8 ms·
Lufthansa jet and drone nearly collide near LAX
- mchahn 11y ago> at an elevation of 5,000 feet That is not a hobby drone. I could never get mine to that height.
- vmorgulis 11y agoProbably and hexa or octocopter: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GfxdeRx2fLA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GfxdeRx2fLA
- berkut 11y agoPhantom's can get quite high: http://www.dnaindia.com/scitech/report-watch-a-stupid-drone-user-flies-a-dji-phantom-2-straight-up-11000-feet-2188024 http://www.dnaindia.com/scitech/report-watch-a-stupid-drone-...
- Animats 11y agoThere are videos of a Phantom 2 drone, which is under $500 used ($1300 new) reaching almost 11,000 feet.[1] [1] http://www.ibtimes.co.uk/11000ft-dji-drone-flight-record-attempt-slammed-idiotic-dangerous-by-uav-hobbyists-1548057 http://www.ibtimes.co.uk/11000ft-dji-drone-flight-record-att...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- torkable 11y agoJust watch for a youtube upload with a "fuckin sick flyover footage of a jet, brah"
- Animats 11y agoYesterday, we had this article on YC [1], from some economist at the anti-regulation Mercatus Institute, claiming that a drone strike was very, very unlikely. That guy assumed that drones are distributed randomly across airspace. In practice, they tend to be near where people live, which means cities and airports. I posted the FAA's list of drone sightings near LAX yesterday. Today, this. The pilot of the aircraft, a Lufthansa A380-800, reported seeing the drone above him. The reported near miss distance of 200 feet is very close for an aircraft with a 260 foot wingspan and a tail tip 60 feet above the pilot. WTF is someone doing flying a drone at 5000 feet over downtown LA in the LAX approach path? That drone operator needs to be found and arrested. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11290674 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11290674
- iofj 11y agoKeep in mind that there are definitions for these terms. "near miss" means coming up on 200 meters distance between two objects if > 400 meters up, otherwise it means whatever the tower decides it means (and presumably for them it means being in controlled airspace at all, e.g. having a drone above the airport building itself)
- funkyy 11y agoNo. Any distance of up to 1,000 meters is "near miss" for uncontrolled (by tower) object around the passenger plane. There is no "but I was far enough" bs. Person than do not flight A LOT or do not pilot PASSENGER planes will never understand of the risks, stress and increasing field for error. Pilot, when preparing for landing is suppose to be 99% concentrated on whats below him.
- chasing 11y agoNear miss: "The drone flew 200 feet over the aircraft, the Federal Aviation Administration said."
- jjwiseman 11y ago> WTF is someone doing flying a drone at 5000 feet over downtown LA in the LAX approach path? That drone operator needs to be found and arrested. Los Angeles has already effectively criminalized flying drones in most of the city. In October 2015 the city passed an ordinance that requires drone pilots to get "express authorization" from all airports within 5 miles[1]. This was done despite the fact that it is stricter than the FAA's requirement/advice for drone pilots to "notify" all airports within 5 miles[2] (Two months later, in December 2015, the FAA published a fact sheet trying to discourage local drone regulations that could result in a patchwork of confusing laws around the country[3].) In January 2016, LA charged two drone pilots under the new ordinance for flying drones within 5 miles of _heliports_[4], indicating that they considered heliports to be equivalent to airports. The pilots are facing misdemeanor charges that could result in a fine and up to 6 months in jail. The thing about heliports in LA is that they're everywhere! Probably 80-90% of LA is within 5 miles of a heliport. And not just one--if you wanted to fly your drone in the field next to the Silver Lake Reservoir, you'd probably have to get authorization from 7 or 8 heliports. It is, effectively, a ban. [1] https://t.co/lst2RzoY5q https://t.co/lst2RzoY5q [2] http://fromwhereidrone.com/can-you-fly-your-drone-within-5-miles-of-an-airport/ http://fromwhereidrone.com/can-you-fly-your-drone-within-5-m... [3] http://www.faa.gov/uas/regulations_policies/media/UAS_Fact_Sheet_Final.pdf http://www.faa.gov/uas/regulations_policies/media/UAS_Fact_S... [4] http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-ln-city-attorney-drones-20160120-story.html http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-ln-city-attorney-dr...
- szx 11y agoThis might be a naive question, but what would happen if a hobby drone collided with a jet? As long as it doesn't hit the engines, wouldn't the damage be negligible?
- DataJunkie 11y agoDisclaimer: Aviation hobbyist but not an expert. It depends on the size of the drone and where it hits. I am not sure how large these drones are, but if they have the mass of a flock of large seagulls, say, it could disable an engine (like the US Airways jet). A collision with a wing could cause substantial damage to the wing which would change the aerodynamics, and that could be potentially dangerous at low altitudes because of the neighborhoods underneath. Debris could fall from the sky and injure or kill someone. I doubt it would come close to tearing off a wing. A collision with the fuselage could breach the cabin which is dangerous in itself, but would not cause a decompression at that altitude. A collision with the windscreen of the flight deck would be dangerous for obvious reasons. In the minor case, it can blind the pilots temporarily. In the worst case, debris from the drone would incapacitate the pilot during the most dangerous phase of flight: landing or departure. What is really dangerous is the speed at which the aircraft hits the mass of the drone. It may seem like the aircraft would just kill the drone, and that is probably the case with most drones, but if it has large mass, it wouldn't. The most dangerous scenario is if a drone hits the control surface like the flaps (very important for landing), or the horizontal stabilizer in the tail, it could be disastrous.
- iofj 11y agoThe airflow would be trying to prevent a collision with the front of the wing, and a drone would simply go where the wind blows. Which is to say if a drone flew straight for an airplane wing, it would fly around the wing and suddenly explode in the massive turbulence behind the wing. This would look very surprising because to the naked eye there is nothing behind the wing. Hitting the fuselage, or entering an engine is probably more realistic. Both would be expensive, but won't be a threat to the passengers. Maybe hitting the wingtips would be doable ... not sure.
- beachstartup 11y agofor those of you who don't know the geography of los angeles, LAX is basically surrounded on 3 sides by dense urban buildup, and then the ocean. the flight path for landing goes over the entire city including downtown, and the runways are sandwiched by freeways and major boulevards on all sides. the approach at night is quite dramatic visually, if you're lucky enough to snag a window seat. i very much enjoy trying to identify everything as i fly over. it truly is "the motherboard". people who have never flown in before are shocked to see it. it's something else. the only thing that compares in the US is probably chicago, but it's not the same scale, and LA also has geography which adds to the visual drama. tokyo is similar but not quite the same kind of approach. i don't recall any airport in europe even approaching the visual appeal of the LAX approach. i've never flown into mexico city, from looking at maps it's probably close, but physically it's nowhere near as large as the LA metro (including IE, OC, etc.). LA is huge. yuuuuuge. it is bounded by office highrises, datacenters, hotels, and housing. in my opinion it's likely the most dangerous airport in the US in terms of potential damage from a non-terrorist crash. i can't think of any airports in the US that are quite the same. it's currently the global #5 volume airport but the insane amount of traffic from asia will probably make it #1 within a few years. there is a major expansion and renovation project happening right now.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- chx 11y agoA few more of this and realistic or not and the FAA will ban any drones in a significant radius of any aerodome effectively ending most drone activity. The Canadians already did. https://www.reddit.com/r/vancouver/comments/3h2e8t/for_all_of_the_responsible_droneuav_pilots_out/ https://www.reddit.com/r/vancouver/comments/3h2e8t/for_all_o... you want to fly a drone here in Vancouver, you better get a permit. The fines start at $1000 and they are finding people.
- joelrunyon 11y agoIs there anything preventing manufacturers from limiting the height drones can fly? I'm not particularly pro-regulation, but this seems like a scenario where it seems quite necessary.
- cjhveal 11y agoIf I recall correctly, GPS receivers for non-military use are specifically designed not to operate over 60,000 feet altitude or 1,000 knots velocity. So it's not un-precedented.
- Veratyr 11y agoAnd like GPS receivers, anyone who DIYs can get around those restrictions themselves: http://www.aholme.co.uk/GPS/Main.htm http://www.aholme.co.uk/GPS/Main.htm
- FranOntanaya 11y agoSeveral commercial models are already capped at 120m or so. With DIY ones though it's not so easy.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- newman314 11y agoI think drones are cool and would love to get one. However, I think there are too many entitled asses that pretty much think they can do whatever they want. You wouldn't believe th number of drones they now have flying at cars and coffee events. I'm also fairly certain that none of these drone operators have insurance so imagine the scenario of drone operator (likely without a whole lot of experience) + many expensive cars (but that's not the point). Not gonna end well. Sooner or later, a drone strike will happen if left unchecked.