5 ms·
First, educated and immigrants of means are a great addition to any economy they go to and a drain to the economies they leave. It's understandable why educate
by mc32 11y ago
First, educated and immigrants of means are a great addition to any economy they go to and a drain to the economies they leave. It's understandable why educated people might want to leave a country with few economic opportunities for their careers.
What I'm not so clear on is what attracts educated people of means to emigrate to the US [and AU and UK] from otherwise stable mature economies? We're better off for them, just a question as to what attracts them given they also have opportunities in their home countries.
- rayiner 11y agoYou can make a lot more money in the U.S. From entrepreneurship, of course, but Professionals and executives get paid way more in the U.S. too.
- mc32 11y agoThat's true; however, the stereotype is that in a lot of places that are not the US, except for China, value other "social cohesion" characteristics of their economies over "crass" pursuit of money. If that stereotype still has merit, then it implies the ones who come here are the ones who believe in US-style economics over their homelands' --which is neither here nor there, just an observation.
- bkanber 11y agoIt's simple: the US economy is huge. It's bigger than Japan, Germany, France, Brazil, and the UK combined. It's got the same GDP as the EU and as China, but half the population (and 1/4, respectively). No matter where you are, the US can be a step up -- as is indicated by the OP. These are exactly the immigrants you're asking about, and they came for a shot at exactly this, which they couldn't get back at home. Incidentally, here's a cool infographic: http://graphics.wsj.com/global-growth/ http://graphics.wsj.com/global-growth/
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- hibikir 11y agoI come from Spain, and the situation was very easy: Spain's cities have a midwest-like cost of living. A programmer there, right out of school, is what we call a mileurista: Someone with a take home of about a thousand Euros a month. In comparison, my first job in the midwest paid three times that. And that's the difference at the beginning of a career. Nobody programming over there will make more than, maybe, 3500 euros a month, unless they start their own company. Last year, I went past 18K a month, in a stable, 9-5 job. The market is so good, I could quit my job any day I want, and I get to choose among a bunch of great alternatives, including bay area companies that hire remotes. In comparison, Spain has about 20% unemployment. If anything, I would ask other programmers from Spain why in the world aren't they leaving!
- cplanas 11y agoAs a fellow Spaniard, how you got to the US? H1B?
- brianwawok 11y agoSo this plus even browsing job postings around England (which I can do better than job postings in Spain porque mi Espanol no es bueno), this seems generally true. So big question. WHY are software developers paid so low in 1st world European countries, and so high in the US? Clearly a good software developer can save a company 100k, 200k, 500k Euros a year (think of replacing a bunch of office workers with a computer program). Why don't programmers get a bigger chunk of the pie? GDP says the countries are fairly similar. Programming is a high skill job. Why would it pay so different in different locations?