5 ms·
$115M verdict in Hulk Hogan sex-tape lawsuit could wipe out Gawker
- seunosewa 11y agoThe $115m verdict seems excessive. It vastly exceeds the damage done by the offense and the benefits gained by the perpetrators.
- brohee 11y agoIt's supposed to be punitive right?
- ksherlock 11y agoThe $115 million is compensatory ($55 million for economic harm, $60 million for emotional distress). Punitive damages haven't been decided on yet.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Khaine 11y agoIt takes into account that gawker ignored a court order and kept the video up1. They are absolute scum. And then to be such hypocrites about the fappening. Good riddance to such rubbish. 1 http://gawker.com/a-judge-told-us-to-take-down-our-hulk-hogan-sex-tape-po-481328088 http://gawker.com/a-judge-told-us-to-take-down-our-hulk-hoga...
- ikeboy 11y agoThe post you link to says they took the video down, only leaving the post up. One would think someone would read posts before citing them as a source, and notice if it actually says the opposite.
- Khaine 11y agoIts funny, because the wikipedia article says the opposite: In April 2013, Gawker wrote, "A judge told us to take down our Hulk Hogan sex tape post. We won't." It also stated that "we are refusing to comply" with the order of the circuit court judge. And so does the archived version of the page.
- dalke 11y agoFrom April 27, 2013, http://www.skyvalleychronicle.com/BREAKING-NEWS/GAWKER-SAYS-NO-TO-COURT-ORDER-IN-HULK-HOGAN-SEX-TAPE-CASE-1333410 http://www.skyvalleychronicle.com/BREAKING-NEWS/GAWKER-SAYS-... : > A Pinellas County Judge, Pamela A.M. Campbell issued an order Wednesday directing Gawker to remove a video of Hogan (real name Terry Bollea) purportedly having sex with the ex-wife of a disc jockey named "Bubba the Love Sponge" Clem, as well as a 1,400-word narrative about the tape and hundreds of user-submitted comments. > The site did take down the video, but the narrative and comments remain on the site with the website's attorney, Gregg Thomas saying the order to remove that material infringes on the website's First Amendment rights. So, yes, the video was taken down. No, the post concerning the video was not, despite the court order to do so. I believe "Hulk Hogan sex tape post" refers to the latter commentary post, not the actual video.
- ikeboy 11y ago>A lawful order from a circuit court judge is a serious thing. While we vehemently disagree with Campbell's order with respect to the video itself, we have chosen to take it down pending our appeal. From your own link, which you clearly didn't bother to read even after I pointed out that it contradicts what you said.
- mikearagua 11y agoI'll allow it.
- forgetsusername 11y ago>It vastly exceeds the damage done by the offense What is your calculus? "Hulk Hogan" is a brand that has been around for almost 40 years. The release of the video ruined it; he was fired from the WWE. I don't know what the real number is, but significant value was lost.
- mcguire 11y agoAccording to the article, the portion of the tape that caused his firing was not included in the Gawker article. "Bollea's reputation took a huge hit last year, and he got fired from his job at World Wrestling Entertainment. That outcome wasn't fallout from the Gawker article, however. In a section of the sex tape that could be described as "pillow talk" (which wasn't published by Gawker), Bollea went on a racist diatribe. He repeatedly used the N-word and other racial insults, expressing disappointment that his daughter was in a relationship with a black man. The racial epithets were leaked by other news sites, including Radar Online and the National Enquirer."
- Eric_WVGG 11y agoWhat I'd like to know is, would a sum like that be handed to someone who wasn't a celebrity? Seems a little plutocratic to me. [edit] Another comment here splits the judgement into $50m economic harm and $65m emotional distress. I'm not arguing against the first figure, obviously a celebrity has more money and earning potential that is capable of being harmed. But I don't think they're capable of being distressed any more than the next person.
- rayiner 11y agoA celebreity's sex tape is going to get much wider viewing than some random person's. Your typical person wouldn't be walking down the street and have everyone recognize them and think of their sex tape even if it was on the Internet.
- Kristine1975 11y agoSo they published a privately made video about people having sex without those people's consent? Yeah, good riddance Gawker. I'm still hoping the Condé Nast CFO sues them for outing him: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gawker#Cond.C3.A9_Nast_CFO_prostitution_claims https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gawker#Cond.C3.A9_Nast_CFO_pro...
- raverbashing 11y agoYes, that's pretty much it Oh and with an added contempt of court: a Judge ordered them to take it down and they refused
- chimeracoder 11y ago> Oh and with an added contempt of court: a Judge ordered them to take it down and they refused Not just that: a Judge ordered them to take it down and they published an article bragging about their refusal.
- chris_wot 11y agoYup, that's an extra $15 million. Serves them right. I'll bet all the staffers who made crude jokes and laughed at a guy having consensual sex with someone in what they thought was a private, intimate act wouldn't be very happy if the same was done to them. This whole argument that public people don't have ANY right to privacy is utterly absurd, and Gawker have been very much been brought down to earth - hard. And funnily enough, thought I cant stand the man - they've been super critical of a variety of unethical and outrageous things Trump has said and done. But Trump hasn't ever published a sex tape, and defied a court order to remove it!
- vermontdevil 11y agoHow different is this from Snowden giving top secret documents to Greenwald et al? It's the "compelling news interest" so I think it falls under the First Amendment for Gawker. I wouldn't be surprised it'll be overturned on appeal. But Florida does require a bond to be put up and it's significant. This might hamstring Gawker while they go through the appeals process.
- triztian 11y agoHows is this hacker news?, I mean; seems like another Kim K story....
- anonymousab 11y agoGawker is a major media org which had and has a lot of influence over online news reporting. Going further than that, this judgement may be useful in determining how future, similar acts are treated by the courts.
- afarrell 11y agoThis article written by Justices-to-be Warren and Brandeis about the right to privacy is always a good read: http://groups.csail.mit.edu/mac/classes/6.805/articles/privacy/Privacy_brand_warr2.html http://groups.csail.mit.edu/mac/classes/6.805/articles/priva...
- rnernento 11y agoI was a regular Gawker reader for a while, their salacious stories are hard to resist. Eventually I realized they were crossing lines, both in their aggressive attacks toward individuals who didn't really deserve it and their general preference for sexy headlines and clicks over actual stories and reporting. If this really does bring down Gawker I will consider Hulk Hogan one of the great heroes of our generation. Hopefully it will cause other "news" outlets to step a little more carefully in regards to casually ruining someone's life.
- erelde 11y agoio9 had a really good selection of writers and topics. I could go there to get good recommendations for books, SF, fantasy, fiction in general. It has really changed in the last year or so, and even more since its fusion with gizmodo.
- waylandsmithers 11y agoThey definitely benefitted from usually being first in "race to the bottom" journalism.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoReally? The guy that spends half the time on tape making racist remarks? I don't know, 'hero' isn't the first word that crosses my mind.
- windowsworkstoo 11y agoHulkamania is running wild, Brother! Whatcha gonna do when Hulkamania destroys you?
- alexandre_m 11y agoWatcha gonna do when Hulk Hogan runs wild on your wife, Brother! Distribute the sex tape then make you earn 115 millions.
- TillE 11y ago
- philjohn 11y agoAnd nothing of value was lost.
- J_Darnley 11y agoThe discussion attached to the BBC's version of the story can be found here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11315985 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11315985 (135 comments)
- zamiang_brennan 11y agoI'm a bit confused why people are taking the side of Hulk Hogan. Maybe the dislike of gossip news is blinding people to the larger free speech implications. Do you think a publication should be able to publish facts about a person? Do you think a publication should be able to publish facts about a person without their consent? Do you think a publication should be able to publish facts about a person that were initially obtained illegally but were given to the publication? (see wikileaks…etc) If you answered 'yes' to all 3, what principals (or ideally…laws) let you side with Hulk Hogan?
- Thriptic 11y agoAt the end of the day I am forced to agree with you. Is the publication of this content morally wrong? Yes. Are the publishers pieces of shit for doing this? Yes. Is what they did illegal? Unless they committed a crime to obtain the content, I would have to say no.
- Delmania 11y agoIt's not illegal, but it publishing someone's intimate details without his consent falls into the realm of civil law.
- Kristine1975 11y ago>Do you think a publication should be able to publish facts about a person? Yes. >Do you think a publication should be able to publish facts about a person without their consent? Depends. Is it important that other people know these facts, as in "will they be harmed/make bad decisions if they don't know them"? (Think knowledge about a politician.) >Do you think a publication should be able to publish facts about a person that were initially obtained illegally but were given to the publication? (see wikileaks…etc) See question two.
- WizardlySquid 11y agoThere's a massive difference between wikileaks who report on human rights violations of governments and Gawker posting a sex tape with the intent of ruining a person's life.