6 ms·
A chilling mathematical model of inequality
- danharaj 11y agoAnyone have a link to a paper?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- anexprogrammer 11y agoPaper is at http://arxiv.org/abs/1602.07300 http://arxiv.org/abs/1602.07300
- mathgenius 11y agoNice how they cite their git repository in the references.
- p4wnc6 11y agoBut they didn't even bother to cite a tagged release or even a specific commit. Presumably, master will change and could be different than when the paper was published. I guess you could compare dates (although, who knows how far prior to the submission date the git repo master branch corresponded to the exact code used for the paper), but why make reproducibility more obfuscated, when all it costs you is `git tag` to the appropriate commit, making an easily obtainable copy of the state of the repo exactly as it was used for everything that was submitted. Providing the source is better than nothing, but we still have so far to go educating academics about the vital need for real and effortful data provenance and reproducibility.
- nekopa 11y agoI'm thinking that maybe they're not developers as such, just scientists, and therefore may not know how to do that. Could you open an issue that could show them how to do what you're suggesting?
- p4wnc6 11y agoUnfortunately, I don't have a Bitbucket account because I don't approve of Atlassian, so I can't. But hopefully someone here who does use Atlassian products will do it?
- nekopa 11y agoLooking at the repo, seems like there is only 1 commit. I have a BB account, so when I get back to my PC I'll drop them a message on the repo.
- p4wnc6 11y agoThe fact that there is only one commit is a bit disconcerting. It suggests that they edited, debugged, and modified the code "offline" until they felt it was "good enough" to share, so whatever revision history there was when the paper was being created, revised, and submitted, is lost. We can only take the authors' word for it that in between getting results for the paper and releasing the commit, they didn't make any significant alterations that would affect reproducibility. The point is not to be critical of these particular authors. Good on them for sharing their code. The point is to highlight that it's harmful for academics to "hide" their code until they get it all together for the "perfect" commit. It defeats the point of version control and their repo functions instead as basically nothing but a download link. All the reproducibility problems would remain the same as if the code was provided as just a tarball linked from some academic web page.
- ktRolster 11y agoThe fact that there is only one commit is a bit disconcerting. It suggests that they edited, debugged, and modified the code "offline" until they felt it was "good enough" to share, so whatever revision history there was when the paper was being created, revised, and submitted, is lost. Obsessions with code history are a little disconcerting. It's interesting to see, but has little relation to the quality of the paper (or the code base, for that matter).
- RangerScience 11y agohttps://bitbucket.org/flandes/ineqfreezeseconomy_montecarlo_mastereq/src https://bitbucket.org/flandes/ineqfreezeseconomy_montecarlo_...
- p4wnc6 11y agoThis is admittedly extremely naive, but won't liquidity simply become a service that commands a premium? In finance, you see the entry of market makers who provide liquidity when you need it, in exchange for collecting a premium (the bid-ask spread). As more market makers enter this situation, one of the main ways they compete is by lowering prices, which is good for consumers who rely on them for liquidity on demand. The market makers are essentially willing to put their money at risk by scrambling it around all day in the form of ownership of different assets, and then squaring up by the end of the day so that they hopefully don't hold any exposure to any asset over some significant time period. This isn't about financial market making per se, but just the basic idea. There could be similar market makers in other fields, perhaps buying and selling physical goods, but never storing them for sale over time. Fields where the handling and registration of goods transfers can't be as highly digitized as finance or energy would be much more expensive to provide liquidity, and the "bid-ask spread" would have to be higher to compensate. In a sense, it would reflect the kinds of liquidity people care about buying, and if other kinds of liquidity dried up, it would be because people mostly didn't want to buy that liquidity. I'm not saying that there wouldn't be unhealthy effects from inequality, but I think to the extent that inequality inherently limits liquidity, then market makers enter to provide that liquidity as a service.
- danharaj 11y agoYou can't market make between people who have too little money and people who have too much money. Lending money to consumers won't work because while their increased consumption would produce economic activity and profit for someone, it wouldn't return to them and so such lending is inherently risky, so the interest rates would have to be high, which just further exacerbates the problem that they have too little money. This paper is basically a stone's throw away from the Marxian analysis of crises of capital. It's nice that it's quantitative; a nice complement to all the qualitative criticisms of capitalism's fundamental structure. It's not the market that is the issue, but the tendency of capital to concentrate in the hands of the propertied class. There are two kinds of capitalist societies actually seen in the real world, the unstable kinds, and the kinds that have significant wealth redistribution mechanisms. Real economies oscillate between the two or collapse.
- shasta 11y ago> The reason is quite simple. As inequality gets more pronounced, a larger fraction of the population faces more stringent budget constraints, and the spectrum of possible economic interactions open to them narrows. That's pretty simple, alright. Gee whiz. It's a good thing we have those abstruse theories from physics to tell us that people without money don't buy as much stuff. I'm guessing this is a case of bad journalism -- anyone have a better layman's explanation?
- turbohz 11y agoInteraction could also mean selling.
- Terr_ 11y ago"Poor people can't afford to wait for better deals", perhaps?
- nekopa 11y agoI think the point of the article and the paper is to take that simple assumption and see exactly what level of inequality leads to effects on the larger economy. A number which we seem to be approaching.
- yxlx 11y ago>The researchers found another interesting effect — a "trickle up" flow of wealth quite different from the usual "trickle down" picture of supply-side economics. In an economy with appreciable inequality, capital tends to flow from those with less to those with more, generating a cascade of transactions along the way. Hence, policy interventions aiming to spur economic activity should work better if they inject money into the system at the lower end, rather than from the top. Does this mean that the paper supports basic income? I don't know much about these topics but I see basic income pop up in conversation on HN every now and then, so it came to mind when I read this.
- CuriousSkeptic 11y agoMore or less. While there's some controversy on the morals of getting money for nothing, when you get past that the economic viability is usually the focus of debate, and in this discussion it is certainly relevant. Basic income proponents tend to focus on on sums big enough to live on though, but on this particular topic the size isn't really an issue, and smaller amounts could be interesting to try. Things like http://www.qe4people.eu http://www.qe4people.eu tend to come up as a type of basic income. More permanent things like the Icelandic souverign money proposal ( https://www.forsaetisraduneyti.is/media/Skyrslur/monetary-reform.pdf https://www.forsaetisraduneyti.is/media/Skyrslur/monetary-re... ) has similar elements.
- skylan_q 11y ago* Hence, policy interventions aiming to spur economic activity should work better if they inject money into the system at the lower end, rather than from the top.* Cantillon effects: In Essai, Cantillon provided an advanced version of John Locke's quantity theory of money, focusing on relative inflation and the velocity of money.[61] Cantillon suggested that inflation occurs gradually and that the new supply of money has a localised effect on inflation, effectively originating the concept of non-neutral money.[62] Furthermore, he posited that the original recipients of new money enjoy higher standards of living at the expense of later recipients.[63] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Cantillon#Monetary_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Cantillon#Monetary_the... Right now, banks and then gov't are the first recipients of new money being injected into the system a la central banking. Wealth distribution schemes implemented through fiscal policy (taxes and tax credits/grants/UBI) can be undermined through monetary policy this way.
- chrispeel 11y agoPaul Graham (co-founder of y-combinator) questioned whether inequality itself is a bad thing [1] [2]. I'd love to hear his comments. Or has he backtracked? I know that Ycombinator is investigating a basic income [3], which addresses income inequality. I'd love to see the level of a basic income used as the knob to use to kick-start an economy. Or some argument as to why this is a bad idea. [1] http://www.paulgraham.com/ineq.html http://www.paulgraham.com/ineq.html [2] http://paulgraham.com/sim.html http://paulgraham.com/sim.html [3] https://blog.ycombinator.com/basic-income https://blog.ycombinator.com/basic-income
- ChrisDutrow 11y agoI don't know much about inequality specifically. But I know poverty is a bad thing for everyone. It creates violence and prevents people from having a chance to contribute to society. We're starting to see people who have health issues that have accumulated over multiple generations: lead poisoning, nutritional deficiencies, drug poisoning... Is it ok to have inequality if everyone is at least middle class? It seems ok, but I think the problem with this is the artificial barriers to breaking into the wealthy class. Lots of more capable people tend to be held down in lower classes while less capable people are allowed handle the wealth because they were born into it, know the right people, and know the culture. Of course there are plenty of exceptions to this trend.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- et2o 11y agoThis technique maybe points a way toward answering a very important question: what is the optimum level of inequality in a society? I doubt that the answer would be 'one where everyone is exactly equal,' because we do have differing physical and intellectual capabilities which would mean that if everyone was exactly equal, we would be under-allocating resources to certain people. On the other hand, it's almost assuredly true that the level of inequality we have now is just too high. The difficulty is in finding the exact equation to maximize.
- danharaj 11y ago> I doubt that the answer would be 'one where everyone is exactly equal,' because we do have differing physical and intellectual capabilities which would mean that if everyone was exactly equal, we would be under-allocating resources to certain people. This is only true if one assumes private property and resource equality at the same time. If one abandons private property and tries to imagine systems of resource distribution based on democratic processes, there are far more possibilities. One possibility that obviously doesn't work out is a command economy where a centralized bureaucratic state owns everything. These systems seem to have similar dysfunctions to a megacorporation that owns everything in a country. We've never seen a decentralized, democratic system of communal property at large scale because they're always destroyed by violent means by other systems if they get too big.
- ams6110 11y agoAhh, the old "communism works, it's just never been done right" argument....
- danharaj 11y agoI mean, communism has a particular definition, so if that definition isn't met, then it's not communism. Communism is a classless society with worker control of the means of production. A sprawling centralized state bureaucracy is none of those things. Indeed, the whole departure of Leninism from Marxism is the idea of a vanguard party transitioning from capitalism to communism via a state apparatus. It's a fundamentally elitist doctrine that quite obviously did not work the way it was presupposed to work. It's not like people don't talk about capitalism in heavily idealized terms, either. I've never seen an exegesis of liberalism that doesn't elide the pervasive and frequent expropriation and violent enforcement required to prevent the system from falling over.
- venomsnake 11y agoWealth accumulates exponentially when you have longevity or inheritance in the system. Why do we suddenly act surprised that an exponential function is growing exponentially after we reduced all other variables that could slow its growth to zero.
- chrispeel 11y agoThe author of the article, Mark Buchanan, has a blog [1] titled "Physics Perspective" and subtitled "Inspiration from physics for thinking about economics, finance and social systems". Lotsa interesting stuff; I saw one article which said that stable economic growth in developed countries tends to be linear. [1] http://physicsoffinance.blogspot.com/ http://physicsoffinance.blogspot.com/ [2] http://physicsoffinance.blogspot.com/2016/02/economic-growth-vastly-slower-than-we.html http://physicsoffinance.blogspot.com/2016/02/economic-growth...
- dhimes 11y agoAlso excellent from the same author: http://www.amazon.com/Ubiquity-Catastrophes-Happen-Mark-Buchanan/dp/0609809989 http://www.amazon.com/Ubiquity-Catastrophes-Happen-Mark-Buch... http://www.amazon.com/Nexus-Worlds-Groundbreaking-Science-Networks/dp/0393324427/ http://www.amazon.com/Nexus-Worlds-Groundbreaking-Science-Ne...
- mtgx 11y ago> This fits with the argument that quantitative easing — in which central banks purchase securities — may ultimately be misguided. Such a policy is supposed to encourage spending by propping up the prices of stocks and bonds, which tends to boost wealth only at the top end of the distribution. Central bankers might have a more powerful and beneficial effect if they instead injected money directly into the accounts of citizens, who could then use it to pay down debts or spend as they like. Interestingly enough, Ron Paul was one of the few saying this all along.
- ams6110 11y agoCentral bankers might have a more powerful and beneficial effect if they instead injected money directly into the accounts of citizens, who could then use it to pay down debts or spend as they like That's what tax cuts do, without the overhead of a large central bureaucratic program to manage it.
- chillwaves 11y agoHow much in taxes are people at the bottom paying?
- banku_brougham 11y agoI love this. Economics is such a complicated system that the expert opinions have long been biased toward the 'opinion' side, forget about the large stakes in the game that the loudest voices hold. A physical model of network effects that presents phase transitions gives us a view into the underlying reality. So cool. Sadly, for 100+ years we've known about the destructive effects of deflation on leveraged economies (Much longer for the accelerated growth that comes with leverage), yet the leadership in political economics continues to call for hard money and budgetary surplus, which doesn't even make sense with respect to accounting identities.
- bendykstra 11y ago> Economics is such a complicated system that the expert opinions have long been biased toward the 'opinion' side > A physical model of network effects that presents phase transitions gives us a view into the underlying reality. Here, imperfect mental models (aka opinions) are replaced by imperfect computational models. There's nothing inherently superior about this model just because it has been translated into code. It should be regarded as a tool to understand the consequences of the assumptions that went into its design. If those assumptions are unsound, the model is unsound and will not reflect real economic systems.
- s_m_t 11y agoAre there any 'natural' tendencies in an economy that resist inequality getting so high?
- slv77 11y agoTorches and pitchforks?
- rishubhav 11y agoThe model in the paper is offensively dumb. A basic explanation (taken from a web-forum where economists hang out): The paper says The model consists of N agents, each with capital ci with i = 1, . . . , N. Agents are allowed to trade among themselves M objects. Each object m = 1, . . . , M has a price πm. Starting from a feasible allocation matrix A, we introduce a random trading dynamics in which a good m is firstly picked up uniformly at random among all goods. Its owner then attempts to sell it to another agent i picked up uniformly at random among the other agents. If agent i has enough cash to buy the product m, that is if `i > πm, the transaction is successful and his/her cash decreases by πm while the cash of the seller increases by πm. In other words: 1. Prices cannot vary. The price a good is set in stone. 2. Agents do not purchase things they want. They "pick up" goods and immediately try to sell them. 3. They sell them at these pre-determined prices to other people, whether the other people want them or not. Well, there's no such thing as "want" in this model. 4. Nor is there any planning by agents. No ability for them to say "Crap, I only have $5 left. Better not spend it on this vase this guy is selling." Original discussion source: http://www.econjobrumors.com/topic/physicists-model-economic-inequality http://www.econjobrumors.com/topic/physicists-model-economic...
- logicrook 11y agoRandom models are very hard to analyze, so people rely on using very basic models - a good example is random graphs, where there is still a lot of research on the very basic Erdos-Renyi model, even if basically everybody is aware of its shortcomings regarding an accurate portrayal of real-world data (none). But it's a model where it's possible to get some good bounds for many problems, basically the only such model, so it's good for papers. But how those "scientists" deduce things on the real-world based on these simplistic models is utterly unjustifiable. In many cases, we know that some statistical properties show the models are inadequate, yet they still dare to write their BS about how "the internet" or "social networks" work based on such trivial models... (and the media disseminates these idiocies, like Ted and Wired...). Sad!
- pak 11y agoYou would be surprised how oversimplified most economic models are, particularly those taken as gospel. For instance, I won't deny that there are certain situations in which supply and demand curves are predictive (we all know how commonly they are cited to explain pricing in a market), but consider how many conditions must be assumed in order for them to apply as originally constructed: 1. The good is a commodity, i.e. its labeling has no effect on perceived value 2. The selling firms are perfectly competitive (i.e., no partial or complete monopolies that allow price-fixing) 3. The buyers are perfectly competitive (i.e., no purchasing groups) 4. All sellers can sell to all buyers equally easily 5. All parties in the market have equal access to information 6. All parties act rationally and based only on the marginal utility of each individual transaction etc., etc., and a whole litany of other things that we know are rarely true. Since the theory is so "squishy" in practice, one could even protest that it does more harm than good when treated as a de facto starting point for price modeling: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supply_and_demand#Criticisms https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supply_and_demand#Criticisms So this model, even if it too is sadly oversimplified, may still be useful simply by starting from a different set of assumptions than whatever is typical in the field, and seeing how the modeled behavior differs from existing theories. There's basically no hope of experimental validation for any of this, though.
- alanwatts 11y agoWhat is the root cause of economic inequality? I would argue it is rooted in the super admin - user relationship inequality of the monetary system and the inherent conflict of interest. A handful of super admins have the proprietary privilege to CRUD the money supply while the billions of other users have a limited privilege of simply using it.
- ktRolster 11y agoWhat is the root cause of economic inequality? Even if you solve absolutely all the problems related to the level-playing-field and give everyone the same chance, you're still going to have some people who produce more value than others. I would say that is the root cause.
- alanwatts 11y agoYes that may be the cause of marginal inequality in a meritocracy which most everyone would argue is better than oligarchy. But extreme inequality is where those with the most money (the "super admin" user group) produce negligible real wealth.
- ktRolster 11y agoAt least half of the Forbes 10 richest got wealthy by starting their own companies, so I'm not sure your analysis is correct.
- alanwatts 11y agoThose in the top 10 as ranked by Forbes are not super admins as much as they are highly privileged users. Bloomberg might be considered an admin of sorts due to his fortune being made on financial software. The real super admins are people like the current US Treasury Secretary who has the highest voting power on the board of governors of the IMF. This particular super admin made a fortune at Citi by betting on the global economic collapse of 2008 while hoarding cash in British tax havens like the Cayman Islands and was then promoted to his current administrative post.[1] This is a (sub) prime example of a super admin purposefully crashing the system in order to gain more power; greatly increasing global inequality in the process. This is a cyclical use case which has been occurring for hundreds of years in the global paper-based markets. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jack_Lew#Between_Clinton_and_Obama_tenures https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jack_Lew#Between_Clinton_and_O...
- ChuckMcM 11y agoA meta comment, but I'm really interested here. I tend to read the 'new' page a lot (I mostly see HN stories in the RSS feed rather than visiting the site) and there is a constant stream of "the economy is going to explode!" submissions. They are all based on loose reasoning and wild extrapolation (much like this one). I enjoy thinking about economics because I am fascinated by systems. And economic systems are pretty cool because we all participate one way or another, they behave in ways that we might individually dislike (like "fair" market values) and as we are all components in a larger machine we get to try to see the "big" picture to understand what actions are available to the individual cogs. And as the system arises as an artifact of our individual actions, it cannot "break", it can only "change". Further, when it does change it does so over months or years as peoples actions change and new equilibrium emerges. Many, if not most, of the stories posted take some aspect of the system and extrapolate it out to some weird end point. My favorite example is, "Housing is so out of control in SF soon nobody will be able to afford to live there." On its face, extrapolations like that are silly. If nobody lived in SF, there would be no companies and no businesses and no need for city services, it would be a giant scrubland. Which absolutely nobody believes would ever happen. It doesn't happen because prices rise until nobody (individual action) is willing to buy at the price, at which point sellers have to lower their price (individual action) if they want to move away and realize the economic value of their home. Or more crisply, the system adapts to what is happening and that adaptation becomes the new normal. So when I read these sorts of articles/stories, I always wonder "What are they really trying to say, the premise is clearly bogus so that can't be it." And in this particular case it seems to be trying to make people "care more" about inequality. Did you care more? If so why? If not why?
- akgerber 11y agoWhen people say "Housing is so out of control in SF soon nobody will be able to afford to live there," they mean 'nobody like my friends or me'— the system may reach a new normal, but it is a new normal where a city with lovely weather (and thus some of the US' lowest carbon emissions) and spectacular professional opportunities is closed to all but the wealthy.
- oldmanjay 11y ago