2 ms·
"It's overly verbose, condescending, and allows you to give the appearance of resolving a debate when all you've actually done is talk down to a sock puppet."
by greenyoda 11y ago
"It's overly verbose, condescending, and allows you to give the appearance of resolving a debate when all you've actually done is talk down to a sock puppet."
I agree with your criticism of the article's style. But to be fair, if you're arguing with yourself (as the author is), it's not really the Socratic Method, which is a dialog with another person. If you don't get to control what questions the other person asks, it makes for much a more interesting conversation.
- me_again 11y agoAgreed- if there are 2 real people debating, it's much more bearable. Ironically some of the canonical Socratic dialogs (http://www.gutenberg.org/files/1643/1643-h/1643-h.htm http://www.gutenberg.org/files/1643/1643-h/1643-h.htm) have the same problem - Meno's slave is too obviously Plato's mouthpiece IMHO.
- jacques_chester 11y agoSock-puppeting is rife in Plato's books. And it is just as infuriating as Bob Martin's writing is. But I agree with Martin more than I do with Plato. Take that as you will.