4 ms·
I agree. It's one of only areas the AI's have been hood at. Pathfinding and build orders being other two. AI should be limited to a specific number of actions a
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
I agree. It's one of only areas the AI's have been hood at. Pathfinding and build orders being other two. AI should be limited to a specific number of actions a minute comparable with opposing player or best human champ. Then, we're grading it on its "thinking" instead of dexterity.
They better keep fog of war on too.
- derefr 11y agoOr, the AI could be set up like AlphaGo was: as a computer giving instructions to a merely human player. I'd love to see what a powerful StarCraft AI would do if trained to "predict and compensate for" not only its opponent, but also the inevitable human errors in faithfully executing its strategy. A certain Sector Command and Control Unit springs to mind...
- dragontamer 11y agoA huge amount of Starcraft is the intense APM training regiment that the pros undergo. APM is a huge indicator of Starcraft "skill". Its not the only thing of course, but winning "micro-battles" greatly changes the game. I don't care how good Michael Jordan is. He'll never "win" a game of basketball vs a standard professional by shouting commands to an average joe. Similarly, no average joe will be able to perform a muta-harass while retaining full-speed, taking only a single missile from a Turret. That sort of "micro-skill" takes practice and dexterity.
- derefr 11y agoYou don't think it'd be interesting to take a player who's already one of the top players, and measure the marginal gains of them doing their own macro+micro, vs. just doing micro and leaving macro to the AI?
- ktRolster 11y agoWe can see that now, with the new Archon mode, which allows two players to control the units together.
- garrettgrimsley 11y agoI haven't been following SC2 since HOTS, are they really still trying to achieve feature parity with Brood War? http://starcraft.wikia.com/wiki/Team_Melee http://starcraft.wikia.com/wiki/Team_Melee
- ktRolster 11y agoI haven't been following SC2 since HOTS Too bad, it's really good.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoThe game moves too fast for that. When I contemplated it, I was going to let the AI do the micro battles and build orders. The other aspects are planning one's strategy, identifying opponent's strategy, counters, bluffs, and so on. Humans are best at this. The machines have been laughably easy to beat at it so far. DeepMind's system is all about finding patterns. It might do better on those aspects. It could even be trained to recognize some aspects of enemy intent, how the battles are going, etc. Thing is, there's lots of potentials for curveballs in Starcraft compared to Go or Atari games. Human pro's curveball on demand. Should be interesting to see what it can do.
- derefr 11y agoHmm. Instead of purely focusing on macro, what if the human was in the middle, while the AI existed at both the top and bottom? I'm now thinking more explicitly of the book series I alluded to (The General series by S.M. Stirling and David Drake): the human is a commander, so the units are intelligent in their own right (thus, handled by the AI); and the AI is also giving the human commander real-time advice based on what knowledge it can discover through the human's vision (isolated from the other AI-instance doing micro, but "smart" in the sense that it can assume that the micro is being done by a [fallible] rational actor that thinks like it does.) I feel like that "human in the middle" configuration would actually make for its own new subgenre of 4X/RTS-like games, if we could get it right; somewhat like a more interesting version of tower defense. Like an RTS, it would be about issuing orders; like a MOBA, you'd have direct control of a "champion" unit. But the job of the unit would be to give those orders, and your job as the player would be to get their position fortified while also gaining enough information to accurately strategize. Come to think of it, this is what Dungeons & Dragons was originally supposed to be about, wasn't it? Commander-level characters going off to do scouting or other special ops for their army, advancing in rank and gaining underlings in the process. (D&D1e assumes you'll just already have a wargame going with an overworld hex grid, unit stats, etc., and just serves as a "what heroes do in a zoomed-in view" add-on to it. Thus why it doesn't come with its own battle system.)
- nickpsecurity 11y ago