4 ms·
I'm okay with this. As he says, robots are the best workers. Once companies start investing more in automation, then we as a country can focus on freeing huma
by mywittyname 11y ago
I'm okay with this. As he says, robots are the best workers.
Once companies start investing more in automation, then we as a country can focus on freeing humans from the shackles of performing meager tasks for penance. We can tax these companies a modest amount and give that to unemployed workers.
It's really a win/win. The business makes lots more money and the former workers now have a load of free time to do with as they please. They can focus on developing skills for higher paying jobs, or just live out their lives in modest leisure, focusing on raising their family instead of just feeding them.
- GSegbar 11y agoI don't think so. It'd be more cost-effective to let us all starve.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoHence, socialist safety nets. Because the alternative is.... unpleasant for capital/automation owners. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_Revolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_Revolution
- chopin 11y agoThis problem could be solved with robots as well. Why not having farming robots alongside with ones which protect them and the products of their labor from the greedy hands of the have-nots? It could be that robots able to kill will overturn the balance to the ones who can afford them even if they are a few. Who would dare to stop them?
- toomuchtodo 11y agoIf you have nothing to lose as a have-not, your options for action are extensive. Even the smallest nation-states can afford and manufacture nuclear weapons now (ie North Korea). I don't foresee this capability getting more expensive or more difficult as time goes on, only cheaper and easier.
- mywittyname 11y agoThen we'd just steal the food and he'd get nothing.
- chopin 11y agoRobots could protect the food as well...
- paulojreis 11y ago> As he says, robots are the best workers. That's not a statement that can be made universally, I think. They're way better in scenarios which tend to be deterministic, but otherwise not so much (e.g. when there's more interaction with humans!). I also like the predictability of robots, but more than once I got blocked by a e-toll system with Gandalf-syndrome - "you shall not pass!" :). It's really a lousy, lousy experience. You can say "it was a case of bad implementation", but surely an analagous argument can be made to a less-than-performant human employee.
- mhurron 11y agoLook back at human history. Now ask yourself how you can be so naive still. We (society in general) will let these people starve and act like it's their own fault. > They can focus on developing skills for higher paying jobs Ever wondered why they don't do that now. I mean, everyone could right after high school right? They had tons of free time then. It costs money, an increasing amount of money actually. Where do you propose they get it? We (society) blame people for not improving themselves when they work hard to make a corporation money now, how can you think that would improve when they don't.
- mywittyname 11y agoActually, the argument is that people working 60 hours a week at two jobs really has no free time to learn anything. If you free people from work, some portion of them will take up a hobby to fill time and some of those hobbies can be turned into a job. Some of them may look to school and education to improve their prospects, but those aren't the only path to a good job. Lots of people are creative and have good business sense and I think freeing people up from doing meaningless tasks is a great way to capitalize on this fact. To me, people + time + capital => innovation. All I'm proposing is to give these people a lot of time and a bit of money.
- throwaway2016a 11y agoAlso, automation tends to make commodity goods less expensive. Which helps the poor and middle class. Assuming of course that the market does it's job and costs do go lower rather than getting added to the company bottom line.
- st3v3r 11y agoLower costs of goods only helps the poor if they have the money to actually purchase those goods. If they're just being kicked out of jobs, and not given any assistance, then lower cost of goods does nothing for them.
- gooseus 11y agoWhat about Maslow's hierarchy of needs? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maslow%27s_hierarchy_of_needs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maslow%27s_hierarchy_of_needs Freeing people from work also "frees" them from the income stream that allows them to feel secure. If you don't feel secure in some being able to provide basic needs (food, shelter, water, etc) for yourself and your dependents then it's a lot harder to focus on higher level concepts which are required to learn new, more marketable skills.
- ProAm 11y ago> We can tax these companies a modest amount and give that to unemployed workers. This is subjective and a slippery slope. There really is no difference between a tax and raising the minimum wage. A tax creates a new middle mam, the government, who is responsible to pay people vs a business owner. Either way the cost is passed to the consumer.
- drabiega 11y agoSaying there is no difference between a tax and raising the minimum wage might be going a bit far. Depending on what you're taxing the incentives and results of a tax and a minimum wage increase can be very different. For instance, a tax on profits doesn't change which activities are profitable it reduces the extent to which they are profitable, while a minimum wage increase can actually change what activities are profitable in edge cases. Personally, I think guaranteed basic income + no minimum wage puts the incentives in the right places, but I'll settle for increased minimum wage in the face of the unlikelihood of a basic income being put in place.
- st3v3r 11y ago"Once companies start investing more in automation, then we as a country can focus on freeing humans from the shackles of performing meager tasks for penance. We can tax these companies a modest amount and give that to unemployed workers." Except Congress right now would never enact such a tax (or any tax, thanks to that stupid pledge). So what will those workers who no longer have a way to support themselves do?