7 ms·
WikiLeaks: “Hillary Emails: Google Tried to Boost Assad Defections”
- mgraczyk 11y agoThe map discussed in the email, for those interested. http://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/interactive/syriadefections/2012730840348158.html?utm_content=automate&utm_campaign=Trial6&utm_source=NewSocialFlow&utm_term=plustweets&utm_medium=MasterAccount http://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/interactive/syriadefections...
- gbuk2013 11y ago"In collaboration with: movements.org" - in Assange's article[1] about his meeting with Eric Schmidt he mentions: --- Gen Next also backs an NGO, launched by Cohen toward the end of his State Department tenure, for bringing internet-based global “pro-democracy activists” into the US foreign relations patronage network. The group originated as the “Alliance of Youth Movements” with an inaugural summit in New York City in 2008 funded by the State Department and encrusted with the logos of corporate sponsors. [...] In 2011, the Alliance of Youth Movements rebranded as “Movements.org.” In 2012 Movements.org became a division of “Advancing Human Rights,” a new NGO set up by Robert L. Bernstein after he resigned from Human Rights Watch (which he had originally founded) because he felt it should not cover Israeli and US human rights abuses. Advancing Human Rights aims to right Human Rights Watch’s wrong by focusing exclusively on “dictatorships.” Cohen stated that the merger of his Movements.org outfit with Advancing Human Rights was “irresistible,” pointing to the latter’s “phenomenal network of cyberactivists in the Middle East and North Africa.” He then joined the Advancing Human Rights board, which also includes Richard Kemp, the former commander of British forces in occupied Afghanistan. In its present guise, Movements.org continues to receive funding from Gen Next, as well as from Google, MSNBC, and PR giant Edelman, which represents General Electric, Boeing, and Shell, among others. --- Fascinating stuff - a glimpse into the murky world of international politics for someone like me who generally has no idea. [1] https://wikileaks.org/google-is-not-what-it-seems/ https://wikileaks.org/google-is-not-what-it-seems/
- progressive_dad 11y agoGoogle, The Bill and Melinda Gates foundation, and Edelman all strongly courted Obama staffers in 2012 during and after the election. There are many close ties between these companies and the current administration. It wouldn't surprise me a bit if movements.org was simply another funnel for these organizations to continue to splash money and favors in their direction. How depressing would it be to know your job and existence is basically a bribe, with no expectation to make a meaningful contribution to the world? I'm picturing some enterprising recent college graduate thinking they're going there to change the world and getting laughed out of the room after laying out a plan to make them more effective. I need a shower just thinking about it.
- tamana 11y agoSo your idea is that companies give money to employee Y of X, as a bribe to X (who likes the company better because they game X money), and that's bad because Y is somehow unable to use money effectively, but X is able to use money effectively?
- jnaour 11y agoMade me thinks of the last season of House of Cards. Really a good one, really neat and engaged in some aspect like Reign by Terror, Manufacturing consent using search engine, relation with Russia... One of other HN article is about Facebook data used for social studies. If you are not paying for it, you're not the customer; you're the product being sold.
- baldfat 11y ago> If you are not paying for it, you're not the customer; you're the product being sold. I hear this all the time but it's message is a bit off. I'll quote this page http://powazek.com/posts/3229 http://powazek.com/posts/3229 1) Assumption: This is new or unique to the internet 2) Assumption: You’re either the product or the customer 3) My Favorite - Assumption: Companies you pay treat you better (Comcast Anyone?)
- golergka 11y agoWell — is there anyone who would paint Google as bad guys because of this? How and why?
- adwf 11y agoThis particular incident? No. It's the fact that they're doing this kind of thing at all is the problem. People have been worrying for years about the filter bubble that Google put you in; could you imagine if they tried to skew the US election? This document provides some evidence that they've certainly been thinking along those lines.
- golergka 11y agoJared Cohen is a director of Google Ideas, now called Jigsaw under Alphabet. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jigsaw_(company) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jigsaw_(company) The email is lacking context, but it appears that they gather data from open sources, not from some sinister surveillance program. And they use this data in open partnership with Al Jazeera. And the company itself is not the main "Google" that is tied to search an ads, but was launched, at inception, as "global technology think-tank". So I see no relationship between what's discussed in these emails and hypothetical scenarios you're describing.
- akerro 11y ago>Jared Cohen is the President of Jigsaw and an Adjunct Senior Fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations.[3] Previously, he served as a member of the Secretary of State's Policy Planning Staff and as a advisor to Condoleezza Rice and later Hillary Clinton It looks like high tech in US is in relationship with politicians who promote war, warrant-less NSA spying and built torture programs http://www.drop-dropbox.com/ http://www.drop-dropbox.com/
- gbuk2013 11y agoAgain from Assange's article[1]: --- In fact, Cohen had moved to Google from the US State Department in 2010. He had been a fast-talking “Generation Y” ideas man at State under two US administrations, a courtier from the world of policy think tanks and institutes, poached in his early twenties. He became a senior advisor for Secretaries of State Rice and Clinton. At State, on the Policy Planning Staff, Cohen was soon christened “Condi’s party-starter,” channeling buzzwords from Silicon Valley into US policy circles and producing delightful rhetorical concoctions such as “Public Diplomacy 2.0.” On his Council on Foreign Relations adjunct staff page he listed his expertise as “terrorism; radicalization; impact of connection technologies on 21st century statecraft; Iran.” --- Good or evil is quite subjective, but there is a pretty clear connection to at least one presidential candidate. That article is a seriously interesting (and long) read, assuming that it's all true of course - it is not interesting enough for me to start digging for proofs! ;) [1] https://wikileaks.org/google-is-not-what-it-seems/ https://wikileaks.org/google-is-not-what-it-seems/
- wodenokoto 11y agoWhat is so bad about that map?
- austerity 11y agoNothing. But some people can't control their urge to cry wolf.
- cryoshon 11y agoA multinational corporation has decided to map defections in a civil war in order to encourage people to defect from the government. An evil government, sure-- but it's a company weighing in on one side of a war. It isn't within their mandate. Manipulation here means that manipulation elsewhere is possible.
- gcb0 11y agowell, even that would be OK of it was the company/owner desire. the crux here is that it was a government project, paid by your money, without your representation, and that it completely backfired.
- DominikR 11y agoI believe that this kind of behaviour will be the reason why the Internet as we know it and are used to it will end some day. We will have many island solutions with firewalls around them just to prevent foreign powers from interfering in internal political processes. For example I certainly do not like what Erdogan is doing in Turkey (cutting off Facebook and Twitter), but is he wrong when he is accusing foreign powers from trying to incite demonstrations or manipulate public opinion? I'm pretty sure he is not. Same goes for China, Russia and all the other countries that are implementing or already have finished implementing their own great firewall. There is no reason in the world why any country should ever accept this. (I doubt the US would ever accept China doing this to them) But there are also serious internal problems. For one Google could influence the US presidential elections by skewing search results and making certain candidates look bad and others good. I'm sure almost 100% of Google employees would never support such a thing, but when Google does this regarding Syria you can't really be sure that they wouldn't do this internally too.
- adrianN 11y agoI don't think restricting the flow of information because you don't trust people to interpret it correctly is morally okay. People have been influenced by other people since the dawn of language. Deciding by whom they can be influenced shouldn't be the state's concern.
- brbsix 11y agoWhy the downvotes? Are people really advocating for state censorship and propagandization? Perhaps the state has already achieved it's goals if this is so.
- saasyguy 11y agoThis kind of thing isn't new though. The Internet is just the latest means of communication with the public. Public opinion has, and still is, manipulated for good and bad via mass media, grassroots campaigning, bribery, agent provocateurs, etc., etc. Replace "internet" with "telephone" or "printing press" and your post would read the same. Governments always want to control their "internal political processes" and to achieve that they tend to block out anything that interferes, whether it be foreign governments or internal factions that run counter to their interests.
- gpm 11y agoLots of people here are talking about skewing search results, but it doesn't seem like we have any evidence Google did that. All the email says they did was create a tool to visualize data, and give it to the press. The article linked talks about a few other things Google did, but the closest they get to manipulating search results is putting “Live! Secretary Kerry answers questions on Syria. Today via Hangout at 2pm ET.” on the homepage below the search box. A politically neutral statement advertising a unique source of (biased) information, and their own product. This is the moral equivalent of reddit advertising an AMA with Obama, or Elon Musk as far as I can see.
- vonklaus 11y agoI am not making the claim that lack of evidence is proof, but there really isn't a control group for "unbiased results". - people see different results. - countries see different results - all search engines use page rank and model results of google Without a whistleblower, or someone literally searching millions of things with a battery of diagnostics (which google would notice) it would be hard. Either way, it doesn't matter. Google (cobsolidation) is one of the bigger risks we face now.
- vonklaus 11y agoEdit: Maybe it is thread based selection bias, but I have been consistently stating this and more developed versions of this threat model and consistently get downed. If anyone sees this and votes on my above comment (either direction) I would be curious to get thoughts on Google, search engines, or general winner take all/consolidation dynamics in tech
- nostrademons 11y agoThis was a very different branch of Google than Search. The email was from Jared Cohen, who I had to look up to verify that he even worked at Google (apparently, he left the State Department in 2010 to become a director at Google Ideas). I never saw so much as an email or presentation while I was at Google; my understanding is that he operated in a siloed part of Google (now Alphabet) whose mission specifically was to spread democracy across the world: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jigsaw_(company) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jigsaw_(company)
- Grue3 11y agoSo Google did something good for once?
- godgod 11y agoIsn't this Progressive corporatism? You have a corporation trying to overthrow a nations leader. How is google not part of the evil here?
- throwaway9ttt 11y agoFrom the original article: "The last forty years has seen a huge proliferation of think tanks and political NGOs whose purpose, beneath all the verbiage, is to execute political agendas by proxy." This is how powerful governments shape the world: 1. Create ideas (lies) 2. Get the press to constantly write those ideas 3. Change the truth Once the truth is shaped you can now do what you want. In fact you now have to do required things to keep your country safe. Examples: Millions of people unnecessarily dying in Iraq and Syria.