7 ms·
I can't seem to understand if MSFT patents actually apply to the Android OS / AOSP or just to various firmware, middleware and software that OEM's use on their
by dogma1138 11y ago
I can't seem to understand if MSFT patents actually apply to the Android OS / AOSP or just to various firmware, middleware and software that OEM's use on their devices regardless of the OS in question.
The AOSP license and 3rd party notifications do not mention Microsoft and the patents listed in Chinese doc are like vague in the usual patent-esque way.
But in any case i don't really see the issue here, if MSFT gets royalties from these patents it would be irresponsible (to their shareholders, and employees) for them to ditch them, none of these patents claims actually seem to be aimed at Google or the AOSP project so it looks like the core Android OS is not really affected by this.
Google owns countless patents and Apple just might be the biggest patent troll in history and none of them seem to receive even remotely the same amount of scrutiny.
- leadingthenet 11y agoOut of curiosity, what do you mean when you say that Apple is the biggest patent troll in history? It's the first time I hear such a claim.
- dogma1138 11y agoApple vs Samsung et al. Issuing patents on silly things like slide to unlock and mag lock even tho those functions existed before Apple has ever used them? Heck I'm surprised they haven't sue every kitchen appliance in Asia for violating their maglock patent.... Heck the first apple iPhone GUI related suit against Samsung was field before the first iPhone was even on the market.
- josephpmay 11y agoCan you provide an example of slide to unlock before the iPhone? Also, I (personally) feel that maglock for a power cable is very different from maglock for a refrigerator. (A ticket terminal and a vending machine are very different devices covered by different patents even if they both utilize the same basic mechanisms.)
- dogma1138 11y agoIn Asia small appliances had a magnet on the power cable for ages these aren't fridges but smaller appliances like kettles and hotplates and it was added exactly for the same reason that Apple added it to their laptops the only difference is that Asia has been doing so since the 60's.
- Coincoin 11y agoNot just in Asia. I threw a couple of old (60s~70s) appliances with magnet power cables a few years ago. The cables were very north american.
- esolyt 11y agoA touchscreen phone named Neonode N1 had slide-to-unlock 2 years before iPhone. http://9to5mac.com/2011/10/25/slide-to-unlock-patented/ http://9to5mac.com/2011/10/25/slide-to-unlock-patented/ But the point is, it is a very trivial way of interacting with a touchscreen. It is, in fact, one of the few ways one can interact with a touchscreen.
- rubber_duck 11y ago>But the point is, it is a very trivial way of interacting with a touchscreen. It is, in fact, one of the few ways one can interact with a touchscreen. I don't get how people can argue stuff like this should even be covered by patents. What's the rationale ? Did Apple spend billions in R&D to develop this feature it now needs a mechanism to recoup it's investment ? I suppose they wouldn't "invent" swipe to unlock if it wasn't for the patent so they needed extra incentives to make it a viable investment ? The fact that you can get a patent for something trivial and inconsequential like this shows how flawed the system is IMO.
- ams6110 11y agoYeah that's supposed to be covered by the requirement that an invention be "novel" to qualify for a patent.
- reitanqild 11y agoAnd that is before we even start on the "design patents".
- mwfunk 11y agoI wouldn't defend any of those cases, but if that's your yardstick for "biggest patent troll in history", then you have a lot of disillusionment and disappointment ahead of you. There is no shortage of vastly sillier patent cases being won by organizations whose entire business model is "winning silly patent cases", in many cases against people who can't afford to defend themselves, but sometimes against giant tech companies as well. Big tech companies sue each other all the time over all sorts of stupid things. Everybody is suing everybody all the time and it's absurd that they have to play that game, but that's not even close to the bottom of the barrel of patent insanity. Don't mistake the handful of high-profile cases that bubble to the top of your RSS feeds (or whatever) as being a meaningful sample of what is actually going on in the world, because the reality is so much worse than that.
- mtgx 11y agoEven if that was the case, which I don't think it is, Microsoft shouldn't be asking for stuff like FAT32 royalties. Think about it. Microsoft is asking for royalties for making devices that work with Windows. How crazy is that? Imagine if Google charged accessory makers for hooking into Android devices. I don't care if others do this sort of thing, too. It's just wrong. It should be an anti-trust issue, especially when you have a dominating OS like Windows. What are other companies going to do - make mobile devices that don't work with Windows?
- yuhong 11y agoAnd remember that it was only relatively recently that they asked for it in the first place. And yes indeed I think it also includes Chrome OS too nowadays.
- dogma1138 11y agoWhy shouldn't MSFT claim patents for FAT? They've developed it and it was adopted by everyone and their mother for being good and cheap FS. You don't need to support FAT to allow transfer of files between your your Windows PC and the phone standards that abstract the file system like MTP and PTP exist for this very own reason. If you are as a phone maker want to enable users to mount their local phone storage as a fully writable file system cheaply you just format the SDCard using FAT and pay royalties. If you don't you can still easily bypass the FAT patent issue by creating your own abstraction layer which may or maynot require the user to use specialized software and drivers (BB manager/itune/kies etc.). That said for the majority of users MTP and PTP are more than sufficient I have an iPhone now and I do not miss the mount-SD card feature one bit if I'm honest even without using iTunes on a non-jailbroken device. I can still plugin the phone and transfer files from the camera which is pretty much the only bloodything I could do with it anyhow and for this Apple does not need to support FAR nor pay MSFT a dime.
- yuhong 11y agoThe actual patents are on the FAT LFN extensions, not FAT itself.
- 11y ago
- mortehu 11y agoWhy do you want more scrutiny for Google's patents? As far as I know, they have never used their patents aggressively, only as a defense. In an environment containing trolls like Apple and Microsoft, I can't blame them.
- true_religion 11y agoGoogle receives as much scrutiny as Microsoft. What they don't receive is criticism, because it's hard to criticize something that is sitting around mostly doing nothing.
- dave2000 11y ago"Google owns countless patents and Apple just might be the biggest patent troll in history and none of them seem to receive even remotely the same amount of scrutiny." Why would you face scrutiny for holding patents?
- Kliment 11y agoPatents are like nuclear weapons - they stay dangerous for a very long time, most who have them claim their primary function is to scare others who have them away from attacking them with theirs, but their actual function is to scare and extort anyone who doesn't have them into doing what the patent-holding assholes want. Of course we want to hold anyone who has them under careful scrutiny.
- vinceguidry 11y ago> Patents are like nuclear weapons - they stay dangerous for a very long time That is not actually true about nuclear weapons; they require regular maintenance. And they are like any other military technology, they get outdated and their designs have to be constantly refreshed. If a country doesn't maintain their nuclear arsenal, there's a very good chance that they might not work when they need it to. This happened to much of Russia's inventory. This, of course, gets factored into geopolitical strategy.
- melling 11y agoApple has a handful of patents that are questionable and they're the biggest patent troll in history? Seems like a bit of an exaggeration considering there's an entire industry built around patent trolling. Here are Microsoft's 300 Android patents. All legit? http://images.mofcom.gov.cn/pep/201404/20140408143159274.docx http://images.mofcom.gov.cn/pep/201404/20140408143159274.doc... "Automatic Re-Authentication" "Reducing Power Consumption in a Networked Battery-Operated Device Using Sensors" "Browser Navigation for Devices With a Limited Input System"
- seanwilson 11y ago> if MSFT gets royalties from these patents it would be irresponsible (to their shareholders, and employees) for them to ditch them Actively enforcing patents like these hurts Microsoft's relationship with developers, hardware manufacturers, the open source community etc.
- mwfunk 11y agoSadly that means that there is likely one group of people in MS saying, "enforcing these patents gives us a large revenue stream that we don't have to do anything to maintain" (except for paying lawyers, but lawyers probably form part of the core of this group). On the other side, there is likely another group of people in MS saying "hey guys, if we give up this massive guaranteed cash flow we could receive an impossible-to-predict-or-measure amount of goodwill from ill-defined groups of hypothetical people who might all just hate us anyway no matter what we do, and even if it does make them like us more we're not sure if it will really make a difference in the long run." Now, I would be squarely in the latter group, because I think it's the right thing to do and is consistent with the kind of company that MS appears to be trying to transform itself into, but I've gotta think that that's a very tough case to argue to anyone who is actually in a position to make that call and is therefore held responsible for the outcome. I would try to make a much more convincing argument than the strawman I presented, but since it's all about intangibles, someone with an opposing viewpoint could probably make just as convincing of a case by framing my intangibles as that strawman, and there's not a whole lot anyone could say to refute it. It's a local maximum seen throughout the industry- I think there is a growing realization outside of the usual niches (open source advocates, HN readers, etc.) that software patents are doing more harm than good, but in the individual isolated cases it still comes down to people arguing internally that an organization should give up a guaranteed revenue stream in exchange for theoretical goodwill that may or may not actually benefit the company in any tangible way. Lots of people hate stupid patents but patent holders would rather change the system for everyone, than go out on a limb and make a sacrifice like that with no guarantee that their competitors would follow suit. I don't envy anyone trying to fight the good fight in that environment.
- lagadu 11y agoThe group of people that still hates Microsoft by and large will always hate them until they die. Even if they opened up the patents they'd still be hated for "being evil". There's next to nothing to gain from doing and there's billions to lose.
- mratzloff 11y agoWhy is Microsoft "irresponsible," in your words, if they don't extract maximum value from their patent portfolio, but Apple is a troll? Doesn't Apple likewise have an "obligation" to their shareholders to maximize their value based on your implication?
- whybroke 11y ago> ...if MSFT gets royalties from these patents it would be irresponsible (to their shareholders, and employees) for them to ditch them... Continuing that logic, it would be irresponsible not to defend this patent's revenue in court. Irresponsible not to use the most advantageous court for that (i.e. East Texas). Irresponsible to campaign in such a way that might invalidate that patent as it would deprive them of a valuable asset. Irresponsible not to reinvest some of the revenue these parent's generate into lobbyists to protect that revenue stream and asset. So responsibly to investors again results in a tragedy of the commons. This time in patent litigation and legislation
- twblalock 11y agoIf you want that to change, support changes in patent law. You can't expect any company to act against its own self interest while other companies take full advantage of the system. In other words, don't hate the player; hate the game.
- AnthonyMouse 11y agoIf you play the game you end up with an interest in the game continuing to exist. If you play the game because you have to while working to destroy it, that is one thing. If you play the game and lobby against the destruction of the game, you are the problem.
- low_battery 11y agoReally? Is Google actively shaking up tens of companies with secret patents and threats?
- ocdtrekkie 11y agoIt's kinda hard to prove because of the confidentiality Google uses in it's agreements with partners, but Samsung was making every indication that they would fork Android, prepping alternatives to all of Google's apps. Then, they reversed course in 2014, they signed a patent agreement with Google and started 'toning down TouchWiz'. These stories were two days apart. Why would Samsung do this if Google wasn't leveraging it's patent portfolio? http://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/2014/01/27/samgsung-google-patents-agreement/4937057/ http://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/2014/01/27/samgsung-googl... http://androidandme.com/2014/01/news/samsung-may-be-toning-down-touchwiz-due-to-googles-influence/ http://androidandme.com/2014/01/news/samsung-may-be-toning-d...
- PhasmaFelis 11y ago> But in any case i don't really see the issue here, if MSFT gets royalties from these patents it would be irresponsible (to their shareholders, and employees) for them to ditch them So it's okay to shake people down over bogus patent claims, as long as your shareholders get their take? As I said elsewhere in this thread, I really hate how people hurry to come up with excuses for corporations and their representatives acting like jerks. They can take responsibility for their actions just like the rest of us. > Google owns countless patents and Apple just might be the biggest patent troll in history and none of them seem to receive even remotely the same amount of scrutiny. Are you serious? Did you not notice the endless derisive coverage about slide-to-unlock, "rounded corners," etc, etc? Apple deserves and gets plenty of shit for its patent trolling. This article, on the other hand, is the first thing I've personally heard about Microsoft patents in years--I'm sure there's been other coverage, but it's certainly not as comprehensive as Apple's.