2 ms·
Only if the code is trivial. Max/MSP and PD are the goto products here. https://cycling74.com/max7/ https://cycling74.com/max7/ They're incredibly horrible f
by TheOtherHobbes 11y ago
Only if the code is trivial.
Max/MSP and PD are the goto products here.
https://cycling74.com/max7/ https://cycling74.com/max7/
They're incredibly horrible for anything complicated. Even a simple for loop requires multiple clicks to select the modules you need, multiple lines of typing to set their parameters, and multiple mouse movements to define the connections. It literally takes about around ten times longer than typing.
Neither handles encapsulation elegantly and transparently. (Max 7 is the best effort yet, but it's still not pain free.)
They have some nice DSP features for building DSP chains, and as long as you stick with those they're useful. But they're an instant nightmare if you try to do anything with logic that would be trivial in written code.
Reaktor doesn't compare because it just does the DSP thing. It's a very simple pipeline.
The takeaway is that simple module composition is easy, but non-trivial logic flows with many data types can be very challenging indeed.