4 ms·
Even if that was the case, which I don't think it is, Microsoft shouldn't be asking for stuff like FAT32 royalties. Think about it. Microsoft is asking for roy
by mtgx 11y ago
Even if that was the case, which I don't think it is, Microsoft shouldn't be asking for stuff like FAT32 royalties.
Think about it. Microsoft is asking for royalties for making devices that work with Windows. How crazy is that? Imagine if Google charged accessory makers for hooking into Android devices. I don't care if others do this sort of thing, too. It's just wrong.
It should be an anti-trust issue, especially when you have a dominating OS like Windows. What are other companies going to do - make mobile devices that don't work with Windows?
- yuhong 11y agoAnd remember that it was only relatively recently that they asked for it in the first place. And yes indeed I think it also includes Chrome OS too nowadays.
- dogma1138 11y agoWhy shouldn't MSFT claim patents for FAT? They've developed it and it was adopted by everyone and their mother for being good and cheap FS. You don't need to support FAT to allow transfer of files between your your Windows PC and the phone standards that abstract the file system like MTP and PTP exist for this very own reason. If you are as a phone maker want to enable users to mount their local phone storage as a fully writable file system cheaply you just format the SDCard using FAT and pay royalties. If you don't you can still easily bypass the FAT patent issue by creating your own abstraction layer which may or maynot require the user to use specialized software and drivers (BB manager/itune/kies etc.). That said for the majority of users MTP and PTP are more than sufficient I have an iPhone now and I do not miss the mount-SD card feature one bit if I'm honest even without using iTunes on a non-jailbroken device. I can still plugin the phone and transfer files from the camera which is pretty much the only bloodything I could do with it anyhow and for this Apple does not need to support FAR nor pay MSFT a dime.
- yuhong 11y agoThe actual patents are on the FAT LFN extensions, not FAT itself.
- gillianseed 11y ago>They've developed it and it was adopted by everyone and their mother for being good and cheap FS. No, it was adopted in order to have Windows compability, which you need given the Windows desktop monopoly and since Windows refuses to support any filesystem it won't get royalties on.
- RaleyField 11y agoThere are drivers for other file systems like ext3 on Windows.
- ams6110 11y agoFAT is getting on for what, 40 years old now?
- vetinari 11y agoThe point is, that you cannot use other filesystem, perhaps more suitable to underlying storage technology, like F2FS, because it does not work with Windows. FAT is actually terrible filesystem. It's only advantage is "works with Windows". For SD-cards, it is actually mandatory to use FAT (exFAT for SDXC). It's part of the spec. MTP/PTP is a non-functioning mess.
- dogma1138 11y agoMTP/PTP works fine for what it is. Also MSFT didn't force anyone to adopt FAT32 and exFAT for SDHC and SDXC it's not even part of the SD association https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SD_Association https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SD_Association If there was a better FS out there that met all the requirements for SD cards don't you think it would've been adopted? Because the last thing I think all of those guys wanted is to pay MSFT royalty fees, however the alternative could've been even more expensive.
- cyphar 11y ago> MTP/PTP works fine for what it is. > Also MSFT didn't force anyone to adopt FAT32 and exFAT for SDHC and SDXC it's not even part of the SD association https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SD_Association https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SD_Association > If there was a better FS out there that met all the requirements for SD cards don't you think it would've been adopted? They need to allow users to plug their SD cards into their Windows machine without it being wiped. That requires using FAT. Considering the fact that most Android distributions use far more modern Linux filesystems (ext, xfs, etc), I wouldn't say that the reason they use FAT is because it's "the best FS out there". In all honesty, you can't come close to ZFS. Not to mention that Windows has poisoned the UEFI spec by requiring that your UEFI boot partition be formatted with FAT. However, as it turns out, this means that they had to give a patent grant to anyone who implements UEFI-based booting (which is why the vfat Linux kernel code is still there).
- vetinari 11y ago> If there was a better FS out there that met all the requirements for SD cards don't you think it would've been adopted? No, it would not. It is dependent on Microsoft's willingness to ship IFS with Windows. And why would they do that, to lose their leverage? No, common user is not going install third-party IFS module. He might not even able to do so (work computers, etc).
- beagle3 11y agoFAT is actually a CPM disk format, from before the time Microsoft was even in the operating system business. The patents are for the LFN extension, and they are completely trivial and bogus.
- ourmandave 11y agoHow much longer can MS collect on FAT32? The wiki page says patent terms are 20 years in the U.S. and FAT32 was introduced in August 1996. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Term_of_patent_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Term_of_patent_in_the_United_S... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File_Allocation_Table#FAT32 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File_Allocation_Table#FAT32
- yuhong 11y agoYea, most of the FAT LFN patents has expired by now. I think this is part of why MS created exFAT and patented it.