3 ms·
A related question that might be interesting is in a container of a given volume that is perfectly sealed except for one hole to the outside air, and with no fa
by tzs 11y ago
A related question that might be interesting is in a container of a given volume that is perfectly sealed except for one hole to the outside air, and with no fans or other systems to encourage air exchange, how big does the hole need to be to keep oxygen levels high enough and CO2 levels low enough for survival indefinitely?
My intuition at first says that it would need to be a big hole because there won't be much airflow since the pressure inside and outside will be the same. But that is looking at it wrong.
It's the individual gases that matter. If CO2 is more concentrated inside than out, then there will be a net transfer of CO2 out. Similarly for O2 coming in. It's a diffusion problem, not an airflow problem, and I've got no usable intuition for that.
A interesting variant would be to make the hole intermittent. Assuming that my house is perfectly sealed when the doors are closed, do the normal openings for my daily comings and goings provide sufficient time for enough O2 to diffuse in and CO2 to diffuse out to keep my inside air breathable?
- jpeanuts 11y agoThis is a question I've asked myself before too. Here's a back-of-envelope calculation which seems to suggest that diffusion alone will never be enough to keep someone alive inside a box. I'd be really interested to hear if someone can confirm or refute this. Let's assume CO2 transfer is entirely diffusion-limited, i.e. the worst-case of completely still air. The diffusive flux of some gas-component (per unit area per unit time) J is governed by concentration-gradient (dn/dx) multiplied by a magic diffusion coefficient D, which depends on the molecular properties of the gas. For CO2 in air D = 1.6e-5 m^2/s. Let's assume the gradient is linear so dn/dx = (n_{inside} - n_{outside}) / length. Now n_{outside) = 0.04% * 1 kg/m^3 = 4e-4 kg/m^3. We should decide what level of CO2 we can tolerate, 0.5% should be on the safe side, so n_{inside} = 5e-3 kg/m^3. Length is a bit trickier. If (a) we assume completely stagnant air inside and outside, length should be chosen as the size of the box ~1 m say. However if (b) we assume that inside and outside are pretty well-mixed individually, due by breathing, wind etc., then length should be about the depth of the hole, or thickness of the box-material, say 1 cm = 0.01 m. For case (a) CO2 leaves our box at a rate of about 7e-8 kg/s/m^2, for (b) 7e-6 kg/s/m^2. From the original article, a human breaths .84 kg of O2/day, let's estimate a production of 1kg CO2/day (the extra carbon atom can't be all that significant), or 1e-5 kg/s. To compute the area of hole needed to maintain 0.5% CO2, we just divide 1e-5 by J, to get the area. In case (a) we need an enormous area of 135 m^2, in (b) "only" 1.35 m^2. This seems to suggest that "air-holes" must work (if indeed they work at all) with air-flow. This doesn't necessary require an over- or under-pressure in the box - a suction can be generated by wind passing over a box with holes on both sides - this process would be far more efficient at restoring atmosphere than diffusion. But would be less reliable.
- xenadu02 11y agoHeat is another helper here. Body heat would eventually cause a chimney effect unless the single hole is on the bottom of the box. That will create an air current, greatly increasing the speed of diffusion.