3 ms·
The roadmap for Titan is unclear to say the least. No communication, then a release drops, then nothing again. Hmm. I agree with your point about the Wikidata
by nl 11y ago
The roadmap for Titan is unclear to say the least. No communication, then a release drops, then nothing again. Hmm.
I agree with your point about the Wikidata decision process. Some links about this if anyone is interested: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11201943 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11201943
BlazeGraph seems like a reasonable product (now). But I don't like seeing this "Wikidata evaluated products and chose Blazegraph" thing - they started an evaluation process.
- lmeyerov 11y agoAFAICT, Titan is effectively dead, being replaced by Datastax Graph. Likewise, Blazegraph is about graph computation (think Spark's GraphX, OLAP) rather than simple reads/writes (OLTP). Systems can try to straddle both, but the benchmarks should be different. Quickly looking at this project suggests it's on the OLTP side, not OLAP, so apples/oranges. Claiming more performance than a GPU compute engine would need some real benchmarking ;-)
- nl 11y agoBlazegraph is about graph computation (think Spark's GraphX, OLAP) This is definitely incorrect. Wikidata uses it exclusively for read/write queries. The (GPU accelerated) graph processing in BlazeGraph is new, and it's pretty unclear to me if it actually does the (GraphX) style processing. The examples[1] are all query-based. It does look interesting though! [1] https://www.blazegraph.com/product/gpu-accelerated/ https://www.blazegraph.com/product/gpu-accelerated/
- lmeyerov 11y agoBlazegraph has multiple backends. Their GPU compute engine vs. their classic DB engine are different ones. And yes, I doubt they use the same approach as GraphX, considering they've published how they don't (MapGraph) and GPUs require way more work. Lumping all these systems together doesn't make sense: reads aren't writes, and there's a whole world of graph computations. Benchmarks matter. That said, I'd be skeptical of a GPU system for being great at writes, and I'd be skeptical of a non-GPU one computing better than one on GPUs.
- lobster_johnson 11y agoThere's quite a lot of activity on http://github.com/thinkaurelius/titan http://github.com/thinkaurelius/titan for a dead project. Admittedly, the issues are piling up, but the code seems to be actively worked on.