/paradoxes-of-stability-how-life-began... http://www.bgu.ac.il/~pross/PDF-10.pdf http://www.bgu.ac.il/~pross/PDF-10.pdf http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3843823/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3843823/ The upshot is that life is its own state of matter, essentially a self-stabilizing repeating pattern of matter and energy, like a waterfall or a chemical clock.
- agumonkey 11y agoKinda reminds me of the old teleology.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jheriko 11y agoIt's a shame there is a huge lack of technical details here... maybe there is a profound thing that has been discovered, but I can't tell because the article is vague and describes the mundane and obvious in a grandiose style.
- d02 11y agoI wish they would put actual content in bold for those of us who aren't sure it's worth it to wade through the endless fluff.
- mchahn 11y agoMy understanding of "life" has changed since I learned how biology at a low enough level is mechanical. A virus is a mechanical structure with nothing that we normally consider "alive". It arrives at a cell by accident, and its mechanical structure happens to interact with the surroundings to literally drill into the cell and then interact with its contents, again mechanically.
- tbabb 11y agoThis seems to be a really overcomplicated re-stating of Darwin. There is no "lower level" at which to explain it: Things that are good at making copies of themselves will tend to be more prolific. Restating Darwin in terms of thermodynamics takes a simple idea and complicates it without adding explanatory power, which makes it a poor theory. Here is how you "say 'Life' in physics": Life is a pattern which obeys four rules: - Reproduction: The pattern makes copies of itself. - Inheritance: The copies share traits of the original. - Variation: The copies can be different from the original. - Selection: The success of the pattern making more copies depends on the traits which it inherits. That's it. A tree is alive. A person is alive. A stone is not alive. A virus is alive. And an idea is alive. It is a pattern in matter which replicates (I can tell you an idea; now there's one in my head AND your head), it inherits (your idea is similar to mine), it varies (you may reinterpret the idea, or combine it with your own ideas), and it selects (you will spread ideas you think are good, and discard those you think are bad). From this arises technology, or religion. We may, with a twist of the mind, think of either as an organism in its own right living in the habitat of human consciousness. (Perhaps all of our species' success can be attributed to the fact that our brains support a symbiotic form of life which can adapt far, far faster than DNA can). And so by this definition even a solar panel is alive (and the "problem" of physically differentiating the two evaporates); it is just a stranger form of life that spends part of its existence as the plans for its production, coded in the configuration of matter in its blueprints, computer files, and human brains; and whose life cycle includes a stage where it is physically manifests and makes it self useful to its human hosts by providing them electricity. Its design is copied and mutated; some better at providing power for less effort, and thus more likely to propagate and eventually out-compete weaker designs.