3 ms·
I noticed supercomputer vendors and Oracle are using ChipKill plus ECC. Does adding that change the results any or still reduce to DOS?
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
I noticed supercomputer vendors and Oracle are using ChipKill plus ECC. Does adding that change the results any or still reduce to DOS?
- tdullien 11y agoSo I do not know (in the mathematical sense) that ChipKill won't create a problem, but I think it is unlikely. In general, if the ECC infrastructure works (e.g. DRAM detecting bit corruption and reporting it to the OS), the odds of an attacker finding a piece of RAM that flips bits "just right" to bypass the checksumming without triggering a OS panic are low enough that I'd rather worry about software bugs. DoS may still be a pretty viable attack, though.
- baruch 11y agoIt can mitigate the DoS if you have enough spare RAM. if you are right on the edge that removed RAM will turn into an OOM condition and will become a DoS.
- darkr 11y agoNot just supercomputer vendors - Chipkill has been a standard option on IBM X-Series (their standard server range) for years now. I remember deploying a whole bunch of servers back 2011 or so that had it.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoAppreciate everyone's insightful replies. :)