5 ms·
> I'm on a H1-b visa and I'm basically in prison I know this is an exaggeration, and I'm fully aware the current visa situation in the US could be better, but
by Alupis 11y ago
> I'm on a H1-b visa and I'm basically in prison
I know this is an exaggeration, and I'm fully aware the current visa situation in the US could be better, but I really take issue with the sentiment of your statement.
You're being afforded an enormous opportunity here, and should not compare it with being in a prison.
Think about it -- you clearly decided your home country was not as conducive for building your future as the US may be, and therefore applied for (and accepted) a visa. Now it's up to you to prove value in allowing you to remain in the country. A visa is a privilege, not a right.
Literally billions of folks around the world are never given this opportunity.
- DKnoll 11y agoThink about it -- you clearly decided your home country was not as conducive for building your future as the US may be Hi, as a Canadian, I also take issue with your statement. Your ancestors came here for the same reason as him, and with far less scrutiny, same as mine, and were provided many benefits not recieved today, including land grants. Why does a person migrating today deserve to be treated as second class?
- ConfuciusSay02 11y agoCall it second class is different than comparing it to being in prison. People in actual prison might take issue with your statement.
- DKnoll 11y agoPeople in prison would likely take issue with a lot of things unreasonably, which is likely why they're in prison to begin with.
- ConfuciusSay02 11y agoYou think it's unreasonable to take issue with comparing someone on an h1b visa to being in prison?
- DKnoll 11y agoI think I made that pretty clear. I'd add petty as well.
- phibit 11y ago> Your ancestors came here for the same reason as him, and with far less scrutiny, same as mine, and were provided many benefits not recieved today, including land grants. There has been a dramatic change in economic and social climate in the Americas. Our vague "ancestors" entered Canada and the US in times where it might not have been so magnificent to immigrate, and as such they were presented with incentives to immigrate and contribute to a growing economy. Never mind that some of our ancestors came in as refugees fleeing war and communism. Today, both Canada and the US have the right to protect their national interests and prioritize the development of their own citizens above the interests of foreign nationals. All countries do this, even those perceived as the most accepting.
- DKnoll 11y agoCanada just accepted 25,000 Syrian refugees fleeing war and something much worse than communism. The social and economic climate has changed dramatically, you're right. We no longer have a climate condusive to a free-for-all exploitation of Aboriginals, Africans, and the environment.
- phibit 11y ago> Canada just accepted 25,000 Syrian refugees fleeing war and something much worse than communism. This is to my point, there is less scrutiny for immigrants in 'dire straits'. > The social and economic climate has changed dramatically, you're right. We no longer have a climate condusive to a free-for-all exploitation of Aboriginals, Africans, and the environment. Unclear how this goes to show that anybody should be allowed to immigrate anywhere under any conditions. Edit: straights -> straits
- arcticfox 11y agoThey have not become a citizen just because they have a work visa. If they become a citizen, of course they shouldn't be second class. They've been given a visa for a specific purpose, and in the eyes of the law are not "first class citizens". If your argument is that we should grant citizenship to anyone that wants it: OK, vote for it.
- lnkmails 11y agoWell, as a H1B visa holder paying same taxes as citizens, I either need the country to provide me a path to citizenship or stop taxing me like citizens. I can go either ways. Your ancestors fought for taxation without representation. I come from a democracy too and yes my country is not as conducive as United States for starting businesses but I just won't be made feel inferior to citizens because I was born elsewhere. That is against the promise of the constitution especially when I live in continental United States. Also, seriously, if I can work indefinitely on a visa without citizenship, I am 100% happy to do that. There is a 6 year cap unless you express willingness to migrate or stay in home country for a year before getting another six years. So your government is disrupting my life in many ways that they don't to the citizens. It seems unfair.
- arcticfox 11y agoI can see why it's better for you if the US government doesn't tax you, but why is it better for the US? It is a nice place, and I hope you're able to become a citizen at some point if you desire to, but until then the priorities of the US are with its own people. "Taxation without representation" doesn't apply here, because you aren't forced to live or work here. You do have representation in your own government, which is exactly what the founders of the US fought for. They did not fight for the right to go work in other places, like the UK, untaxed.
- rifung 11y ago> Why does a person migrating today deserve to be treated as second class? You don't go into someone else's home and then expect to be treated like family. I don't think immigration policy is really centered around morality or what people "deserve" but, like with most government policy, looking out for the interests of the country.
- nailer 11y agoIt's in the interests of countries to have the best and brightest in the world starting businesses there.
- phibit 11y ago+1 from someone who has been on H1-B, I recognize it as a great opportunity and privilege. The option to return to my home country was never taken away from me, and at every step I knew I retained the freedom to simply quit my job and leave; I did not do that. No, an H1-B does not afford you the privilege of switching jobs or careers easily. There's no reason to think it should, and that is made very clear during the application process.
- ellemedit 11y agoTo use your phrasing, literally millions of Americans don't even meet the minimum quality bar to even qualify for a TN/H1B if they were to do it from scratch. Maybe Americans will be well served to understand that the current visa regime is severely dysfunctional, and that it serves to boost egos of more incompetent and uneducated Trump-ians, and less the interests of US in obtaining talent and even less in giving brilliant minds all over the world an equal playing field.
- DrJid 11y agoI agree that with your sentiment about it being a privilege, not a right. As an immigrant right now, out of school, even getting an H1-B is so hard, that I'd do anything just for that visa. You can at least join a program like Unshackled or become a Global Entrepreneur in Residence at a University while working for you startup. However, the metaphor about it being a prison isn't so farfetched either. It's likes writing book in prison, vs writing it not in prison. You can still write the book - They are just different scenarios.
- inopinatus 11y agoYou might want to reconsider the strong language. Firstly, do you know the individual concerned? If not, the assumption about someone's motivation for living and working in the US is problematic. Secondly, I find a contradiction in these remarks. You "take issue with the sentiment", which is clearly one of feeling trapped by the visa rules. But the line of "it's a privilege, not a right" and the demand to "prove value in allowing you to remain" simply reinforces the systematic entrapment, by threat of withdrawal of privilege. In particular, it denies the individual any moral right to change the system. So I suggest those remarks actually reinforce the sentiment, rather than challenging it. Such a scenario is commonplace in many jobs, and the more toxic the boss, the more likely it is to occur. A more creative suggestion out of that logical trap might be that a visa should be a right, not a privilege, since it permits a broader range of contribution towards both GDP and cultural wealth. But now I betray my own leaning towards high levels of international migration for all.
- dang 11y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11314923 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11314923 and marked it off-topic.
- eldavido 11y agodang, the variety of behaviors you witness each day would make for a great book in itself. Sign me up, I'll buy the first copy!
- sethd 11y agoIt's not prison but an H1-B is basically indentured servitude.
- phibit 11y agoIf you are going to boil things down very basically, all jobs are basically indentured servitude. That's why they call it "making a living".