5 ms·
They promised secure communications and when the government made it impossible for them to legally continue to offer that service, they shut down rather than be
by taneq 11y ago
They promised secure communications and when the government made it impossible for them to legally continue to offer that service, they shut down rather than betray their users.
As far as I can see, they delivered on their promise.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoNo, he promised secure communications, developed a dumb design that tied all users to one secret, and folded rather than divulge it. Fortunately, others learned from his mistake in designing better services.
- taneq 11y agoIn hindsight, yes. It's possible (although seems naive these days) that he didn't actually believe he had to count his own government as hostile.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoNo, in foresight. It was so dumb that secure messaging from 80's and 90's did better in various ways. High assurance already settled on proxies, guards, and per message crypto due to many attacks possible. Hushmail put the needed functionality in an applet to avoid relying on just web tech. Then, there was Lavabit founder acting snobby talkinv about how he used same security as banks. What might that be? HSM's for keys, link encryption, and per user policies? No, one SSL key protecting everyone like a generic website. Ohhh.... Definitely foresight on my part when I avoided that and similar services. Not to mention I thought they'd 0-day the servers. Still not sure why they didnt. You dont need US government in your threat profile to know top notch hackers like Chinese, Russians, and Israelis might target you to see who you're hiding with "bank style" security. Note: I protect my Hacker News posts with bank-grade security. I require a login, name, and HTTPS on all posts. I feel safer already.
- taneq 11y agoYou make a lot of good points. Have a bank-grade-security upvote.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoI appreciate it lol.
- MichaelGG 11y agoWikipedia says Lavabit complied with previous search orders. They just chose to take a stand. They did not create a secure communications platform. Any email sent to a user would be delivered plaintext (SMTP), and nothing stopped Lavabit from intercepting that info other than them saying so. This is why (afaik) Silent Circle stopped offering their "secure" email system, because Lavabit made it clear that such a service is not really secure. As a side note, Snowden also used Cryptocat so the fact he used Lavabit isn't necessarily a positive endorsement.