3 ms·
The big disadvantage of OSS versus (competent) infrastructure SaaS, is that open source software tends to have very poor operational efficiency. A major compone
by jandrewrogers 11y ago
The big disadvantage of OSS versus (competent) infrastructure SaaS, is that open source software tends to have very poor operational efficiency. A major component of the infrastructure SaaS business model and defensibility is arbitraging the OpEx between open source and a properly designed SaaS implementation, primarily by radically reducing resource requirements to deliver a given level of scale and performance.
The rule of thumb for most infrastructure SaaS like databases, big data platforms, etc is that you can get a 10x reduction in hardware requirements versus OSS, hence the OpEx/CapEx savings, with a well-engineered implementation of the same functionality. As someone in the business of doing exactly this, I can tell you that this is simple to achieve. OSS may be "free" but if it requires an order of magnitude more hardware to deliver the same performance and scale as my cloud implementation of the same thing, it makes the OSS much more expensive to the end user.
This dynamic would go away if OSS infrastructure software was designed with performance and efficiency as a priority, but in practice that has been pretty far down the list of priorities for most popular OSS software. But I think most people are surprised by just how inefficient OSS software actually is compared to other implementations. I have been telling people for some time that without an increased focus on absolute performance and efficiency in OSS, it will be increasingly marginalized in usage because the CapEx/OpEx of deploying it is far too high compared to the alternatives.
- elsurudo 11y agoCould you provide some high-profile examples where the SaaS implementation is much more performant than the OSS variant? Genuinely curious... I figured the SaaS vendors (mostly) use OSS under-the-hood anyways, and then they have to take their overhead and profits, etc.
- manigandham 11y agoArent most SaaS backed by the same open-source software? Often the part you're paying for is the management of the software, not the software itself.
- nzoschke 11y agoThis is a really great perspective. You're totally right, SaaS companies have far more motivation to maximize performance and operations to reduce the cost of keeping their services running. OSS often doesn't have the need or the expertise to do this. But I do see some of this shifting... Some OSS projects are now built by folks that have lots of performance expertise and goals. There's also more funding or sponsorship for OSS development which will help. For example Redis is ridiculously cheap and easy to run on your own. antirez is a world class engineer with high standards and he has sponsorship to work towards his goals full time. AWS offers it as a service through ElasticCache which removes what challenges remain about configuration, replication or failover. So I wouldn't build, integrate or bet on a SaaS "cache" platform/company any more. It's been commoditized. I see signs of the same thing happening to more parts of the stack. ELK isn't the most performant log analysis platform, but it's close to Splunk in my experience, with the added benefit of the possibility of anyone, Elastic or the community, contributing performance improvements. Yes there is lots of wishful thinking here...