7 ms·
I would argue that is not the point of the story. The point is that this man stood up for his daughter who was being made to feel bad because she had a better
by pmiller2 11y ago
I would argue that is not the point of the story. The point is that this man stood up for his daughter who was being made to feel bad because she had a better answer than the other kids. You can quibble about 9^9^9 vs Knuth notation vs Conway notation (you didn't mention that one) vs some arbitrary notation you can invent, but the point is the girl was more creative than the rest of her class and was penalized for it, and her dad stood up for her.
- threatofrain 11y agoYou frame the poster as quibbling, but that's exactly what the father is doing, in a way that is both incorrect and pedantic, even if we were to follow their internal logic of using only implicit operators (why not tetration?). Yes, the girl exercised creativity. It is the teacher's discretionary job to reward that creativity. In this case, though, the father is wrong and he myopically uses it to attack the Common Core.
- Mithaldu 11y agoIt is not incorrect, since her answer entirely fulfills the text of the question. He is not quibbling. Textual questions by their very nature can have multiple answers, depending on the context the question is read in. Any system that can not accept that is broken and does nothing to educate students and merely creates unthinking rote repetition automatons. He is perfectly right in attacking that and in fact it must be attacked.
- threatofrain 11y agoHow is it correct? If we follow her internal, idiosyncratic logic of using implicit operators, then tentration is a better fit answer.
- Mithaldu 11y agoIt is correct because a textual question will always have multiple correct answers. Only a very narrow mind will insist on there being only one correct answer. Edit: Out of curiosity, and since i can't find it: How is the highest number out of three 9s written with tetration on paper?
- threatofrain 11y agoThere's such thing as a wrong answer, and it's pretty poor ethic to discuss psychology here before understanding someone's argument. I could just as well say that you are narrow-minded for not entertaining my perspective when I have given analysis for yours. Giving an argument about psychology which you don't want returned is bad faith. It shows a lack of regard for difficulty of good faith reciprocity. You're basically arguing that (1) textual questions inherently have more than one answers [care to explain?], and that (2) therefore 9^9^9 is correct [can you explain if you think 100 is correct?], and as an additional tack-on point, you think that (3) operators are fair play as long as they're implicit, even though there's nothing mathematically special about them except for the typography. Tetration is typographically written as the reverse of 9^9^9 on paper.
- Mithaldu 11y ago> There's such thing as a wrong answer I never said otherwise, why do you state the obvious? > and it's pretty poor ethic to discuss psychology here before understanding someone's argument. It's pretty poor ethic to proclaim one's understanding of another's mindset as fact without having asked them if it such or them having declared it. You have no place to try and claim what her logic was. > I could just as well say that you are narrow-minded for not entertaining my perspective when I have given analysis for yours. I did entertain and i found it wanting, as explained above. > textual questions inherently have more than one answers [care to explain?] Every text is open for interpretation and its understanding always depends on any assumptions made while reading it. Be ware of assuming that your assumptions about assumptions made actually match reality. Further, particularly in schooling, tests serve to ask whether understanding exists or not. I have repeatedly gotten full grades on problems where i applied the correct method and described it accurately, even when along the way a small oversight in numerical operations resulted in a wrong final number. > can you explain if you think 100 is correct? Why should i? I don't understand why you ask this. Please explain yourself if you think it truly merits discussion. > Tetration is typographically written as the reverse of 9^9^9 on paper. So, sub-script instead of super-script?
- jacquesm 11y agoI think you are missing the wood for the trees. The question as stated allowed for multiple answers to be correct. Note that exponentiation needs no 'operators' to work in a visual way, just place the two 9's in ascending positions relative to the first. That's just 'three digits'. Now that's a clever answer. A teacher appreciative of that cleverness would have noted it and would have marked the answer correct and moved on. To go 'to war' over something that simple at some point becomes a point of principle and if - as a parent - you let your kid down at a time like that when your kid has fought very hard to maintain a 'perfect score' then you fail your duty as a parent. The school should have backed down immediately, then when given the choice again they should have backed down by simply marking the answer correct upon review. Finally, by making it a point of principle that they would not mark the answer correct they essentially forced the dad to choose between supporting his daughter or telling her to suck it up because 'after all, what does a perfect math score matter'. That he chose to pursue it is a-ok in my book. To 'attack the common core' need not have happened. If the school wanted the simple answer they could have chosen to only allow multiple choice, by making it an 'open answer' they allowed for creativity and that should always be rewarded, especially in classes such as math.
- threatofrain 11y agoI have already entertained the internal and idiosyncratic logic at play here, that implicit operators are fair game. If that's the case, then tetration is the right answer. Furthermore, the question permitted argumentation, which was refused. Why might 500 be a wrong answer? For the same logic you might use to answer that question, I would say that tetration is a superior answer to exponentiation, even following the typographic logic that implicit operators are okay. Typographically, tetration is the reverse of exponentiation. And I believe I addressed the broadest-perspective point of all -- that this is not an adequate launching point for an argument against the Common Core. It's shrill.
- jacquesm 11y ago> If that's the case, then tetration is the right answer. Sure, and whenever you're in a position to give that answer you should. But from the point of view of the girl her answer was right and 'better' than 999, and to deny her that small victory (especially with her being such a good student) would seem to me to achieve the exact opposite of what school is all about: to teach, to motivate and to reward original thinking, especially when it leads to better answers than the commonly visible ones. To dis-incentivize (I hope that's spelled correctly) that is the worst thing you could do to an otherwise motivated student.
- dagw 11y agoI was with the dad until he started to use his daughter as a launching platform for his own personal crusade against his political bugbears. After that it became clear that he cared less about his daughter and more about his politics.