4 ms·
BI reeks of the same lazy centralized thinking responsible for the very trends that cause BI to seem necessary. After feedback, BI will just raise rents a corre
by mindslight 11y ago
BI reeks of the same lazy centralized thinking responsible for the very trends that cause BI to seem necessary. After feedback, BI will just raise rents a corresponding amount - broken monetary policy simply speeds up the debt treadmill to funnel the added surplus upwards. And income always comes with strings attached, so increased centralized command would be inevitable. The end result is an even larger underclass being socially engineered from Washington.
Restore sane monetary policy so most people can accumulate wealth. Rebuke the broken Silicon Valley VC model of proprietary systems that further concentrate the N^2 wealth from Metcalfe's law into a few rendezvous bottlenecks. Only then can we have a chance at a functioning economy in the face of increasing technological progress.
- drabiega 11y agoConsider that BI has been agreed to be a good idea by a variety of well regarded intelligent people on both sides of the political spectrum. If anything, offhand dismissal is the lazy attitude here. > After feedback, BI will just raise rents a corresponding amount Basic Income is inherently redistributive. The prices of goods are inherently based on the distribution of income. It is pretty reasonable to expect the balance of prices to adjust given the income redistribution. > And income always comes with strings attached The point of BI is income without strings, so could you explain how this is impossible? > Restore sane monetary policy Could you explain what you regard as sane monetary policy?
- mindslight 11y ago(My criticism could seem like "offhand dismissal" because you're quickly reading it, not because I spent little time thinking about it.) > Could you explain what you regard as sane monetary policy? Restoring the ability for non-upper-class people to save. Specifically, ending the policy of forced inflation that prevents the lower class from saving in cash, and pushes the middle class into simulated "investments" to slow the erosion. Technological progress means prices should be getting ever-cheaper, so the effects of forced inflation get ever-worse - an economic treadmill that favors income (with accompanying requirements) over minor wealth (which can be wielded as one pleases). > The point of BI is income without strings That is the initial intention and design, but all systems evolve. BI creates an income stream at the mercy of politics, which are the biggest strings that can be attached. Imagine the same "drug users on welfare" rhetoric applied to even more people. > Basic Income is inherently redistributive But still subject to the rent treadmill, which will simply recollect the distributed money upwards to the money printers and associated artificial industries (eg by increasing the arbitrary capital cost of a place to live, raising the carrying cost aka rent). BI seems like a solution because it goes right along with the trends of centralization, but it's those very trends that are causing the economic pain in the first place!
- Apocryphon 11y agoWhile I feel you might be being too dismissive of BI, I do appreciate this comment because there seems to be a prevailing conception of seeing it as a panacea for the problems brought by automation. UBI simply on its own shouldn't be enough to fix everything. It's good that people are critiquing it against the hype.
- mindslight 11y agoMy comment probably seems dismissive because I'm taking issue with the singular premise of BI, as opposed to pontificating about its many possible effects. (And I guess that "lazy" - originally it was directly describing SV's popular centralized information architecture, but it really is applicable to all centralizing thinking) Do a thought experiment - imagine claims on future BI were allowed to be sold. There's currently a lucrative trade in turning structured settlements into immediate lump-sum cash, and it's often looked down on as exploitive. What economic incentive keeps BI payments from being deannuitized in such fashion? If your immediate thought is to pass a law prohibiting that, then you seem to agree that it goes against current economics. My fundamental point is to think about that economic gradient, what makes it so, and how that underlying problem can be reformed. Because otherwise BI just seems like adding fuel to the fire, regardless of laws to make the burning less efficient.