4 ms·
I have to assume the timing of this, coming so soon after the Pentagon bailed on BD, is no coincidence. Does Google figure that the division cannot turn a profi
by Analemma_ 11y ago
I have to assume the timing of this, coming so soon after the Pentagon bailed on BD, is no coincidence. Does Google figure that the division cannot turn a profit without that sweet spigot of defense dollars?
- melling 11y agoWhat other non-defense products do they have? What other non-defense clients do they have? Consumers robotics is still waiting for its Apple II moment.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> Consumers robotics is still waiting for its Apple II moment. Elderly care in first world countries.
- melling 11y agoIdeas are easy. I've got a dozen great ideas too but I won't waste anyone's time. The trick is for a company to profitability make a product then parlay that into the next big thing.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoHonda has been building robotics for years ahead of everyone else. Google "japan elderly care robotics". What's cheaper? A robot, or a human caregiver who has fully loaded costs for decades? If you can even find the human who wants to do the job. http://asimo.honda.com/ http://asimo.honda.com/
- melling 11y agoA human is much cheaper because no robot can currently do the job. You are completely missing the point. Years ahead means nothing. it could be 20-30 years before it can replace a human for that job. In the meantime, it's a pet project. The idea is for companies to find revenue from the technology as soon as possible then turn that revenue into R&D to build even better robots. Look at the revenue the smartphone market generates. There's an arm's race to get consumers buying new devices. We need a couple $100 billion robotics companies pushing boundaries. Also consider, for example, how Elon is bootstrapping electric cars and private rockets.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> Also consider, for example, how Elon is bootstrapping electric cars and private rockets. That's a great example. And I agree with you in part. Look how far Elon and Co have come in under 15 years with both Tesla and SpaceX. Bootstrapped? Indeed. But they also had to prime the pump with demand (SpaceX with gov contracts, Tesla with wealthy purchasers)
- melling 11y agoYes, they had to find customers. That's how business works. You sound as if they cheated. You find someone willing to pay for your product. The "build it and they will come" doesn't usually work out so well. Finding governments or wealthy people to pay for your products counts when building a business. Elon didn't invent this tactic.
- Oletros 11y agoWhen Google acquired them,, they said that they didn't want to be defense contractors
- mtgx 11y agoExactly. And then they went ahead and tried to get a defense contract from Pentagon anyway. In fact, about 3 months after they said that, they started wanting to sell Google Glass to the military. Not as bad as selling them autonomous robots, but still. It just shows much little when we trust what Google says when an acquisition happens. Eventually they are just going to do what they think will make them money, regardless of what they promised. That said, now I'm worried that an actual defense contractor will get those robots.
- 91bananas 11y agoCurious, because you think this is a consumer technology?
- 13thLetter 11y ago"That said, now I'm worried that an actual defense contractor will get those robots." Why is this worrying? If you're afraid that the military will do something evil with the robots, you're going to be dismayed to learn that they already have automatic rifles, tanks, and atomic bombs.
- Oletros 11y ago> And then they went ahead and tried to get a defense contract from Pentagon anyway. Source for that? > In fact, about 3 months after they said that, they started wanting to sell Google Glass to the military Source for that?
- Alupis 11y agoI believe Google was in the process of winding down all of BD's defense contracts anyway - because they have no interest in being in the defense contractor business. But to have bought a leading "next-gen" defense contractor, only to wind down all of their contracts, and then sell off the company... seems... wrong? Almost like a deliberate destruction of this company.
- woah 11y agoIs there anything wrong about destroying a defense contractor?
- Alupis 11y ago> Is there anything wrong about destroying a defense contractor? A company like Boston Dynamics? Absolutely yes. They were working on next-gen robotics that would directly save American soldier lives - both while in combat and during rescue operations. Their technology was also being tested for domestic search-and-rescue operations where it was too dangerous to send in humans.
- nitrogen 11y agoSome people make the case that war should remain dangerous so countries are reluctant to start wars. Or maybe some see a trajectory from robotic mules to robotic weapons platforms. In those cases, no amount of search-and-rescue window dressing would change their minds.
- Alupis 11y agoWar is not the only scenario where there is armed conflict. Stopping a genocide, inserting a military "buffer" in-between two hostile nations, general peace keeping, hostage rescue, VIP protection, bomb location/defusal, hijackings, and more come to mind. The fact is, soldier's lives are going to be put into harms way, even in a perfectly at-peace world (which none of us live in). Perhaps I'm biased, as I come from a military family, but I'd far rather a walking circuit board take a bullet over a human soldier.
- j1vms 11y agoIf the Pentagon had indeed bailed on BD, it is possible that they know that their own research is safely near par or even further along than that of BD. While they would have otherwise funneled money over to GOOG regardless, they possibly tilted the other way as the US government slowly distances themselves from the country's tech industry - that is, until AAPL and others get "on-side" again. Of course, we may never know for sure.
- stupidcar 11y agoThe Pentagon bailed because the bigdog project just wasn't practical[1]. The large version was too noisy for use on the battlefield, and the small version was too weak to do useful work. It seems like Google are bailing on BD for much the same reason: Their tech works, but it doesn't actually solve any practical problem that Google have, and isn't close to producing any independent, sellable product. [1] http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-35201183 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-35201183