9 ms·
Recording of aerospace executive's speech leads to his resignation the next day
- bsder 11y agoCongratulations, Mr. Generation Text. You remember bitching about how all your college speakers are boring squares? You have just ensured that no speaker will ever tell you anything interesting ever again. Enjoy your milquetoast.
- mfoy_ 11y agoVery insightful comments... apparently just a little too insightful.
- sosuke 11y agoAre we heading for some science fiction future where no one speaks honestly? It isn't a far stretch to imagine that everything is already recorded and what might not be usable against you today could be usable tomorrow if the climate changes. Frightening train of thought, I'll disembark now.
- fallingfrog 11y agoWe're already there, friend, and have been for some time.
- AndyNemmity 11y agoVery true. The comments I have made in this thread already feel to me as they've crossed a line I shouldn't cross, and I haven't said anything all that meaningful or impactful. That's the fear of being truthful at all.
- icedata 11y agoHave you been watching the Primary campaigns?
- mikeash 11y agoThis honesty reveals a lot of problematic stuff about this person. Just taking one random example, if he honestly believes that SES-9 required 100,000 pounds of fuel to make its landing attempt, should he really be part of the upper management of a rocket company? If he thinks their most threatening competitor is "doing nothing," does that maybe suggest he's unsuitable for his position?
- michaelkeenan 11y ago> if he honestly believes that SES-9 required 100,000 pounds of fuel to make its landing attempt, should he really be part of the upper management of a rocket company? What is the correct amount of fuel used to make the landing attempt? I just googled and didn't quickly find it, though I did find this speculation at StackExchange[0] talking about reserving 15% of the fuel, or 66 tons, for the landing. 66 tons is 132,000 pounds, so 100,000 pounds seems a reasonable rounding - what am I missing? (I don't know anything about rockets.) [0] http://space.stackexchange.com/questions/4466/how-is-spacex-going-to-land-their-falcon-first-stage http://space.stackexchange.com/questions/4466/how-is-spacex-...
- mikeash 11y agoFirst, a quick overview on how the landing works. After the first stage separates, it executes a "boostback burn," using the engines to get it moving toward the landing site. Sometime later, it fires the engines again as part of the "reentry burn," which is used to soften the blow of hitting the atmosphere at Mach Whatever. Apparently the rocket exhaust acts a little bit like an ad hoc heat shield, plus it helps slow the thing down. Finally, right as it approaches the landing site, it fires the center engine a final time to, hopefully, bring the rocket to a stop at zero altitude. The amount of fuel used varies a lot, because they can land in different places. At one extreme, you have a landing at the launch site, which uses the most fuel in order to get the first stage turned around and coming back. Barge landings use less fuel, because they can be positioned under the flight path so the rocket doesn't have to maneuver as much. SES-9 was at the other extreme. It reserved the bare minimum of fuel for the landing attempt because of its heavy, high-performance payload. That meant no maneuvering boostback burn, no or minimal reentry burn, and the landing burn itself was done with three engines instead of the typical one. That saves fuel because the rocket decelerates faster and spends less time fighting gravity, but of course the control challenge is magnified, which is probably why it went all explodey. Putting some numbers on it, I found some estimates here: https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/2vuy1v/how_much_fuel_do_the_boost_back_reentry_and/ https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/2vuy1v/how_much_fue... According to that, landing at the launch site would require about 38 tons of fuel, and a (normal) barge landing would require about 20 tons. SES-9's barge landing would have been even less. I believe the 15% from your StackExchange link is confused, and someone mistook the payload penalty (about 15% for a barge landing) for the amount of fuel required.
- fallingfrog 11y agoI'm actually sad that any hint of honesty is so quickly and severely punished in the business world. This is why we get so used to hearing nothing but empty platitudes and bald faced lies from business executives and government officials alike. It does not make me hopeful.
- fallingfrog 11y agoA lot of people are pointing out that what this guy said was in various ways kind of awful. I wouldn't dispute that. It's just- he wasn't fired for doing awful things. He was fired for being honest about it in public. What kind of perverse incentives are we setting up here? I can guarantee that there isn't a single exec right now looking at this and thinking, maybe I shouldn't be such a bastard. They're thinking, boy I better not let anybody know what I really think!
- neurotech1 11y agoIts the "in public" part that got him fired. If it was private constructive criticism, I'd hope that would be accepted as such. IMO Most of what he said was widely thought by others, but not previously confirmed by ULA.
- fallingfrog 11y agoA lot of people are pointing out that what this guy said was in various ways kind of awful. I wouldn't dispute that. It's just- he wasn't fired for doing awful things. He was fired for being honest about it in public. What kind of perverse incentives are we setting up here? I can guarantee that there isn't a single exec right now looking at this and thinking, maybe I shouldn't be such a bastard. They're thinking, boy I better not let anybody know what I really think!
- jinushaun 11y agoIt's not about honestly. He basically admitted that the procurement is broken and that ULA is part of the problem.
- dwolfson 11y ago
- jinushaun 11y agoOh to be a fly on the wall in closed door meetings at Booz, Deloitte, BAE, Lockheed, Boeing, etc. The procurement process is busted and I'm glad SpaceX is shining a light on it.
- flatline 11y agoToo bad - as the article implies in several cases, this kind of stuff is all common knowledge in government contracting. The USG has tried to revamp the procurement processes repeatedly - and not without some success - but the bottom line is that people in positions of power will often give money to whomever they want to give it to, and by imposing more restrictions you just force them to be more creative about how exactly they do this. The most common form is careful phrasing about what exact capabilities are required, such that only one contractor meets those criteria. There was a famous case a few years ago[0] over the Interior Department's email systems in which the contract required compatibility with Microsoft products - Google sued and ultimate won the contract. Senators can blow their tops off all day about this guy's statements but it won't change a thing about the opacity, nepotism, and sometimes complete arbitrariness of the USG procurement process. [0] http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052748704141104575588641430182832 http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB100014240527487041411045755886...
- pyb 11y agoCommon knowledge indeed, absolutely everybody inside the industry understand that's just how things work. Perhaps this guy, after 30+ years in the industry, just forgot that industry outsiders exist,and that they would be quite surprised.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- vermontdevil 11y agoThis was originally posted on Facebook SpaceX public group. Was surprised the executive would be this candid and never imagined it would spread this fast!
- Lazare 11y agoDefinetly a gaffe by the Michael Kinsley definition: That is, when someone accidentally tells the truth. :) Most of what he said (and especially the stuff that people were angry about) is, in fact, common knowledge. ULA can't compete on price, the trade restrictions on Russian engines are politically motivated, most of the funding decisions are made by congress explicitly to funnel spending to their districts, and the procurement process is utterly broken. And you can find industry experts and analysts who say all of this repeatedly and noisily. But if you're speaking for one of the players, obviously you're not allowed to admit any of it.
- AndyNemmity 11y agoExactly. This is the normal tenor of candid conversation in business. You just don't record it. The biggest gaffe he made was the audience. He felt he could candidly discuss the topics with students from his alma mater. He learned that was absolutely the wrong move. He should have been fired, simply because he didn't understand the audience.
- dtf 11y agoIn the UK, we call that "doing a Ratner". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gerald_Ratner https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gerald_Ratner
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mikeash 11y agoI'm noticing a lot of politics in non-political threads lately. Some story is posted which has both political element and a non-political element, and the comments focus entirely on the political side. Case in point: Spike Lee posts his movie list. Roughly 5% of the comment thread is dedicated to talking about the movies. 95% of the thread is about how terrible it was for people to criticize Spike Lee for not including any female directors. Here: there's lots of fascinating discussion to be had about the current state of the space launch industry, how legacy players will respond to upstarts, rocket reusability, etc. But the whole discussion is about how terrible it was that this guy was fired for what he said. Could everybody cut it out? It's annoying!
- ufmace 11y agoWhat I found really baffling is that he apparently said all of these things to an audience of college students at his alma mater. How could anybody make it to a high-level position and be so clueless about what you can say to what audience? This isn't like somebody snuck a recorded into a secret meeting, this is a perfectly predictable consequence of discussing confidential business details with random college students. Especially when you're a C-level executive of a major corporation, there are certain things you just don't ever discuss frankly other than behind closed doors with a very select audience. Even if this hadn't been recorded, it would have been felony stupid to say those things to that audience. The consequences are entirely predictable and well-deserved.
- AndyNemmity 11y ago"Especially when you're a C-level executive of a major corporation, there are certain things you just don't ever discuss frankly other than behind closed doors with a very select audience." I agree with everything except this statement. It's discussed without closed doors, and without a select audience all the time. It's actually quite wide and open for this kind of thing, which is likely how he made the error. He's so used to communicating in this way, he didn't realize that he needed to dramatically change his content for this particular audience.
- ufmace 11y agoEh? Who do you think he is discussing the confidential details of a sensitive negotiation between competing providers of rocket engines with? Considering that it's an extremely vertical market, and one impolite comment at the wrong time could get them shut out of all of the suppliers in the industry.
- roymurdock 11y agoI find it funny that he was basically bragging/venting about a lot of quasi-illegal things in order to seem cool in front of some college kids. This kind of stuff happens all the time between friends, but come on man, you don't need them to validate whatever insecurities you have about not having a cool/exciting job or whatever. You build rockets!
- Animats 11y agoMost of what he said has already appeared in Aviation Leak. "ULA did not seriously consider Aeroject-Rocketdyne bid"[1] ULA's problems with using Russian engines are well known.[2] ULA's cost-competitiveness comes from a bulk buy deal with the USAF.[3] None of this is surprising. ULA's big problems are cost and dependence on Russian engines. Space-X's big problem is that they keep having launch delays and can't launch often enough. They're about a year behind schedule and no longer even publish a projected launch manifest with dates. They have angry customers whose launch schedules are not being met.[4] [1] http://aviationweek.com/space/ula-did-not-seriously-consider-aerojet-rocketdyne-bid http://aviationweek.com/space/ula-did-not-seriously-consider... [2] http://aviationweek.com/space/usaf-cost-rd-180-termination-uncertain http://aviationweek.com/space/usaf-cost-rd-180-termination-u... [3] http://www.bizjournals.com/denver/blog/boosters_bits/2014/05/ulas-per-launch-costs-rival-spacex-and-its-a.html http://www.bizjournals.com/denver/blog/boosters_bits/2014/05... [4] http://spacenews.com/delays-in-spacex-falcon-9-upgrade-schedule-raises-concerns/ http://spacenews.com/delays-in-spacex-falcon-9-upgrade-sched...