5 ms·
This makes Clinton seem petty. She had a wired-computer she could check email on in the SCIF, but she refused and was only willing to read her email on a Black
by Someone1234 11y ago
This makes Clinton seem petty.
She had a wired-computer she could check email on in the SCIF, but she refused and was only willing to read her email on a Blackberry, so her staff tried to get authorisation for one, failed, and then tried to get her a highly sensitive top level device just so she could check her unclassified email in the SCIF (she could use a standard Blackberry elsewhere).
I'm siding with the NSA here. She should just buck up and learn to check her email on a wired PC like everyone else.
- res0nat0r 11y agoThis is easy when you work in an office every day at the same location for your job. As Secretary of State travelling all of the time around the world this isn't realistic.
- Someone1234 11y agoThe SCIF is a fixed location, your point doesn't make sense/doesn't apply here. Nobody was stopping her from using a standard Blackberry outside of that facility (and she was, according to the article).
- batbomb 11y agoJust because it's a fixed location doesn't mean employees in that fixed locations should be fixtures.
- Someone1234 11y agoThen deploy RJ-45 into conference rooms and give staff laptops without WiFi. That maintains operational security and allows people to move around.
- vonmoltke 11y agoActually, the usual approach to information security in a SAPF/SCIF is that computing resources are fixtures.
- WizardlySquid 11y agoThe entire point of a SCIF is that it is a very secure fixed location where the intelligence community can make sure people don't say steal documents, listen in or look at secret documents behind another person's shoulder.
- talmand 11y agoImagine all the previous people in that position that were incapable of properly doing their jobs because they had no Blackberry in which to receive secured information.
- inopinatus 11y agoIt says in the article that Condaleeza Rice + staff were authorized for BB use whilst SecState, but the grant of that was withdrawn for Clinton.
- talmand 11y agoAs others have said in an attempt to refute my comment, times change.
- Someone1234 11y agoIt wasn't withdrawn for Clinton, it was withdrawn for the devices themselves. The NSA decided the potential consequences for a baseband compromise within a SCIF was too high risk. Honestly I suspect their policy is "no wireless devices within the SCIF period." From wireless keyboards, to cellphones, to WiFi, and beyond. The black phone might be authorised but I suspect that is due to operational importance (e.g. calls vital to national security).
- eanzenberg 11y agoAnd John Kerry was given a gov't BB as secretary of state. https://www.bostonglobe.com/news/nation/2015/09/30/john-kerry-sometimes-uses-private-mail-account-for-state-department-business-official-says/DmZz3PBxGgoUtOlREsuLhL/story.html https://www.bostonglobe.com/news/nation/2015/09/30/john-kerr...
- karlshea 11y agoThe world is a different place now than it was when those people were in that position, it's hardly a good comparison. Everything moves faster today and the Secretary of State should be able to along with it. Would you be able to be good at your job if you were only able to check email once a day? I sure couldn't, but 15 years ago that's how often I checked it.
- MrMullen 11y agoThen get her a laptop and she can use that all the time. Then train her how to use the laptop so she does not have use other devices.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mywittyname 11y agoThe issue is that the NSA didn't want to deal with managing remote devices. So the laptop would be no better than a BB.
- sharemywin 11y agoI doubt she was staring at a computer using her blackberry. Possible I suppose but I imagine she was in a lot of meetings.
- bradleyjg 11y agoThe subtext of some of these stories seem to be that there was a great deal of tension between the intelligence community and the state department. In particular, this whole business about retroactive classification seems to be part of a larger battle on the issue of overclassification.
- nitid_name 11y agoThere's always friction between covert and overt operations. For another elucidating example (and another Hillary situation), look at the CIA vs State Department in Benghazi.
- kafkaesq 11y agoShe should just buck up and learn to check her email on a wired PC like everyone else. No, the NSA was being petty. Worse than that, actually. Most likely whoever made this decision had some kind of a personal grudge.
- Someone1234 11y agoWhat is your basis for calling the NSA petty? Or claiming it was a personal grudge? On technical grounds the NSA's position makes sense. Baseband compromises are viable and an active threat, cellphone OS software compromises are also viable and an active threat, so effectively every wireless device inside of a SCIF could be turned into a bug at any minute. Additionally the NSA doesn't let wireless devices into ANY SCIF, by Clinton or anyone else. Only the US president himself is the exception to this rule and even then we're talking about a specific device designed for official functions only. So again, you'll have to justify your position.
- kafkaesq 11y agoWhat is your basis for calling the NSA petty? Or claiming it was a personal grudge? There may have been valid (short-term) reasons as to why it would have been difficult (or costly) to provide her with a POTUS-like solution. But the overall sense I get from the article (and in my view, the bigger issue at play here) is that Clinton and her secure technology coordinator (Donald Reid) felt they weren't being given a credible explanation as to why their request would be unworkable. And (subjectively) felt they were being ignored generally with regard to their request. (And BTW no, the partial explanation they were given -- "use has expanded to an unmanageable number of users" -- meaning presumably legions of underlings probably shouldn't have been granted exceptions in the first place, is not, on the face of it, a credible explanation as to why an exception can't be granted for the 2nd most important office holder in the Executive Branch). Only the US president himself is the exception to this rule Umm, what "rule", and why is the POTUS the only exception? These are the questions that Clinton and Reid were apparently unable to get an answer to.
- RobertoG 11y ago
- CIPHERSTONE 11y agoThe arguement I have read is that the device the president had was only possible because he has a full security detail 24x7 that can keep track of the phone. Doesn't the secretary of state have that as well?
- Someone1234 11y agoThat isn't an argument that I have read. Obviously it would be "bad" if the black phone slipped into enemy hands, but I think the real concern is that with more of them out in the world there is more potential for adversaries to try and attack them wirelessly. That's the real paranoia. What if the black phone turned into a wireless bug? Anything wireless inside of a SCIF is "bad." The black phone is just an exception for national security reasons, the default is to deny all.
- golemotron 11y agoThe timing of this article is significant. Politically, it's playing the victim card.