3 ms·
No, it was removed because it "used 5MB for every change". I also wish for an app that would defy reality, but, until then, telling a server who your friends ar
by StavrosK 11y ago
No, it was removed because it "used 5MB for every change". I also wish for an app that would defy reality, but, until then, telling a server who your friends are so it can check, without telling it who your friends are, is a hard problem to solve.
- tveita 11y agoThere is nothing reality defying about meeting up and exchanging keys in person. Unfortunately, that's a use case the Signal UI goes out of its way to discourage. It's not like they don't know how, copying Threema's UI would be a massive improvement. Hell, even Snapchat lets you add a friend by scanning their screen, it's not like it's some user hostile ivory tower feature.
- StavrosK 11y agoSignal does too. We're talking about contact discovery, not key verification. Contact discovery is the problem of, given a list of contacts, returning the ones that are on the service. Contact discovery without the server seeing the list of contacts is hard.
- newman314 11y agoGiven that the way Signal presents contacts is suboptimal too (contacts showing up irregardless if they have Signal installed only someone else uploaded said contact), I'd rather have a mode where I have to manually exchange contact info until such time secure contact exchange is solved.