5 ms·
On the upside there will be potential for better detecting foodborne illnesses as well as just better food hygiene with fewer human hands. It's a dire time for
by mc32 11y ago
On the upside there will be potential for better detecting foodborne illnesses as well as just better food hygiene with fewer human hands.
It's a dire time for people who dropped out of school and with few marketable skills. The tattered net that was the McD's job, is not going to be there for long, not that should have ever been a job for proper adults, but soon it will be on its way out.
However, I think minimum wage increases are a red herring. Increased minimum wages should buy you better employees who are more productive. Never the less, it's just more automation, possibly base wage increase accelerates adoption, but it's not the reason --were just getting better at automation and it's becoming pervasive.
As to people's appetite for automated food production and presentation Japan should allay their fears. After a little trepidation, consumers will grow to like the predictable service.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoHowever, I think minimum wage increases are a red herring. Increased minimum wages should buy you better employees who are more productive. Why would it do that? If your wages were higher than competitors, certainly paying higher wages gives you the best of the existing workers. But a minimum wage doesn't give you higher wages than competitors at all.
- TheBeardKing 11y ago*higher productivity
- mc32 11y agoBecause you're no longer scraping the bottom of the barrel and it gives the worker more in germs of financial stability.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoWhy aren't you scraping the bottom of the barrel anymore? Before a min wage, you are hiring the least valuable workers. After a min wage increase you are still hiring the same low value workers.
- mc32 11y agoPeople who didn't see it fit to work for 7/hr might find value in working at 15/hr. Now they can afford to pay gas to get there, etc. Cost benefitwise more people see a benefit in taking that job.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoWhy are these "better employees"? Also, it seems like a minimum wage actually makes life worse for employers who have use for high value employees. Without a minimum wage I can offer $15/hour and I'll get the high value people. High value labor is therefore sorted into high productivity use. Once you impose a minimum wage this effect is eliminated. All the benefits you attribute to a minimum wage could be gained voluntarily by companies even without a minimum wage. In fact the minimum wage interferes with these voluntary efforts. Yet they often don't exploit them. Why don't they?
- mc32 11y agoWith a minimum wage you have a fairer wages playing field. No longer are you competing against the wage exploiter when it comes to labor costs. As to why you get a better employee at 15 vs 7/hr, think about an engineer. At 70k a laid off engineer will sit it out. A so so engineer will take that job instead. Now, raise that 70k to 120k (or whatever rate) and you'll be able to entice the better engineer, while the so so engineer gets left out, perhaps going back to learn more marketable skills.
- bcpermafrost 11y ago"Why are these better employees" He just explained that to you. The people who actually work hard and have goals will actually want the minimum wage jobs because now its more manageable to live off of. A university student who needs to pay rent, groceries, a car, etc. Cant afford to live off minimum wage so they want the better paying jobs which may not exist cause companies want to get away with the most profitable scenario which is paying employees the absolute minimum. That last statement wasn't needed, no body has time for ad hominems.
- SilasX 11y agoRight, but if no one hires the bottom of the barrel, what do we do with them? Ramp up welfare programs, further penalizing anyone who eventually finds something they can do for a living? We can't all hire the best (or better) employees.
- mc32 11y agoYes, logically, we'd have to provide [either subsidies, or training, etc.] for people who don't have skills necessary to enter the job market. However at the higher min wage, we get better workers as well as a bigger economy (they make more, spending more and thus contribute more to tax receipts). A worker at 15/hr has more economic stability than a 7 or 8/hr worker, as well you're now getting high school graduates with some junior college ed. A more educated workforce should offer the potential of more value add vs a less educated worker.
- throwaway2016a 11y ago> However, I think minimum wage increases are a red herring. Increased minimum wages should buy you better employees who are more productive. Never the less, it's just more automation, possibly base wage increase accelerates adoption, but it's not the reason --were just getting better at automation and it's becoming pervasive. I'm not sure adding productivity helps. Since a lot of the time is spent doing things like waiting for the frier to be done cooking the fries. No matter how efficient a worker you are, the fries will not cook faster. Likewise there are times of the day when the foot traffic is very low. At those times people are told to do things like sweep the floor but I'm not sure if someone finishes sweeping 10 minutes earlier it really makes a difference.
- st3v3r 11y agoMore productive workers are also usually more dependable. So you're worrying less that the person that's supposed to come in before the lunch rush isn't just going to flake out on you.
- throwaway2016a 11y agoI have to admit, I had not considered them just not showing up to work at all. I'm a bit unqualified to talk on this topic as I have never worked in fast food, I was more curious why it matters in that environment.
- mc32 11y agoAt 15 on average one might get a better worker, one more dependable, one who may be able to be rested before work, one which does not have to work as many hours at minimum wage to make ends meet. This will result in a healthier worker, therefore more dependable and offer more labor stability to the employer.
- edgyswingset 11y agoProductive workers are better, period. The fact that there are hours where productivity doesn't affect your bottom line doesn't really matter. Managers have been scheduling around these hours since the dawn of time. Source: I worked fast food with both lazy and productive workers before I decided making $8.00/HR wasn't good enough.
- xiaoma 11y agoThe bottom quartile of workers still has to work somewhere.
- mc32 11y agoSome will be pushed out. That means more people will require government subsidies and it contributes to building a virtual "wall" by pushing low skills immigrants out of the shrinking low skills labor pool. With automation Trump (or Hillary) won't have to visit immigration reform, there will be no jobs to attract people at the lowest skills levels. There will still be a pull on high skills professionals.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoWhy is this a good thing? If a Mexican can do a job cheaper than a machine, why shouldn't he be hired to do so? It makes life better for him and for the guy who doesn't need to buy a machine. If you really dislike Mexicans and are willing to harm Americans in order to keep them away, I guess it makes sense. I guess I'm just not a fan of Trump/Bernie/Hillary style nationalism.
- mc32 11y agoThat's a characterization I didn't make. What I stated were the consequences of higher min wages. It benefits citizens as well as high skills foreign nationals in the US but is possibly detrimental to low skills labor. There is no judgement in that, just stating the consequences, some positive, some negative. Not all low skills labor come from directly across the border. On the other hand it benefits higher skills workers from across the border because there will be more demand for high skills labor.
- blfr 11y agoIt's a good thing because it expands our ability to automate things. It rewards innovation rather than manipulating the immigration process. And you know why people don't want Mexicans to flood America. I've seen you link to Putnam's study which shows that diversity destroys trust and communities. There are real externalities here.
- bko 11y ago> Increased minimum wages should buy you better employees who are more productive I disagree. I think an increased minimum wage, presumably above the market clearing price for a person with that set of skills, allows the manager to introduce non-economic factors into his decision making. This includes personal biases and encourages nepotism. It's also worth remembering that the minimum wage law had less than noble intentions > The business-friendly National Center for Policy Analysis points out “the 1931 Davis-Bacon Act, requiring ‘prevailing’ wages on federally assisted construction projects, was supported by the idea that it would keep contractors from using ‘cheap colored labor’ to underbid contractors using white labor.” [0] http://www.forbes.com/sites/carriesheffield/2014/04/29/on-the-historically-racist-motivations-behind-minimum-wage/#19ea54a51957 http://www.forbes.com/sites/carriesheffield/2014/04/29/on-th...
- mc32 11y agoThe current min wage is no wage for an adult. It's untenable. Admittedly, I imagine it will benefit modestly educated Americans (including white, black and Latin) but will likely be detrimental to low skills (minimum education) immigrants (and some locals) as there is no price advantage to hiring them, given their deficits.
- pasquinelli 11y agomaking food shouldn't have ever been a job for a proper adult?