6 ms·
Email reveals Clinton worked with Google CEOs to keep Benghazi video blocked
- cryoshon 11y agoSo... whatever happened to "Don't be Evil"? This incident depicts the US government asking for clandestine political cover from a multinational corporation, and receiving it. The State Department was the organ by which this unity of corporate and political power was achieved. A candidate currently running for election was at least in part responsible for the underhanded censorship of information from the public. These favors end up being repaid at some point, because that is how politics works. I doubt we will be informed about the nature of the favor that will be transacted from the US government to the credit of Google.
- 27182818284 11y ago>So... whatever happened to "Don't be Evil"? They actually dropped it: http://time.com/4060575/alphabet-google-dont-be-evil/ http://time.com/4060575/alphabet-google-dont-be-evil/
- cuckcuckspruce 11y ago>The State Department was the organ by which this unity of corporate and political power was achieved. You can call this what it is: fascism.
- brador 11y ago> So... whatever happened to "Don't be Evil"? Google is a for profit corporation, not a person. It has a fiducary responsibility to maximise profit and investor returns within all legal bounds. Nothing else matters in the long term, no matter how much you might wish it.
- RodericDay 11y agoThere Is No Effective Fiduciary Duty to Maximize Profits https://medium.com/bull-market/there-is-no-effective-fiduciary-duty-to-maximize-profits-939ae50d0572#.7xoi4zn44 https://medium.com/bull-market/there-is-no-effective-fiducia...
- brador 11y agoIt is implicit and accepted.
- koberstein 11y agohttp://www.newyorker.com/cartoons/a16995 http://www.newyorker.com/cartoons/a16995
- 16bytes 11y agoTo be clear, here's the relevant text: "Sue just called back and theblockwill staythroughMonday" I don't get why this would be considered evil or even underhanded. It's normal operating procedure for various government organizations to ask media outlets to postpone publication due to time sensitive events. For example, say the NY Times is going to publish a piece on civilian causalities in Afghanistan by CIA operatives on the ground. The DOD might come in an ask for a couple of days to prepare deployed forces that there might be some sort of retaliation. This saves lives and isn't censorship--the piece is still published--but is a necessary interplay between media and government. In this case, where early reports say that violence and riots are being spurned on by the availability of a video online and you have local assets there, why is it wrong to block for a couple of days? I would argue that this is exactly what should have happened in the state department given the amount of knowledge they knew at the time. This isn't a partition issue. I would expect that every administration since WWII would have made similar requests to media organizations.
- cryoshon 11y ago>I don't get why this would be considered evil or even underhanded. It's normal operating procedure for various government organizations to ask media outlets to postpone publication due to time sensitive events. It's a form of censorship, so it's both evil and underhanded. The government does this kind of stuff all the time, and it's really just a tactic to prevent ugly things from coming out whatsoever, though they claim it's temporary. Certain reports have been "requested" to be delayed for well over a year. This is standard procedure, but it's illiberal and undemocratic because it presumes the public doesn't deserve to know what is going on during the time period in which it is possible to change course. In criminal court, we call this tactic "distancing", because it allows tempers to cool off due to the temporal distance between the offense and the trial. From your perspective, it's the US government looking out for itself-- but your perspective is not the only one. Consider that people were willing to riot over this information that was blocked. Do you think that they consider the blocking to be a beneficent act in order to save lives? No, they view it as an empire protecting itself by covering up things it doesn't want seen.
- 11y ago
- travmatt 11y agoJulian Assange's book regarding his conversation with Eric Schmidt ('when google met wiki leaks') depicts google as a company becoming increasingly intertwined with the existing power structures of government, especially the state department.
- lallysingh 11y agoBut the whole thing is a massive conspiracy theory based on ridiculous tainting inference. It's like seeing Bill Gates ask if Clinton is thirsty and then bringing her a drink, and concluding that Microsoft is an arm of the State Dept. Really, the whole thing reads a bit like Ancient Aliens. I can't be the only one who reads it this way.
- Someone1234 11y agoWhat specific video? I mean, yes, it is interesting that state asked Google to block something on YT, but knowing what video is highly relevant to understand the significance.
- dublinben 11y agoThis is likely in reference to Innocence of Muslims[0] the movie which allegedly prompted the attack on the US embassy in Benghazi. It can be easily found on Youtube today.[1] [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Innocence_of_Muslims https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Innocence_of_Muslims [1]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vl2-NyONaL8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vl2-NyONaL8
- obvio171 11y agoTitle taken from Wikileaks' tweet: https://twitter.com/wikileaks/status/710855886940540929 https://twitter.com/wikileaks/status/710855886940540929
- devereaux 11y agoThat to me seems like a good reason to have your own private email server. (add appropriate sarcasm tag) How will she scratch back Google once elected? What kind of favors will be exchanged??
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Jgrubb 11y agoI was wondering this the other night will looking at the bar chart at the top of the "Democratic Primary Results" query result. Bernie's behind for sure but if you removed the superdelegate portion, which they've had in there from day one, it looks much less like a runaway lead. Rather maddening as a Bernie supporter, but I guess that's the way the game gets played.
- talmand 11y agoMore the way the game plays you.
- grandalf 11y agoGoogle is the Halliburton of information.
- VikingCoder 11y agoIf I understand correctly, it's possible that someone in the State Department asked Google to temporarily take down a YouTube video, which they believed was actively inciting murderous violence against our embassies. I'm okay with that. If the government had attacked a private individual's server, and taken it down, that's different in my mind. But YouTube does and should reserve the right to not host content, yes? Perhaps the Terms of Service have changed (they probably have), but they currently include rules like: Violent or graphic content - It's not okay to post violent or gory content that's primarily intended to be shocking, sensational, or disrespectful. If posting graphic content in a news or documentary context, please be mindful to provide enough information to help people understand what's going on in the video. Don't encourage others to commit specific acts of violence. Hateful content - Our products are platforms for free expression. But we don't support content that promotes or condones violence against individuals or groups based on race or ethnic origin, religion, disability, gender, age, nationality, veteran status, or sexual orientation/gender identity, or whose primary purpose is inciting hatred on the basis of these core characteristics. This can be a delicate balancing act, but if the primary purpose is to attack a protected group, the content crosses the line. Perhaps in the heat of the moment (and with lives on the line), everyone made a bad decision. The video is actually currently available, so maybe they have changed their minds about some or all of this. But yeah, I'm okay with this. I may change my mind when more evidence comes out.
- zaroth 11y agoMy understanding is that there was never any rational basis or honest belief that a YouTube video was ever "inciting murderous violence against our embassies." It was a smoke screen to try to blunt the impact of what the expert reports at the time described as a well-planned terrorist attack. But I guess if you have to pick between gross incompetence or lies and cover-ups, you can take your pick, or perhaps the truth is just, "yes".
- Bud 11y agoYour folks have had years now to show any—any—proof of "lies and coverups", and they have utterly and laughably failed. So perhaps the truth is just, "no", instead.
- Bud 11y agoToo much to ask for "Benghazi" to be spelled correctly? Also, this is overblown, doesn't mention Clinton, and DOES mention that this email was already voluntarily given to House Select Committee on Pretending That Benghazi is a Real Issue (aka Gowdy-Doody Time).
- kafkaesq 11y agoToo much to ask for "Benghazi" to be spelled correctly? Apparently, yes.
- talmand 11y agoOther than it saying "Hillary Clinton Email Archive" at the top implying where it came from and it says "Office of the Secretary" in the email itself? I mean, I understand the committee thing was a waste of time but don't pretend with your obvious bias that absolutely nothing happened here.
- Bud 11y agoYes, whereas you of course have no bias! Let's be honest: everyone has made a judgment about whether this is a real issue or not, by now. My point, however, was a factual one: this particular email was a) voluntarily disclosed, and b) does not mention Clinton or substantiate the allegation in the headline, and c) also fails to show that anything untoward occurred here.
- talmand 11y agoWhat exactly is my bias you detected in my statement?
- kzhahou 11y agoYT bans videos all the time. Why does this incident make Clinton or Google "evil"?
- krapp 11y agoBecause Hillary Clinton is running for President and certain parties want to imply a criminal conspiracy on her part regarding the Benghazi attacks.
- obvio171 11y agoI wonder if anyone at Google would resign over something like this, or if everyone has already rationalized it away and now just keep their head down for the next paycheck. Some people definitely do go in with very strong principles, but those seem to dilute quickly.
- talmand 11y agoI see nothing wrong here. It appears it was an informal request that a private company could have nicely said "no" in response. YouTube is taking down videos all the time due to informal requests that have no authority of law behind them, no one complains that much about those.
- 13thLetter 11y agoThe Secretary of State calls up and asks you to take down a video and that's an "informal request"?
- monster3234234 11y ago^ this.
- Bud 11y agoYes. Period, paragraph. An important person can make informal requests, too. A formal request would cite legal authority. Interesting, btw, that you assume that Clinton did this directly, despite zero evidence. Seems just as possible to me that a staff member would have made the request.
- talmand 11y agoThe President of the United States of America can personally call you and request that you take the Trump sign off your lawn. That is an informal request unless he can specify what law he is enforcing that you must be in compliance. You can politely or impolitely respond in any way you wish regardless of the fact of the position the man currently holds. If there is a threat to you for non-compliance of his request, then he has likely broken the law.
- 13thLetter 11y agoIf it was Condoleeza Rice who had made this request a lot of people in this comments section would be singing a different tune.