4 ms·
I think that you are talking past each other because you have different value systems. I've known plenty of people like dantheman before. They believe in and
by btilly 17y ago
I think that you are talking past each other because you have different value systems.
I've known plenty of people like dantheman before. They believe in and value the right to private property, which means believing that it is right to let other people do what you don't like with their private property. Add to that the belief that a personal business is private property, and you get the conclusion that no matter how much you personally dislike it, business owners "should" be allowed to discriminate.
By contrast if your belief in private property is not so absolute, then you're more willing to tolerate society restricting the free use of private property in ways that society does not like.
Different fundamental values leads to different conclusions. Even with agreement on the facts, the laws, and how bad discrimination is. And arguing "should not", "should too" back and forth will get you nowhere.
- jacquesm 17y agoMy house is my private property, I can invite whoever I want there, and can discriminate freely on sex, race and so on (not that I do, but I could) because the decision affects only me. A business is private property and I can hire whoever I want there, discriminating on factors such as suitability for the job, education and other associated factors. Religion, sex, skin colour and other personal attributes are not amongst those and for very good reason, discrimination on those grounds affects the other party economically, individually and as a group. In spite of all those rules there is enough workplace discrimination going on as it is, take those rules away and we're right back in the 1950's.
- codexon 17y agoA business is private property and I can hire whoever I want there, discriminating on factors such as suitability for the job, education and other associated factors. A couple decades ago, businesses in the US would have argued the same thing, claiming that Black and Hispanics are naturally lazier. Think about a company like Walmart, Ikea (or any company you frequent that has a near monopoly). How would you like it if they suddenly don't like your race and decided to stop selling to you or allowing you into their "private" stores that everyone else can shop at? Seeing how you come from a predominately white country, I can understand how you cannot conceive this to be a problem.
- btilly 17y agoI think you responded to the wrong person. jacquesm is the one who thinks businesses should not be allowed to discriminate. Incidentally you're wrong about the "couple of decades ago" timeline. The Civil Rights Act passed in 1964, and the Heart of Atlanta case of 1964 upheld its constitutionality, and the Ollie's BBQ case of 1967 upheld that it applied even to businesses with little obvious interstate commerce (this matters because Congress' authority to pass the Civil Rights Act stems from their ability to regulate interstate commerce). So the basic issues were litigated 40 years ago. That said, it is still depressingly easy to find people today who make the same arguments. They are just not legally allowed to act on them.
- codexon 17y agoWell I see that now in his other comments, but the phrasing of the comment I replied to wasn't quite right. Discrimination outside of businesses can still be immoral and affect minorities heavily. And last time I checked, a couple decades ago also includes 50 years ago.
- eds 17y agoWas the last time you checked thirty years ago?
- codexon 17y agoAre you seriously going to argue the definition of couple and getting 5 upvotes for being wrong? http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/couple http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/couple an indefinite small number : few <a couple of days ago> Hint: the phrase "a couple" does not always mean 2.
- jacquesm 17y agoI think it was phrased just right, there is no implication that discrimination outside of businesses can still be immoral and affect minorities heavily, it is just that for private dwellings these laws do not apply. You can like that or not but that's the way it is and it probably isn't going to change. A mans home is his castle, no matter how reprehensible his views. And that works both ways, you can't be forced to attend the birthday party of a white supremacist either. (personally I'd rather avoid such people completely, effectively discriminating against the minority of white supremacists). The discussion above has a 'scope', the scope is workplace discrimination. You can expand the scope but you can't expand it and declare a parent of the conversation of not addressing your expanded scope by poor phrasing at the same time.
- dantheman 17y agoI think you've hit the nail on the head. I wasn't being intentionally obtuse, I was just trying to state the case as clearly as I could and answer any objections/clarify any misconceptions. I agree often people fundamentally disagree about core issues, but it only manifests itself at higher levels. I hope we didn't jump into the "should not"/"should too" argument.