3 ms·
The post starts with an analogy of a race between a runner and a race car. It says we'd call this unfair because the two are clearly not comparable. But I thin
by mikeash 11y ago
The post starts with an analogy of a race between a runner and a race car. It says we'd call this unfair because the two are clearly not comparable.
But I think it gets the reasons wrong. It says we'd call it unfair because the race car uses so much more energy. I think we'd call it unfair because the outcome is such a foregone conclusion. We know the race car is going to be way faster, so the race is pointless. It's a foregone conclusion, so why even bother unless you do something to make it more even?
Go back to the very early days of automobiles, when they were so slow that a human runner would be faster. Then a new one comes along that can beat a human. The first car faster than a person!
Would you be amazed that machine has beaten man? Or would you say that it somehow doesn't count, because machine used more fuel than man? I'm pretty sure most people would not go for the second one.