4 ms·
Lots of people here are talking about skewing search results, but it doesn't seem like we have any evidence Google did that. All the email says they did was cre
by gpm 11y ago
Lots of people here are talking about skewing search results, but it doesn't seem like we have any evidence Google did that. All the email says they did was create a tool to visualize data, and give it to the press.
The article linked talks about a few other things Google did, but the closest they get to manipulating search results is putting “Live! Secretary Kerry answers questions on Syria. Today via Hangout at 2pm ET.” on the homepage below the search box. A politically neutral statement advertising a unique source of (biased) information, and their own product. This is the moral equivalent of reddit advertising an AMA with Obama, or Elon Musk as far as I can see.
- vonklaus 11y agoI am not making the claim that lack of evidence is proof, but there really isn't a control group for "unbiased results". - people see different results. - countries see different results - all search engines use page rank and model results of google Without a whistleblower, or someone literally searching millions of things with a battery of diagnostics (which google would notice) it would be hard. Either way, it doesn't matter. Google (cobsolidation) is one of the bigger risks we face now.
- vonklaus 11y agoEdit: Maybe it is thread based selection bias, but I have been consistently stating this and more developed versions of this threat model and consistently get downed. If anyone sees this and votes on my above comment (either direction) I would be curious to get thoughts on Google, search engines, or general winner take all/consolidation dynamics in tech
- nostrademons 11y agoThis was a very different branch of Google than Search. The email was from Jared Cohen, who I had to look up to verify that he even worked at Google (apparently, he left the State Department in 2010 to become a director at Google Ideas). I never saw so much as an email or presentation while I was at Google; my understanding is that he operated in a siloed part of Google (now Alphabet) whose mission specifically was to spread democracy across the world: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jigsaw_(company) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jigsaw_(company)
- dTal 11y agoOh boy, lots of hackle-words in that. "Think tank", "global challenges", "US State Department"...
- tamana 11y ago"Google Ideas" is a rather creepy name for a company whose mission is international propaganda. I guess it's good thhey changed it to Jigsaw to reduce tarnish to the Google brand. Funny that Alphabet sold Boston Dynamics because people think robots are scary, but doesn't mind keeping the international intrigue division.