5 ms·
Will We Glue Skyscrapers Together in the Future?
- grogenaut 11y agoWe already do, it's called welding.
- Retric 11y agoIMO, it's closer to Mortar than welding. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mortar_(masonry) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mortar_(masonry)
- ChuckMcM 11y agoHowever, strictly speaking welding requires bringing metal to a melting point, allowing it to alloy and then refreeze. Adhesives typically bond in a chemical way to the materials being attached. This bonding, whether covalent or ionic, is a separate material between the bonded materials. And while that can be good for helping materials resist thermal expansion forces, it can be bad in that the ageing properties of the adhesive is often dissimilar to the ageing properties of the bonded material. Given the advent of extensive amounts of computer power to comprehensively model these properties I could easily see civil engineers adopting adhesives either as an alternative to, or adjunct to, welding and fastening as a way to keep structural members together. For me personally, the discussion of adhesives was the second most interesting part of my materials science classes after forging/working of steel (I always wanted to make my own swords).
- grogenaut 11y agoChuck you're thinking about some welds but not all. Many welds are actually chemical as well as just flowing the metals together. Especially bonds between different kinds of metals. Also there are many adhesives that require temperature treatment so where do you draw the line between "welding" and "adhesives"? Just a thought experiment. I know there is probbably a strict definition. However if you've ever used a mig or flood welder, it's really not very far off of from a hot glue gun or just dumping glue on the thing.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jdietrich 11y ago>However if you've ever used a mig or flood welder, it's really not very far off of from a hot glue gun or just dumping glue on the thing. As I understand it, the defining trait of welding (as compared to soldering or brazing) is that the process fundamentally alters the structure of the materials being bonded. The bonded faces are not merely adhered together with a filler material, but become a cohesive whole on a molecular level. The engineering problems posed by adhesive bonding arise largely because the properties of three materials must be taken into account - the two materials to be bonded and the adhesive itself. The adhesive could react chemically with one or both of the bonded materials, it may be stressed by differences in the coefficients of thermal expansion etc.
- grogenaut 11y ago@jdietrich, while this is generally true there are a bunch of special welds like silver to steel, aluminum to other metals, etc that have specially formulated multi element fillers so there's chemistry going on there, it's not just steel to steel with a slightly different steel filler. Bronze, copper, it can get interesting.
- nkurz 11y agoI can't tell whether you are making a subtle technical point, or if you are don't understand the terminology the rest of us are using. Commonly defined, welding involves melting both the base metals, and the joint ends up as strong as the weaker of the two. Soldering and brazing, on the other hand, melt only the filler, and the joint strength is limited by the strength of the filler or its adhesion to one of the metals. When you say "multi element filler", it seems likely you are saying "welding" when we think you should be saying "brazing". True welding of dissimilar metals is sometimes possible, but is not very common, and usually requires some exotic processes most of us are less familiar with: laser, ultrasonic, diffusion, explosion. There's description of some of these here: http://www.totalmateria.com/page.aspx?ID=CheckArticle&site=ktn&NM=152 http://www.totalmateria.com/page.aspx?ID=CheckArticle&site=k...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Terr_ 11y ago> strictly speaking welding requires bringing metal to a melting point "Strictly" speaking you don't, because there are other techniques, such as diffusion welding.
- ams6110 11y agoI would say brazing is closer.
- cgriswald 11y ago> “The problem is that glue is not a mechanical fastener, [and it] can deteriorate over time,” he tells CityLab. Current materials can rust or rot over time. Water can get in places and cause failures[1]. The problem, in my uneducated-on-the-topic mind, is that glue seems more likely to fail all at once or exhibit a cascade failure than mechanical fasteners. [1] - http://www.mercurynews.com/bay-area-news/ci_28329832/berkeley-deck-collapse-irish-consulate-prepares-arrival-grieving http://www.mercurynews.com/bay-area-news/ci_28329832/berkele...
- bufordsharkley 11y agoYes, glue (at least current glues) are brittle. Failures with ductile materials are preferable (which is why we see rebar inside concrete, for instance)
- monk_e_boy 11y agoYou can put carbon fibre into glue. We make epoxy kiteboards and hydrofoils. Very very light, very strange shapes.
- kazinator 11y agoSome glues are flexible. Certain epoxies can be mixed in a range from 2:1 to 1:1, giving a range of flexibilities. Epoxy can also be combined with rubber.
- jdietrich 11y agoMany adhesives are extremely ductile, the obvious example being silicones.
- msandford 11y agoThere's a lot to be said for a mechanical interference that prevents two things from moving relative to one another. Like say a bolt, in shear (or a pin). Better still is a bolt that exerts clamp force, thus leaving it far, far less in shear. Bolts are amazing and I can't see why people think glue is better. Welding is better, sure, but it's also a lot more permanent. EDIT: I get why people like glue for things like carbon fiber bikes, etc because weight is an issue and you can't really bolt it. But for buildings? That's a different use case.
- bofussing 11y ago> "People are often content with using the tried and true, code-prescribed systems," he said. Unlike aircraft that are made in a carefully controlled factory environment; building sites can be harsh places to work and fastening systems have to have the flexibility and design margins to cope with this. Unless glues start getting a track record of being significantly better (cost, strength, resilience) than current fastening systems I doubt we will see much adoption.
- TrevorJ 11y agoBiggest questions I have are: how reliably can this be done in the harsh environment of a job site, and is it obvious when the application has failed/or is deteriorating?
- ChuckFrank 11y agoThis from the man, Lynn, who said that we'd be making houses the same way we make shoes. He's a techno carpet bagger. He takes the most current and promising technologies, from shoe makers, to car makers, and then rails at the building establishment for not taking that technology and his lead seriously. When in fact, his actual works are bonded kids toys. And that's the problem with these guys, they talk big game, but when it comes to implementation, they barely elicit a shrug. Structural steel was adopted quickly once it was clear that it was superior to all other existing construction technologies. The same thing would be true with glue-this and glue-that, if it turned out the be true. It's not. It's the architectural equivalent of vapor-ware. Sorry Herr Lynn, we are still waiting for your shoe houses.
- hinkley 11y agoWell, technically it has, considering all the laminated wood beams used in low rise buildings...
- alejohausner 11y agoBoston's Big Dig tunnels used bolts glued with epoxy to hang the heavy roof panels that hung over the roadway. The epoxy failed catastrophically and the panels fell on a car, killing the driver. Analysis of the accident blamed the workers who installed the bolts, but I think the big lesson is that construction sites are messy, and don't provide the best environment for the delicate chemical reactions needed to set adhesives properly.
- autopov 11y agoIn California, building codes are tightly integrated with fire code. For example, residential roofs cannot be entirely covered with solar panels because a firefighter may have to punch a hole in the roof to vent a fire. Has anyone ever witnessed a glue lam beam burn? How would glue fasteners in a skyscraper perform in a fire? The relevant industry needs to conduct studies and show proof that it's safe. Safety is a big bandwagon in the CA Leg., so plenty of good data would be needed to push innovation into building codes. Based on my knowledge of how the CA State Fire Marshal works, it'll be 2040 or later for glue welds make it into CA building codes, if the tech proves to be viable.
- pvinis 11y agoWas I the only one who thought that the article will be about "gluing" skyscrapers with each other? Like using metal bars or something to make them less vulnerable to wind and earthquakes, by making them behave as one?
- brenschluss 11y agoThis already happens. The glass on the curtain walls of many skyscrapers is held in place by structural silicon adhesive. Example: Frank Gehry's IAC building in Manhattan, referenced here [1], using products like this: [2] [1] http://archpaper.com/news/articles.asp?id=185 http://archpaper.com/news/articles.asp?id=185 [2] http://www.portafab.com/curtainwall-connecting-adhesives.html http://www.portafab.com/curtainwall-connecting-adhesives.htm...