5 ms·
That's basically the wonder of capitalism. An accelerated form of Darwinism. People try random things, until someone tries the right thing at the right time, an
by cm2187 11y ago
That's basically the wonder of capitalism. An accelerated form of Darwinism. People try random things, until someone tries the right thing at the right time, and it succeeds and takes over. That person is then labelled a genius, everyone think he knows what will happen next, he thinks of himself as a genius, and he will give his opinion on everything, until someone else hits another sweet spot and takes over...
- i2shar 11y agoYou put into exact words what I always had in my head but hadn't articulated. So very true about all products and companies around us.
- md224 11y agoJust remember that Darwinism is a morally neutral process: evolution only cares about the survival of the entities in question. Likewise, capitalism thrives when businesses thrive; everything else is just a means to an end. Not saying it's bad... just neutral. And it may have very good consequences for society as a whole. The only danger is believing the process is "good" in of itself.
- mjburgess 11y agoCapitalism isn't morally neutral because it concerns collectives of moral agents (companies), their goals and the goals of their customers and those they interact with. Evolution operates on genes, an amoral physical process. Capitalism is the operation of people, a morally-laden process.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Retra 11y agoThe only thing evolution and markets have in common is that the terms 'selection process' and 'organism' apply to both. And even then, they mean different things. Don't take the analogy too seriously.
- marklgr 11y agoRight, they are very different things. GP's point about morality stands, though: it's orthogonal to both markets and evolution.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ne01 11y agoI 100% Agree! But, I also want to add that I believe you can start a very profitable business with careful planning that relies less on luck and more on your hard work! In my opinion people behind high-profit-margin startups that were bootstrapped with no venture capital and were profitable from day 1 are the real business "geniuses". Example: my good friends at basecamp.com Edit: I like to add why I think Basecamp is a good example... first of all they are not my actual friends, I just like their take on how to do business. In case you don't know one of the co-founders (David Heinemeier Hansson) is the creator of Rails. They are all about creating a profitable long-lasting business from start and I very much admire that.
- noir_lord 11y agoAlso Fogcreek and to an extent Atlassian. I actually like reading about companies that set out to solve a genuine business need, make some money and treat staff well. It's not as 'sexy' as billion dollar valuations for "Uber for Cats" though.
- dilemma 11y agoI actually think it's a lot "sexier."
- ellius 11y agoTaleb nails this in The Black Swan. He describes how capitalism is NOT meritocratic, it's more like it encourages people to blow huge sums on improbable ideas and, occasionally, they work.
- thanatropism 11y agoBy Taleb you surely mean von Mises, by von Mises you surely mean Schumpeter, by Schumpeter you surely mean Karl Marx. The speculative nature of capital has always been a core theme in economics. Yes, including "freshwater", "neoclassical" or "orthodox" economics.
- marklgr 11y agoIf only people could realize the insane role (good/bad) luck plays in life. I believe it is often a difference between American and European culture: the former very strongly promotes individual responsibility, so when you succeed it's all to your merits, and when you fail you can only blame yourself.
- over 11y agoYes, but I think there's also something to be said for learning to swim in life's ocean of ups and downs, making the most of your situation. For me, a successful person is someone that knows how to swim, not someone that caught a once-in-a-lifetime tidal wave. Usually it isn't very glamorous, but it's what I personally aspire to.
- patrickk 11y ago> not someone that caught a once-in-a-lifetime tidal wave. Those often celebrated in the media as whiz kids or geniuses often do just that. In addition, even if you are a "legitimate" business/founder, there is still a massive amount of luck, way beyond your control. Imagine for example if Elon Musk had founded X.com slightly later that he did - probably wouldn't have the funds or track record to do Tesla and SpaceX due to the lack of exit opportunities with PayPal. Or if Paul Graham had founded ViaWeb slightly later, perhaps no YC.
- over 11y agoAt the very least I think Musk would have been a good engineer, and PG would be inspiring young people to try.
- patrickk 11y agoMost likely, and I think both would've been successful regardless. But their success and impact would've likely been greatly diminished if they were not in the right place and right time before the dotcom bubble popped.
- 11y ago
- thanatropism 11y agoCapitalism, darwinism, stratification (in geology), etc. are probably special cases of a more general "selection + fixation" process. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_Darwinism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_Darwinism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Difference_and_Repetition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Difference_and_Repetition http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/1780937997?keywords=intensive%20science%20and%20virtual%20philosophy&qid=1458303845&ref_=sr_1_1&sr=8-1 http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/1780937997?keywords=intensi...
- kabouseng 11y agoAnother excellent book on this topic that echo's your viewpoint in Malcolm Gladwell's Outliers.