2 ms·
Despite what you may feel, animation and UI/UX are extremely important I disagree. Well-conceived and well-executed animations can be a nice incremental refine
by Silhouette 11y ago
Despite what you may feel, animation and UI/UX are extremely important
I disagree. Well-conceived and well-executed animations can be a nice incremental refinement on top of an already good UI. However, they won't compensate for poor static elements like a bad layout or naff icons or illegible typography. In turn, no amount of beautiful UI whether animated or not will compensate for awkward interactions or a flawed conceptual model.
Motion is a great tool to hide latency
You know what's also great for hiding latency? Designing your system properly so it doesn't have noticeable latency in the first place, which is a viable alternative in the overwhelming majority of cases I've seen advocating this sort of animation-as-band-aid.
give some spacial awareness
You know what's also great for giving spacial awareness? A UI layout where the space is used logically in the first place and different areas of significance are clearly presented. Step 1: Don't dumb everything down to nothing but flat colour boxes and line art, thus giving up a whole array of other useful visual tools and creating a whole set of problems you didn't otherwise have.
can be an additional tool to give quick feedback on an action
True enough, but the key word there is "additional". Animating in response to every user interaction looks cute in demos for trivial gimmick apps, but gets old very quickly if you're using serious software for extended periods with numerous interactions per minute. There's also a frequent irony that those trivial gimmick apps tend to run on mobile devices with touchscreens, so all those clever button animations are right under the user's finger where they can't be seen anyway.
I've personally found its one of the major reasons the "average" person chooses software.
Really? I've never seen much evidence to suggest that in all my years doing UI design work. Much of the time, the user won't even have seen most of the animations before making a decision about whether to use the software or not. They're a nice incremental refinement, helping to reinforce an already well-designed and well-presented UI, but a major reason for choosing software? That seems highly unlikely.
- Klathmon 11y agoYou seem to be implying that I'm advocating you should give up working on a good UI in favor of animations, which I'm saying the opposite. Animations are a tool, and should be applied carefully just like any other. I chose my words carefully and I stand behind them. Animation is important, and it can be a great additional tool to improve usability of an application. It's not the only tool, but an additional one. About my last line, I was talking about design and UI/UX in general, probably should have been more clear about that...