3 ms·
It really doesn't matter. All the modern (not literally home made from the raw materials) goods and commodities they have were delivered in very large part on m
by simonh 11y ago
It really doesn't matter. All the modern (not literally home made from the raw materials) goods and commodities they have were delivered in very large part on mainstream infrastructure. Roads, railway, through airports and cargo ports, etc. That includes every vehicle they drive, the fuel they burn, clothes they wear, food they eat. The electricity they use, even the fuel they use to run generators if they're off the grid (and the generators themselves). The cost of all that has to some extent been subsidised.
Modern economies and technological supply and support chains are so massively integrated that this is unavoidable. Yet most of us are obliviously unaware that they even exist.
- jessaustin 11y agoYeah that's fine but we've really moved the goalposts here. OP mentioned that OP had never received student loans or disability payments. Somehow that inspired a rude comment based on some very developed-world assumptions concerning public infrastructure. Yes, in most situations we see, it's good for public infrastructure to be built using public money. That doesn't mean that someone who e.g. purchases a kerosene lamp to light her home at night should feel thankful toward the government officials who haven't yet nationalized and dismantled the container port that offloaded it, who haven't yet closed the dirt road over which it was hauled by truck, whose military hasn't yet run the local store that sold it out of business for insufficient bribery. Hell, all the infrastructure we're discussing might well have been built during a previous government that was violently overthrown by the current one! Who should she thank in that case? When I was last in a "developing" nation, back in January, my hosts observed that the only existing paved road outside a large city, over which bus, truck, and agricultural traffic was solid day and night, was built and maintained by the federal government rather than the provincial one, because otherwise the money just disappeared. When we reflexively castigate those with questions about the use of public money (or frankly, in this thread, who are misunderstood to have posed such questions), we're protecting those who are glad for no questions to be asked. That's true in both "developing" and "developed" nations.