5 ms·
Full disclosure: I'm a Greek immigrant in an English-speaking country (the UK), working and studying part-time in an English-speaking workplace and university.
by YeGoblynQueenne 11y ago
Full disclosure: I'm a Greek immigrant in an English-speaking country (the UK),
working and studying part-time in an English-speaking workplace and university.
I parse this article as a very typical pair of complaints:
a) There's too many foreigners here.
b) Their English is bad.
On (a) the population of China is 1.3 billion, the world population
is 7.4, so one out of every 7 people on the planet is Chinese. You should expect
there to be more foreign people from China than anywhere else, outside China. It
should be surprising if there aren't.
The same goes for India: its population is 1.2 billion. And, surprise-surprise,
you hear the same complaints about Indians, particularly in IT workplaces, but
also in universities.
Note that because everyone else has less than 1 billion population, there's less
than one of every other ethnicity for each Chinese and Indian person, so the
stand-out effect is even more pronounced.
So, not any serious complaint here, just people who haven't looked at the
numbers and think they live in a different historical period where international
travel was harder.
As to (b) I personally find this distasteful. Everyone else except native
English speakers has even worse trouble communicating in English with non-native
English speakers, yet you don't hear as many complaints about it. I have trouble
getting what Chinese students are saying in English, as they have trouble getting
what I say in English. Well, duh. Human communication is a bitch. If there is a
God, he's got a lot to account for with the Tower of Babel malarky and whatnot.
But listen, this is how communication works: you meet the other person halfway.
You have to make as much of an effort to understand what the other person is
saying as they have to, to make sure you do. That's true even when you both
speak the same language natively. It's amazing -no, it's a bloody miracle- that
we can communicate at all. Anyone who's studied human languages is struck dumb
by the mind-boggling improbability of it. It's crazy that we can even get our
point across with a lot of effort, let along effortlessly.
So yeah, quit complaining and just learn to understand what others are saying,
in spite of the language barrier. That's what an educated human does.
- Shaanie 11y agoThe difference is that in American universities English is the primary language, and if you can't communicate in English then you shouldn't be attending somewhere where English communication is required. I disagree with your assertion that I should have to make as much of an effort to understand them as they have to, when they are the ones visiting another country. I wouldn't attend a Chinese university without making sure I can effectively communicate in Chinese (or whatever language is used there), and I expect the same courtesy from other people.
- elevenfist 11y agoThe problem is neither of what you mentioned. My concern was universities catering to cheaters because they pay more to attend.
- contingencies 11y agoGood summary, though I think your numbers are out of date: I believe China is closer to 1.4 and India's population is estimated as having exceeded that of China of late.