3 ms·
Software development is not the same as Computer Science... Even then, it's a small part of STEM, and beyond that, how much shortage is there, really? In the e
by tracker1 11y ago
Software development is not the same as Computer Science... Even then, it's a small part of STEM, and beyond that, how much shortage is there, really? In the end, I've seen far better results from self-starters that try than graduates with C.S. degrees that don't.
I think that there is a lot of arrogance in the software industry, and it tends to do far more harm than good. It bubbles certain mindsets and pushes out others. In the end, it does little for what's being worked on, and when good enough solutions that work are displaced by "best" solutions that come out months/years late and/or outright fail.
In the end, you can get a LONG way with pragmatic choices... you can go even further, with consistently simpler ones. The more complex something is, the more likely it is to fail when you need it to grow the most. Time and time again, people just don't see this. I've been guilty of it myself.
You don't need a C.S. degree, or a bootcamp, and honestly, if you do, you're probably not enough of a self starter to actually be productive, help and work with a team checking your ego at the door anyway. I'm guilty of this myself at times. But the debate is pretty silly. Nobody should go six figures into debt for a job that starts out at less than six figures. And nobody should expect to master anything in much less than a couple years.
What often bugs me more than anything is institutional resistance to anything new.
Okay, going to sign off this messy rant... I just find the whole debate the article makes irritating, as it's the people more than the process that determine success.
- npx 11y agoI like to think that software can actually be perfect, and that "good enough" is the mortal enemy of excellent. I agree regarding arrogance, though... I think it's insane to imagine that the insertion sort (for example) is somehow more innovative than the plane, train, automobile, or combine. I think that you can actually get very far in terms of educating yourself with the materials and tools that are now publicly available. I'm currently spending a lot of time doing this, so I suppose it's an axiom that I've accepted. https://github.com/hypoalex/machine_learning/blob/61d6729489cfa9d68bcd585bae692627304e0f1d/classes/MIT/18.01/lectures/lecture_1.ipynb https://github.com/hypoalex/machine_learning/blob/61d6729489... For instance, I personally find Jupyter Notebooks many times more useful than traditional course notes. They're executable, they can be revisited and expanded upon, and they're actually used commercially... so you're killing many birds with one stone. It would be a very different world if the first thing you learned in high school was version control and Python, but it might actually be one worth living in.
- tracker1 11y agoPerfect is entirely subjective though... One software usage that I usually rally against is DI/IoC usage... most of the time it only adds indirection and complexity that hinder the development of an application and rarely help it. Time and again I see it used in conditions where there aren't multiple implementations of interfaces, and there isn't any testing at all. So it serves no purpose in these contexts, but is argued as "better". That's just one piece, but one I've consistently come up against. There's also the more functional vs. classical (class oriented) approaches. In any case you can come up with "perfect" is entirely subjective... and if it takes significantly longer, it's rarely the better option.. so long as every piece is modular enough that it can be ripped out, rewritten or replaced easily, and with that mindset in play... then it isn't even good enough.
- pacala 11y agoWhat's valuable is the practice. In sports, in music, in coding. The value of the CS degree, for the people that try, is that they spent the better part of four years coding something. As compared to someone that hasn't, and now it's the team's job to carry the slack.
- Retra 11y ago> You don't need a C.S. degree, or a bootcamp, and honestly, if you do, you're probably not enough of a self starter to actually be productive That really depends on how you're measuring productivity. I needed to get a CS degree to become a good programmer. Not because I'm not a 'self-starter', but because I self-start in so many different ways that I'll avoid becoming a great programmer and instead become a mediocre musician, painter, runner, mathematician, teacher, cook, physicist, biologist, historian, novelist, and programmer. Among other things. I love learning and mastering things. But I don't have the self-control to abandon everything else I love in the world to just do programming unless I've got a dedicated channel for doing that. That doesn't mean I'm not a self-starter.