4 ms·
I love the twist of submerging almost the entire barrel in the ocean, pretty awesome to wrap your brain around how that could actually work out. It was also rea
by zaroth 11y ago
I love the twist of submerging almost the entire barrel in the ocean, pretty awesome to wrap your brain around how that could actually work out. It was also really interesting to hear Hunter's thoughts that even if the physics all works and launch costs could be cut 1/10th, how it would still be unworkable for someone SpaceX to invest in the R&D alongside their reusable rockets.
- maxander 11y agoIt would be interesting to see a quantitative head-to-head comparison, but my guess would be that once you have the technology to retrieve first-stage rocket engines after launch space-guns aren't economical- the fuel used lifting the engine itself may be expensive, but the energy losses from hitting sea-level atmosphere at ~8km/h would have to be astronomical. ...As it were.
- gvb 11y agoSpaceX appears to be competitive even without reusing the first stage: At its 2013 launch price and at full LEO payload capacity, the Falcon 9 v1.1 cost $1,864 per pound ($4,109/kg). Ref: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falcon_9#Launch_prices https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falcon_9#Launch_prices From TFA: The cost was roughly $1,727 per kilogram, adjusting for inflation. By comparison, Nasa estimates that it costs $22,000 per kilogram to launch a modern satellite into orbit using conventional rockets.
- mrfusion 11y agoI disagree. With a rocket you have to lift all your fuel. With a space gun the fuel stays on earth and only the payload goes to space. Look up the rocket equation to see what a huge difference this makes.
- maxander 11y agoDoes it, though? I mean, I've played KSP, I know the rocket equation. But with a space gun, your vehicle only winds up moving as fast as the propellant pushing it out- so that mass of fuel (more explosive than fuel, I guess) still has to be accelerated to near-orbital speeds in order for the gun to work.
- pizza 11y agoWhat about a railgun or some similar accelerator prior to the first stage?
- vlehto 11y agoRocket engines are light. But rockets need lots of fuel. The problem is lifting all the fuel.