5 ms·
Over the last few years I've settled on using NoScript. Mostly it was more for security or speed reasons; that it happened to block ads was just a happy side ef
by jerf 11y ago
Over the last few years I've settled on using NoScript. Mostly it was more for security or speed reasons; that it happened to block ads was just a happy side effect and often not one that I pursued very hard. For many sites, I'd end up with a page that had a couple of ads still on it, rather than a dozen ads plus a popover. The only time I've spent much cognitive bandwidth on getting rid of the ads is when the ads are being disgusting or half-pornographic. (It is not per se that I "disagree" with skin, it is that I hate the advertisers for deliberately trying to bypass my rational brain with those images. It's a hostile cognitive move on their part.)
But it's getting harder. More JS frameworks that depend on JS to render anything other than an empty white page. Then you whitelist that site, and it needs a couple of other domains to render anything. Then you're playing "guess which domain hosts the JS framework", which is not obvious, then you can also go back and play "unwhitelist the wrong answers", which since we're probably talking about a page that takes ten seconds to render and fifteen to be sure it didn't render when I blocked that site is quite a pain.
Also cloudfront is getting more popular, and that's all but an opaque domain now when it serves JS.
I'm getting seriously tempted to throw up my hands and do a serious adblock switch. I don't think using somebody else's list of domains is ethical, for various long and complicated reasons, but I'm finding myself having to balance that against the fact that the advertising industry doesn't seem all that worried about ethics at all, so I feel like I may be bringing an ethics knife to an ethics gun fight.
- blakesterz 11y agoI've finally given up on using NoScript! I used it for quite a while and finally just got sick of everything not working all the time. I think you're exactly correct, so much now depends on JS it just ends up that most every new site I went to was unusable.
- cronjobber 11y agoMaybe the day will come when NoScript allows me to catch up with the internet, but as it is, it remains essentially endless even with NoScript active.
- anexprogrammer 11y agoI've found Firefox reader mode can often give me the content when all scripts are still blocked. The blank page often still gives the reader icon :) For those that don't trigger reader mode I'm increasingly hard nosed and just start ignoring that domain. I'll not enable JS just to read an article or see some images, only when it adds functionality. Most of the time I don't need to - most sites work remarkably well with little or no JS, so I can afford not to care about those that don't. I'm very reluctant to enable anything that's not the visited domain. EDIT: uBlock+NoScript+Stylish almost always active.
- zeveb 11y ago> I've found Firefox reader mode can often give me the content when all scripts are still blocked. For some reason Iceweasel doesn't seem to display the reader icon. It's a bit of a nuisance …
- Esau 11y agoIs Reader even part of Iceweasel? I was under the impression that it was something that Mozilla licensed from a third party.
- SixSigma 11y agothrow Privoxy into the mix a non-caching web proxy with advanced filtering capabilities for enhancing privacy, modifying web page data and HTTP headers, controlling access, and removing ads and other obnoxious Internet junk. http://www.privoxy.org/ http://www.privoxy.org/