3 ms·
> Umm, what "rule", and why is the POTUS the only exception? Taking wireless devices into the SCIF. And because POTUS has a national security need for immediat
by Someone1234 11y ago
> Umm, what "rule", and why is the POTUS the only exception?
Taking wireless devices into the SCIF. And because POTUS has a national security need for immediate communications (because they're the head of the military, have access to the football, and may need to make key strategic decisions).
The key question is: Are you going to risk more lives and save more lives by allowing potential bugs into the state's SCIF? Leaks from within a SCIF could almost certainly get people killed (foreign agents, US agents, US military personnel), the key question is if the Secretary of State can save enough lives by being instantly accessible in that one area?
> These are the questions that Clinton and Reid were apparently unable to get an answer to.
Or they received an answer but either didn't understand the answer or just didn't like it. There are a lot of people who claim that their issues are never addressed just because they don't understand the answer to the question they're asked.
I'm sure the NSA gave them a full report on why cellphones are risky and how they can be compromised. But I don't know if that information was received by state or understood.
- kafkaesq 11y agoBy "rule" I was referring to the criteria by which exceptions were granted. I'll grant that wasn't clear in my language, but that's what I was driving at. Because [the] POTUS has a national security need for immediate communications because they're the head of the military, have access to the football, and may need to make key strategic decisions). The Secretary of State's job is also quite important, you know. They're also pretty high up in the chain-of-succession for direct access to the same duties as the POTUS. Or they received an answer but either didn't understand the answer or just didn't like it. ... I'm sure the NSA gave them a full report on why cellphones are risky and how they can be compromised. But I don't know if that information was received by state or understood. Drawing from the trove of recently released emails, the article itself says that most likely they were informed of (and understood -- or at least her staff understood -- the risks of) using private cellphones ("her staff was fully aware of the security risks associated with using her BlackBerry.") What they didn't understand is why a modified cellphone was considered a secure enough solution both for the POTUS, and for the predecessor SoS -- but not for the current one. As to whether Clinton herself really understood the risks, or she did, why she continued to use a non-secured device, anyway? That I don't know -- and I won't offer any defense for, either.