4 ms·
M(n) = floor[A^3^n] The above will give you primes, so long as A is filled in with the right constant. So, in a strange way, you might imagine A as number that
by whatshisface 11y ago
M(n) = floor[A^3^n]
The above will give you primes, so long as A is filled in with the right constant. So, in a strange way, you might imagine A as number that has information about primes written inside of it. The formula could be thought of as a decompressor to get that information out.
In a similar way, could some of our physical constants be "hiding" structure inside of them? If we got all of the structure out and into math, could we end up with a constant-less physics?
- gizmo686 11y agoThis is essentially what you get in String Theory. The problem is that String Theory requires you to define the "shape" of the extra dimensions. Once you do this, all of the fundamental constants naturally follow. However, there are so many potential shapes that are mathematically valid that this essentially moves the problem from out universe having arbitrary constants to our universe being an arbitrary shape. Unfortunately, it is possible that there is literally to elegant solution to this. For example, consider our solar system. At one point, people tried to explain the distance of the planets from the sun without invoking arbitrary constants. We now know that the distance between the planets and the sun are in largly arbitrary, because we are but one of many solar systems and other solar systems have different distances. Similarly, it is possible (although potentially non-provable and non-falsifiable). That we live in but one of many universes, and that other universes have different constants. If this is true then there is no way to avoid the fact that our universe has some arbitrary constant (even if we obscure it by calling it an arbitrary shape).
- andrewflnr 11y agoIs there a finite or countable number of these "shapes"? That would still be better than a handful of arbitrary-precision numbers. :)
- Intermernet 11y agoCurrently thought to be finite, but very large. Some info at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/String_theory_landscape https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/String_theory_landscape and http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/2873/where-does-the-10500-estimate-for-the-number-of-stringy-vacua-come-from http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/2873/where-does-t...
- positr0n 11y agoDoes that equation have a name? A naive google search doesn't return anything. Edit: Found it. A is known as Mill's constant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mills%27_constant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mills%27_constant
- Houshalter 11y agoThere's a numberphile video on that I just watched: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6ltrPVPEwfo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6ltrPVPEwfo I really don't like this formula. The numbers grow absurdly huge really quickly, and the only way of finding A is brute force search (and there are multiple possible values, they just pick the smallest that works.) It's like saying the number 0.235711131517... contains information about all the prime numbers. Well it does, but once you see how it's constructed it's not terribly interesting. Anyway I think you are saying that the constants might have low kolmogorov complexity. That is, the constant could be compressed to many fewer bits of information. That seems unlikely. There's no reason why constants can't be arbitrary or random. Perhaps there are many universes and each has a different constant. And trying to fit an expression to them is impossible, because we only know them to a few digits. That's not anywhere near enough information, and any expression like that will almost certainly be overfit. But if you insist you could try RIES: http://mrob.com/pub/ries/ries.php?target=1836.15267389&rst= http://mrob.com/pub/ries/ries.php?target=1836.15267389&rst= None of the formulas get out more characters than they put in, or even get more than a handful of digits. It's indistinguishable from a purely random number.
- unabst 11y ago> "hiding" structure inside of them Physical constants all "hide" structure inside of them. They are abstractions of some physical virtue of nature; whatever physical in nature that gives rise to the constant. All constants in physics, ideally, emerge from experiment and from evidence. Behind the constant which is the speed of light "hides" light. No?
- restalis 11y agoThat's what the researchers are after. It's hard to accept things as singular in themselves so they continuously challenge this "constant" status. The speed of light is given by the nature of the light, which is (presumably) ultimately based on other constants, so in this case the light speed is constant only thanks to being a relation of other constants. If one of the relying constants proves to be at its turn only mostly constant that changes the status of all the upstream constants. That's why that rabbit hole of universe's constants' study is so important! That being said, there are constants out there (e.g. π, which is a constant relation instead of relation of constants) for which "challenge" would probably mean assuming another kind universe entirely.
- lazyant 11y agoCarl Sagan's "Cosmos" comes to mind