7 ms·
The idea of a university as a free space rather than a safe space is vanishing
- marcoperaza 11y agoWhen moral relativism is your religion, anyone with moral conviction is your enemy and must be silenced. What's most pitiful is the cowardice displayed by all who should know better. University trustees and professors, business leaders, entertainers, and every last one of us who has ever surrendered to this tyranny in our schools, our jobs, or our communities. Instead of fighting back, we capitulate and cower in fear for our reputations and livelihoods. Seeing this in my own country, America, especially disgusts me. How many good men have put down their lives to secure for us the blessings of liberty. Today, we lack the confidence and courage to even raise a word in their defense.
- dalke 11y agoYou left out an important dimension. The modern trend is to run everything "more like a business." The heads of universities come decreasingly from academia, and re instead MBA and politically connected people. This is justified by the need to bring in more money, because the states no longer want to fully fund the university. My belief is that businesses don't like controversy unless it brings profit. Free speech at a university rarely brings profit. So people who want to run a university like a business are not likely to fight against calls to reduce free speech on campus. And there have always been calls to reduce free speech on campus. Or to repurpose your phrase, "When business and profits are your religion, anyone with moral conviction is your enemy and must be silenced." "How many good men have put down" See, that's the sort of sexist language that encourages knee-jerk reactions, and gets people like me labeled "PC". My wife deployed twice to Iraq. Don't you dare leave out all those women who have died for the US, including nearly 200 in Iraq and Afghanistan.
- marcoperaza 11y agoI'm inclined to agree that "running things like a business" is part of the reason why no one wants to make a stand. But I have to disagree with this: >Or to repurpose your phrase, "When business and profits are your religion, anyone with moral conviction is your enemy and must be silenced." It's not the businessmen who are trying to shut down free speech and debate on college campuses. >See, that's the sort of sexist language that encourages knee-jerk reactions, and gets people like me labeled "PC". My wife deployed twice to Iraq. Don't you dare leave out all those women who have died for the US, including nearly 200 in Iraq and Afghanistan. You're totally right, so while we're at it, I've gone back and fixed an old quote: "One small step for a man or a womyn, one giant leap for man- and womyn-kind". I think I could get that one through even toughest SJW language police. What do you think? Seriously though, I didn't mean to refer to only men. (edit: Perhaps "good people", as suggested below, would have worked too.) I used the term in the broad sense, referring to human beings in general. The modern trend is toward politically correct phrasing that makes a butchery of the English language. I don't see how the phrasing is any more sexist than "mailman", "fireman", or "salesman", which are commonly used in the gender-generic sense. Interestingly, there are many female chairman who insist on being called "chairman", not "chairwoman" or "chair".
- loup-vaillant 11y agoIdioms are a bitch. I'm no native speaker, but I see no good alternative to "good men". "Good People", maybe? But I bet native ears would cringe a bit.
- marcoperaza 11y ago"Good people" would have worked fine, though at some cost to dramatic impact. The really barbarous constructions are things like "he or she" as the third-person singular pronoun. There's five camps I can think of on this: 1) Keep using "he" as the gender-generic third-person singular pronoun. This was the only accepted option for a long time. I think this is the best sounding, but some crowds might give you grief for it. 2) Use "he or she" every time. This is the worst. 3) Use a mix of both "he" and "she", but obviously be consistent when referring to the same abstract person. I like this in theory, but in practice, the "she"s pops out of the page and direct attention away from what you're trying to say. 4) Use "they". This seems to be winning, though many find it to be a grammatical abomination, since "they" is supposed to be plural. 5) Always use "she". This is how you let everyone know that you have a political agenda.
- michaelbuddy 11y agoThey don't run ît like a business, more like a political campaign + foundation + corrupt gov't. Donors, dealmaking, mandates, taxes.
- michaelbuddy 11y ago> See, that's the sort of sexist language that encourages knee-jerk reactions, and gets people like me labeled "PC". My wife deployed twice to Iraq. Don't you dare leave out all those women who have died.... You actually went there. In this thread. Unreal.
- dalke 11y agoI am not calling for a safe haven, or restriction on speech, which is what the main topic concern. Instead, I am using my speech to criticize someone else's speech, which is what "free speech" is supposed to encourage. Why shouldn't I go there in this thread?
- loup-vaillant 11y agoOkay, I'm lost: why the downvotes? This sounds like reasonable comment, even useful (the first sentence is a good summary of the article's subject). I see no attack to any particular group. What in this comment could possibly rub HN the wrong way?
- lizardskull 11y agoMaybe the majority of the readers are in a university.
- hartpuff 11y ago> why the downvotes? This sounds like reasonable comment Happens all the time here, unfortunately, but questioning why is a waste of time. Half the posts in this thread - ironically about free speech - are grey. The surprising thing is that your post isn't, simply for mentioning the D-word.
- loup-vaillant 11y agoThat reminds me: http://lesswrong.com/lw/mm/the_fallacy_of_gray/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/mm/the_fallacy_of_gray/
- over 11y agoI think it's just that there's a lot of dramatic and hyperbolic words and phrases in there, here's a list from a quick pass: > religion, anyone, conviction, enemy, must, silenced > most, pitiful, cowardice, all, should, every last one of us, ever, surrendered, tyranny, fighting, capitulate, cower, fear > my own country, America; disgusts, good men, put down their lives, secure, blessings, liberty, lack, confidence, courage, even, a word, defense A few of these would be fine.
- marcoperaza 11y agoDramatic is the right tone here. We are seeing the collapse of intellectual freedom and openness in the places where it was supposed to be valued most. This does not bode well for our civilization. My generation, the millennials, holds free speech in much lower regard than previous generations. http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2015/11/20/40-of-millennials-ok-with-limiting-speech-offensive-to-minorities/ http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2015/11/20/40-of-millen... . Everyone who values freedom should be very alarmed.
- mc32 11y agoIt is indeed a sad day when people, that is, students, are censored by their own. It's astounding that this would happen being that through disagreement and argument is how we find our better ways. My sentiment is that here is the one place where we should feel free to share our ideas no matter how immature or adolescent they are. This should be the place where we get to open up and explore. But, as they say, the left and the right have conspired to silence discussion and only received opinion is welcome. Here's the relevant quote: "In other words, and not for the first time in history, the far left is allied with the far right, and drags the soggy centre along whimpering behind it."
- hartpuff 11y agoAnyone who uses terms like "the left" is pretty much announcing where they are coming from, and that their argument is almost certainly going to be simplistic and flawed. Take this excerpt: Surely the left believes in secularism and despises the superstitions that have held humanity back? Not so, and not for a long time. If "the left" believes in secularism and atheism, and the people he's talking about oppose secularism and atheism, why does does he conclude this means "the left" no longer believes in secularism, rather than the people he's talking about are not actually "the left"? He claims "Feminists, gay-rights campaigners, anti-fascists and anti-Islamists" are being sanctioned or persecuted. So the left is against feminists, gay-rights and anti-fascism? What do those groups represent then, "the right"? If there's one claim socialism and communism can make, it's that it's diametrically opposed to Islamism, as evidenced in numerous post-war socialist, secular Arab countries, Afghanistan in the 70s and 80s, and in the fact that leftists have been persecuted and murdered in every Islamist state from Saudi to Iran. In any case, the ‘left’ as I suppose I have to call it Why does he have to call it "the left" if even he states they hold "reactionary views"? Because he's pandering to a right-wing audience on a right-wing website.
- mc32 11y agoFor the most part, I take it to mean the academic intellectual left. Yet, I think this dive into who Cohen is referring to is a detour which misses the point. The regrettable issue is various groups (left, right, whatever) within academia being able to establish taboos and enforce topics non-grata, to the detriment of thought exploration and discussion by the student body as well as the faculty.
- naringas 11y ago<tin-foil-hat> Is it just me or is education being slowly but steadily subverted in many countries at once? </tin-foil-hat>
- bsder 11y agoSort of. But it's more pernicious than that. What is the purpose of going to a University/College? The purpose SHOULD be education and enlightenment. The purpose has BECOME vocational training for a job.
- naringas 11y agoDo you think that most universities are starting to operate like corporate businesses? with corporate priorities and corporate practices?
- alricb 11y agoI'm not British, so it's hard to judge, but I'm not entirely certain the interpretation he gives of the events cited are completely accurate. This is a man who supported the Iraq invasion and accused protesters of harming the civil rights of the citizens of Iraq.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- csense 11y agoPopehat, a blog of free-speech lawyers, is a great source for in-depth articles on this kind of thing. Two recent examples: [1] [2] [1] https://popehat.com/2016/02/19/williams-college-our-students-are-children-and-we-must-protect-them/ https://popehat.com/2016/02/19/williams-college-our-students... [2] https://popehat.com/2016/03/08/marc-randazza-something-doesnt-click-here/ https://popehat.com/2016/03/08/marc-randazza-something-doesn...
- noonespecial 11y agoThe real tragedy is that university used to be a place where you could be convinced that some of the ideas you had going in might be wrong. Now the only thing that's being taught is that certain people just aren't allowed to speak at all. People who used to have their ways of thinking changed at university are now leaving silent, angry, and still wrong.
- Spooky23 11y agoUniversities have a lot of overhead these days, and to paraphrase Mel Brooks in Blazing Saddles, the assistant deputy vice provosts say "we gotta protect our phoney baloney jobs".
- tomlock 11y agoThe author seems to reminisce about a time when universities were pure outlets of free thought. At that time women were vastly outnumbered by men in universities. The time when universities were pure and free for everyone exists only in the authors imagination.
- CyberDildonics 11y agoYou didn't back up anything you were saying. It looks to me like women crossed the majority in 1960. http://blogs.berkeley.edu/wp-content/uploads/2011/05/gender-college_goldin-et-al-2006.jpg http://blogs.berkeley.edu/wp-content/uploads/2011/05/gender-...
- chongli 11y agoRead the graph more carefully. That is birth year, not graduation year.
- CyberDildonics 11y agoGood catch. That would be 1978 for enrollment and 1982 for graduation.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Houshalter 11y agoI don't see any contradiction in what you are saying. Perhaps the demographic change caused this, or it could be entirely unrelated.
- matt_wulfeck 11y agoWe're becoming a society that values having or feelings affirmed rather more than having the truth affirmed. Is this not at the core of what we're seeing?