4 ms·
> if you have a locked safe, they can get a court order that compels you to open it. But in this case, the FBI wants the safe manufacturer--not the owner of th
by pdonis 11y ago
> if you have a locked safe, they can get a court order that compels you to open it.
But in this case, the FBI wants the safe manufacturer--not the owner of the safe, who is the one who could be compelled to open it by court order--to redesign the lock on the safe so that the FBI can keep trying combinations indefinitely until it opens. That's not the same thing.
- jessriedel 11y agoThis isn't the point I'm addressing.
- pdonis 11y agoThen I don't understand your position. Just because a court order can compel some things that law enforcement can't compel in its absence, it does not follow that a court order can compel anything that law enforcement can't compel in its absence. But that seems to be what you're claiming--or at least it seems to be the grounds on which you're rejecting the argument you were responding to. My point is that even if a court order can compel the owner of a secret to either divulge it to law enforcement or face consequences, that doesn't mean it can compel a third party to help law enforcement pry loose the secret in the owner's absence. That seems to be precisely the distinction the article is making.