37 ms·
> there is only one word. Corruption The word I would use is Socialism. They are of course related.
by BurningFrog 11y ago
> there is only one word. Corruption
The word I would use is Socialism. They are of course related.
- kafkaesq 11y agoI associate corruption with large-scale human endeavors, generally. If one prefers to believe that any particular -ism has some kind of a corner on the corruption market, as it were... well, that must be a nice, simple, orderly world they get to live in.
- BurningFrog 11y agoI didn't say - or mean - that socialism is the only or worst cause of corruption. I can agree with "large-scale human endeavors" being where it thrives the easiest.
- pvaldes 11y agoCorruption is a much better term. As other philosophical ideas that are not well delimited, socialism is an empty tag that can mean anything as you want. Not much different than words like 'neoliberalism' or so. Elastic terms for filling empty phrases without any real substance.
- BurningFrog 11y agoIn Venezuela's case, I mean a government that controls all the means of production. With one central authority in charge of everything, the corruption opportunities are enormous. Also, even if everyone does as honest work as they can, the coordination problems in a gigantic top-down organization like this would doom it on its own.
- grp 11y agoIn 2016, the word socialism has no value anymore. Venal is more related to corruption as there are independent of any economic and politic systems, even the troll ones.
- SocksCanClose 11y agoand to emphasize, socialism is in fact quite well defined -- especially national socialism (e.g. the Nazi Party of Germany). Here's a good overview of what socialism is, broadly speaking: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socialism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socialism
- the_af 11y agoThe Nazi Party, even though it has "socialism" and "workers" in its title, is not considered to be a form of Socialism (nor, for that matter, to be pro workers). Not that it matters much, but the only mention of Nazism in the Wikipedia article you linked doesn't refer to it as a form of socialism.
- mikerichards 11y agoThe Nazi Party, even though it has "socialism" and "workers" in its title, is not considered to be a form of Socialism (nor, for that matter, to be pro workers) I hate getting down in the weeds on this, but its "not considered socialism" by those on the left who are embarrassed that the Nazis were pretty much a command economy and have socialism in its name.
- the_af 11y agoI don't think Nazism is considered a form of Socialism by pretty much any reputable source; only some in the anti-Left fringe do. A planned economy alone is not enough to classify a system as socialist, and anyway Nazism had enough elements of private property and corporatism. The Nazis, like in many other aspects, were equivocating by calling themselves socialists -- not that they particularly liked the term themselves very much. I wouldn't pay much attention to the name of the Nazi Party, either. After all, North Korea is a "democratic" republic, it says so right in their name!
- orblivion 11y agoSo if a command economy isn't enough, perhaps it has to actually represent a form of community control, do you believe the USSR was any more socialist? What makes something actually socialist? The understanding I've developed of socialism is of worker ownership of the means of production. The state at best can only claim to somehow speak for the workers in a top down manner, and I think that inevitably fails. (Which is not to say I'm advocating it here in a decentralized form but I'm much more sympathetic)
- Frondo 11y agoAs are corruption and capitalism, corruption and monarchy, corruption and communism, corruption and just about every large-scale human endeavor (as well as a lot of the small-scale ones!). If you only associate corruption with socialism, that seems like an uninformed view of the world.
- noir_lord 11y agoDoesn't seem like an uninformed worldview, it is an uninformed world view. https://assets.weforum.org/editor/cYHll0JXGc8zJzpkmvOPzcTTjILC5al1uTEHGFa8X7k.png https://assets.weforum.org/editor/cYHll0JXGc8zJzpkmvOPzcTTjI... Top 10, at least 5 are socialist (I make it 8, Singapore and Switzerland aren't). Of course this is a perception study but I'd argue broadly accurate based on other metrics. This "socialism bad, laissez fair capitalism good" thing gets old and largely seems to be a misunderstanding that Socialism != Communism.
- mattchew 11y agoI would say all 10 are clearly capitalist. All have strong recognition of property rights including private property in the means of production. It is unfortunate that political terminology is muddy enough to allow for this sort of confusion. If I think these 10 countries are capitalist and you think 8 of them are socialist, what is the likelihood of us having a useful conversation discussing capitalism and socialism?
- noir_lord 11y agoSocialism doesn't preclude capitalism, it just harnesses for a different goal.
- mattchew 11y agoPerhaps your idea of socialism, but not many others' ideas. That's the problem. A lot of people who cheer for socialism believe capitalism, in the sense of private property in the means of production, is a problem and should be abolished. Others, like yourself, are advocating fundamentally capitalist states with extensive welfare programs like Denmark or Sweden. Unfortunately, the word socialism is used in both senses quite commonly, and it isn't always easy to tell the intent from the word. (Also, I think sometimes the advocates of socialism aren't very clear on what they mean themselves. Which is unfortunate, as the difference between the two meanings is enormous.) To be fair, it isn't just fans of socialism who perpetuate this. It does not help when right wingers insist on calling Obama a socialist. Since the fraction of internet socialists who would actually like to try Marxist totalitarianism one more time is fairly sizable, I tend to assume the worst when I see people choosing that word for themselves. I will say, if you care about distancing yourself from the totalitarian socialists, but you still like the sound of "socialism", making sure to describe yourself a "democratic socialist" does get the idea across. It's not my favorite term but at least it does suggest Sweden rather than Maoist China.
- bedhead 11y agoYes. Socialism/communism are inherently unfair and unjust, hence breeding a truly staggering amount corruption (almost by necessity).
- ionised 11y agoSocialism != communism. The Nordic countries are pretty damn socialist.
- BurningFrog 11y agoDepends on what you mean. Sweden and Denmark are probably more free market than the US. They do have high taxes and extensive welfare systems.
- nickik 11y agoIt does not depend on what he means, it depends on if he knows what the words he uses mean. Their are two well known economic freedom rankings. - http://www.freetheworld.com/ http://www.freetheworld.com/ (stupid URL, everybody knows) - http://www.heritage.org/index/ http://www.heritage.org/index/ Check out the interactive map: http://www.heritage.org/index/heatmap http://www.heritage.org/index/heatmap The US and Denmark are not for of from each other. The just get subtracted points for different things. Denmark actually had lots of 'neoliberal' reforms, but because it was done by a left government instead of a right one its not commonly mentioned. Sweden has been going in that direction since the 90s as well.
- tim333 11y agoThe thing that is really screwing the Venezuelan economy is the weird exchange rate system which is not exactly corruption or socialism. The ft had "A foreign exchange rate at 10 and 200 versus a 1,000 black market rate is not effective" which I think means you can change at 10 or 200 pesos to the dollar depending on who you know or bribe and the real rate is 1000. Completely Alice in Wonderland mad. I think it's because president Maduro is a former bus conductor who has roughly zero understanding of economics. Interestingly I see some Venezuelans are turning to bitcoin against the the wishes of their government.
- nickik 11y agoControl over currency is as solicalist as it gets. Go back to Lenin and he basically advocates taking control of the currency to monopolies all import and export. So what Venezuela does is straight out of the socialist revolutionary book.
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoNot all socialisms are the same. Some work ...fairly well. It should be clear that there's been a big Dutch Disease/Resource Curse problem in Venezuela. Obviously, the politics didn't help.
- dang 11y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11307202 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11307202 and marked it off-topic.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]