5 ms·
Arguments Supporting Warrantless Surveillance Wither When Exposed to Sunlight
- themartorana 11y agoSecrecy is key. In any conceivable circumstance, where one branch of government operates in total secrecy from the other two, the spirit, at least, if not (but most likely) the letter of the Constitution and its explicit power checks have been violated. When one starts writing and interpreting its own laws in secret from the other two, well... I don't see how it amounts to anything less than a (non-violent?) coup, where one branch has gone completely rogue. But as time and again, no heads will roll, no one will go to prison for making the Free World significantly less free. And I'm pretty sure domestic surveillance now is significantly more advanced than it was back when this letter was written. Is there anything left to hold on to? Edit: I should stop reading. I'm starting to believe that ignorance is indeed bliss.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- AnthonyMouse 11y agoThese things have clear patterns. King George abuses his subjects so they kick him out and adopt a constitution prohibiting the things he did. From time to time, usually in response to some kind of hyped up threat, they crop back up. Hoover's FBI, The House Un-American Activities Committee, Nixon and now the response to 9/11. They go too far and eventually get shut down, but often not before a decade or more. Then we try to pass a law to prevent what they did from happening again, hopefully this time learning from our mistakes and making the law against it airtight. Our major mistake last time seems to have been allowing the process to be secret.
- matt_wulfeck 11y ago> Then we try to pass a law to prevent what they did from happening again, hopefully this time learning from our mistakes and making the law against it airtight. We have evidence in countries like North Korea that government can keep total power and control against their population for a very long time. I know you don't intend it to be, but your response seems kind of like a "things will sort themselves out so let's not worry ourselves". It's this sort of apathetic response to wrongdoing that is the precursor to many evils in history.
- AnthonyMouse 11y agoYou're right, it's quite the opposite. This has happened before and now we have to do it again, but we actually have to do it again -- we now have to stop it and pass new laws against it and hopefully do better this time. In other words, it's likely to happen, but only if we don't say "it's likely to happen" and then not try to make it happen because we assume it's inevitable. The fact that your side is right and usually wins in the end doesn't mean you can win without fighting. We still need to raise hell until the work is done. "The price of liberty is eternal vigilance."
- kabdib 11y agoThe oppression in NK is one of the things that the second amendment is for. As it stands, the people of NK have no options. Arms in the hands of citizens is not a guarantee against abject oppression, but it's a deterrent. Banning general ownership of arms is a step that a despot must take. Naturally, a lot of people think the insurance is not worth the risk. And at the level of national politics it can be hard to separate the honestly concerned, the secretly malicious, and the useful idiots. ---- With crypto, it's pretty easy. The folks who want to ban crypto have an agenda to spy and control, or they are co-opted. Well, there are also a few useful idiots, too . . . .
- nitrogen 11y agoI should stop reading. I'm starting to believe that ignorance is indeed bliss. Ignorance is only bliss until your well-intentioned life accidentally runs into a law you didn't know existed that is now too late to change.
- rayiner 11y agoI kind of agree with the overall conclusion, but the EFF is overstating their Youngstown Steel argument. As a preliminary issue, it's important to note that we're talking about spying that might be outside FISA but is inside the 4th amendment. Spying is a routine military activity that is intrinsic to foreign relations, an area where the Constitution gives the President unique powers. Seizing steel mills, on the other hand, is a major intrusion into domestic activity within Congress's usual domain. It's not so clear why Youngstown would direct the conclusion here. More generally, there are a lot of people who believe that the framers intended to give the President great powers when it came to foreign relations and the exercise of military power, and didn't intend for Congress to be able to check those powers. One of the motivating rationales of having a unitary executive was so that the government could respond to internal and external threats decisively without waiting for hundreds of senators and congressman to get on board. It was set up that way to address the concerns of people who thought that a democracy would be weak and indecisive in the face of foreign threat.
- Zigurd 11y ago> there are a lot of people who believe that the framers intended to give the President great powers when it came to foreign relations and the exercise of military power, and didn't intend for Congress to be able to check those powers Foreign relations, yes. The exercise of military power, no. Especially not creating a permanent wartime condition, secret courts, etc. where military power, including spying, is exercised within the US and against the people.
- tptacek 11y agoYour comment is unresponsive to Rayiner's in two ways. First, it has simply never been the case, since the time of the Presidencies of the founders themselves, that espionage was limited to times of war, or for that matter to countries with whom we had declared war. The President has always been able to spy on other countries. Second, Rayiner himself concedes the distinction between spying on US citizens (an activity restricted by the Fourth Amendment) and spying on foreigners abroad (an activity not restricted by the Fourth Amendment).
- 11y ago
- citizensixteen 11y ago>The government’s ponderous declassification process released this letter far too late to have much more than historical impact. But, in the end, the secrecy clouds parted, and the pattern is clear; we’re back in a place we’ve been time and again. One-sided legal arguments lead to one-sided legal interpretations. The government’s secret process let it get away with drafting an entire 22-page letter that did not even cite let alone grapple with these issues. If there is one thing history teaches us, it is this pattern that repeats itself over and over. For example look at the Stasi of East Germany. The Stasi did everything it did to protect the state and the 'people'. When we look at these totalitarian governments of past, we are shocked and can not believe people allowed it to go on. It is much harder to see these patterns in the present context of our own culture and even harder to do something when things go wrong. Next time you are in Berlin visit the old Stasi headquarters. http://www.stasimuseum.de/en/enindex.htm http://www.stasimuseum.de/en/enindex.htm
- natch 11y agoReading Tim Cook's full interview with Time (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11318905 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11318905) I wonder if anyone at the DOJ is even having an honest discussion about the potential damage they would be doing to public safety if they won in court in the San Bernardino case. Which, granted, is a different case from what the EFF is talking about here but the same question applies: Is the DOJ even considering all the implications of what they do, and how they may be making us less safe by things like requiring back doors and (separately) enabling man in the middle scenarios?
- x5n1 11y agoPeople that make up the DOJ want to win. They never consider the implications of their wins. They are sort of like Charlie Sheen.
- xfour 11y agoWhich in the end appeared to be a backlash of being diagnosed with HIV, so taking your anecdote to its full conclusion the DOJ is sickened with a terminal illness they haven't come to terms with dealing with.
- rgbrenner 11y agoThe DOJ/FBI does not care about the damage. If they win, they get the benefits.. but all of the costs--weakened security, lost money, damage to companies, etc--are ALL external. Don't kid yourself, when all of these things happen, the FBI will not stand up and criticize itself... it'll blame the company that made/maintained the backdoor. When your company (or the company you work for) is compromised because of the backdoor the government mandated, it'll be your company's name on the notice being sent to your customers saying you lost their data; your company in court for the damage caused; your company that will foot the bill.
- jessaustin 11y agoNot only will they receive the direct benefits, but FBI will actually benefit from everyone else's suffering as well. Just like bored firefighters starting fires (a real thing that has happened many times in many places), they're eager to "help" those individuals and businesses who will lose lots of money after they've destroyed security online.
- jbapple 11y agoThe author of the memo, John Yoo, was also famously pro-torture, including the most shocking answer on the treatment of suspected terrorists that I've heard from any part of the political establishment (so I'm excluding the large numbers of Americans who think, for instance, that we should just make Islam illegal): Q: If the President deems that he's got to torture somebody, including by crushing the testicles of the person's child, there is no law that can stop him? A (John Yoo): No treaty. Q: Also no law by Congress—that is what you wrote in the August 2002 memo A: I think it depends on why the President thinks he needs to do that.
- Zigurd 11y agoThis is the thing: The DoJ lawyers behind the Apple case are little John Yoos, turning America into an unrecognizable place because, hey, a victory at lawyering is all they are interested in.
- joshka 11y agoI'm anti-torture personally, but I'm not sure that the quotes you've put here portray a bias one way or another so much as a legal opinion (erroneous or otherwise). What am I missing?
- jbapple 11y ago> I'm not sure that the quotes you've put here portray a bias one way or another so much as a legal opinion (erroneous or otherwise) John Yoo's legal opinions were used by the Bush administration to justify a system of torture up to and including permanent injury, sexual assault, and death. If he had issued these opinions in a vacuum, I would agree with you. Instead, he sought opportunities to provide legal cover for systemic human rights abuses. The consequences of his actions seem predictable, and in my view that makes him partially morally responsible for them and it is fair to call him an advocate of them, in deed and word. You can read about it in the CIA torture report and the DOD torture report: https://www.amnestyusa.org/pdfs/sscistudy1.pdf https://www.amnestyusa.org/pdfs/sscistudy1.pdf http://www.armed-services.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/Detainee-Report-Final_April-22-2009.pdf http://www.armed-services.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/Detainee-... There are a multitude of US laws against torture, but Yoo and his intellectual cohort seem to think that the "Unitary Executive" is not bound by most laws, as long as that executive proclaims the actions are part of a war (which does not need to be declared by Congress, under Unitary Executive theory that rejects the War Powers Act). Finally, I posted this snippet to point out that John Yoo has a history of dismissing limits to executive power to an extreme degree. Even if his theories are viewed outside of the moral consequences of his actions, I think it's important to know that his view on surveillance goes WAY, WAY beyond just warrantlessly listening to the phone calls of innocent people, all the way to, according to him, crushing the testicles of innocent people. I think this helps frame the discussion of the history of the Bush administration's abuse of civil liberties, though you are welcome to disagree.